18

Feb

2009

Reuben Abati’s Immolating Silence PDF Print E-mail
By Sabella O Abidde
18 February 2009

From my own vantage point, the Nigerian public intellectual space is today dominated by four ringing voices: Sonala Olumhense, Levi Obijiofor, Okey Ndibe, and Reuben Abati. These are men with different styles, disparate worldview, and contrasting temperament. As dissimilar as they seem, they also seem similar in two ways: their single-minded pursuit of excellence, and their efforts towards our nation’s salvation and redemption.

 Professors Chinua Achebe, Wole Soyinka, Tam David-West and a few others are our national treasures and stand-alone institutions. When these men speak, we listen, we pay attention. Their pronouncements matters. And their declarations and submissions sometimes have religious whiff. In this regard, Abati, Ndibe, Obijiofor, and Olumhense are not far off the hallow corridors. Their pronouncements also matters. What we think of them matter, too.

 Collectively, we think the world of these men. And we generally hold them to higher ethical and moral standards. Their word means a lot; it carries considerable weight. They are not public officials, but, in so many ways, they have become communal property and have in the process given hope to the everyday Nigerians who are tired and disappointed of their country’s station and direction.

 Although Abati, Ndibe, Olumhense and Obijiofor could argue that they never went in search of such responsibility or accolade, still, that is where they are today. Their every words and gestures are observed; their every move and errands are scrutinized; and their writings are subject to and subjected to the magnifying glass every single time they write.

 Something else you should know: all four men are either employees or Alumnus of the Nigerian Guardian -- the great pontificator. Today, Reuben Abati sits on the editorial board of the Guardian from whence he sermonizes to the general public and public officials and other private and public institutions.

 He and the Guardian calls for transparency and accountability in government, and in public life; and also advocates liberalism and constitutionalism. Anyone whose job description involves calling for higher moral and ethical standards must be wiling to abide by such expectation. There cannot be one set of rule for the public and another set of rule for the pontificator. That would be hypocritical, and unhealthy for the society.

 Silence, for two decades now, has become part of Nigeria’s political culture as the rich and the powerful generally do not respond to accusations and queries from the general public. They are helped by the fact that (a) Nigeria has weak institutions; (b) Nigerians have very short memory; and (c) silence and cooperation can be bought. They are also helped by the fact that no public sanction or precedence-setting legal penalty will befall them. No one, it seems, is afraid of the law.

 Dr. Reuben Abati may not be guilty of anything. It is possible he has not committed any crime or ethical infractions. All the finger-pointing and the brouhaha may be much ado about zilch. Some of us may have been guilty of slander. We may have unjustly maligned him: calling him names, spreading rumors and innuendoes. We have no way of knowing if the man is guilty or innocent without the benefit of a court trial -- or some monumental and incontrovertible evidence.

 In the same vein, we have no way of knowing what really happened or didn’t happen. Few people know the truth, the whole truth and the incontrovertible truth. Mr. Abati is one such person. As it is, he is not saying a word about it. Not a word. At least not publicly. But the way I see, it is in his best interest to clarify things, to separate truth from rumors. And he should have done so within 72-hours of the matter becoming public. By saying nothing, he helped to fuel the rumor flame.

 Reuben Abati is no longer a private citizen, but a public figure. Also, he is not just a writer and a journalist, but one of the nation’s consciences: a truth teller. He is expected to tell the truth everyday and at every turn. His words means a lot to millions; and millions of Nigerians look up to him to fight for them. It is a huge responsibility to shoulder when people swear by what you say and do.

 Granted such expectation is colossal and may be thankless -- that is how millions of Nigerians have come to see him. That’s what they’ve come to expect. And of Ndibe, Obijiofor, and Olumhense. They are all brand names, names associated with truth telling.

 Abati may say he does not care what his critics say or think of him. True, he can dismiss the ranting of his enemies. In fact, he may even give the middle finger to people whom he feel are trying to pull him down. He can do and say a lot of things to his enemies and virulent critics. However, he cannot afford to ignore his friends and his supporters.

 He cannot afford to alienate “his own people:” the reading and viewing public. The reading and viewing public have stood by him for more than a decade. He has built and continues to build his base. To now want to help dismantle it, block by block, would be self-immolating. His silence -- his continue silence -- would be accomplishing exactly that. He does not want to go the way of some so-called intellectuals, leftists, socialists, communists, and comrades (most of who now roam the bedrooms of political boy-boys).

 I repeat: Reuben Abati should have vigorously responded to the news account from the veritable and trail setting SaharaReporters. And he should have done so within 72-hours of the matter becoming public. He didn’t. And because he didn’t -- after several weeks of ridiculing, cajoling, entreaties, and even threats -- whatever he says now will be greeted with cynicism, doubts, and got-ya kind of malicious claps. Still, he should go ahead! Silence, in this particular case, is not golden.

 He may never be able to convince everybody; still, he should give his side of the story. There are several reasons why he should: (1) because, as his organization reminds us, “conscience is an open wound only the truth can heal; (2) a truth-teller must, and should always be a truth-teller; (3) he will be helping to dismantle a culture of silence that has been eating at our country; and (4) all men of integrity and candor knows who they are. No amount of snide, derision, and doubt will make them “less of a man.”

 And finally, his continuing silence will make some people wonder; it will continue to fuel the rumor mills, and people may associate him with the jackasses and fuckups that roam the Nigerian cesspool. He may not think so, but a lot is at stake here.

 However, if Dr. Abati is “guilty as charged,” the effect will reverberate throughout our nation’s political space. Over all, it will not augur well for the few good men and few good women left in the country. History and posterity will frown on him. Either way, his silence may not last. The noise surrounding the alleged Abatilandgate may not go away quietly. In this moment, his continuing silence is self-immolating.

 But I wonder: what would Sonala Olumhense, Levi Obijiofor, and Okey Ndibe do if they were in Reuben Abati’s shoe? What would they do and say? I wonder…

 Sabidde@yahoo.com



Your Comments

Please make The Square an enjoyable experience for everyone by refraining from gratuitous ad-hominem contributions, defamatory comments and off-topic posting. Such posts will be removed.

User Avatar
RobotRobot is offline

 # 1 | 18.02.2009 08:21

From my own vantage point, the Nigerian public intellectual space is today dominated by four ringing voices: Sonala Olumhense, Levi Obijiofor, Okey Ndibe, and Reuben Abati. These are men with different styles, disparate worldview, and contrasting temperament. As dissimilar as they seem, they also seem similar in two ways: their single-minded pursuit of excellence, and their efforts towards our nation’s salvation and redemption. Professors Chinua Achebe, Wole Soyinka, Tam David-West and a few others are our national treasures and stand-alone institutions. When these men speak, we listen, we pay attention. Their pronouncements matters. And their declarations and submissions sometimes have religious whiff. In this regard, Abati, Ndibe, Obijiofor, and Olumhense are not far off the hallow corridors. Their pronouncements also matters. What we think of them matter, too. Collectively, we think the world of these men. And we generally hold them to higher ethi...Read the full article.

User Avatar
allaccessallaccess is offline

 # 2 | 18.02.2009 09:12

If you put your reputation on the line for someone like Abati you are taking a big risk, and believe me I have read Abati's articles more than a lot of people here and I tell you what you are doing is very very risky.

Abati is a man with power, the media is power and if that power is not used righteously and for the best interest of the people (regardless of fear and who's ox is gored) then that person is an untrustworthy person.

Reuben Abati is not Dele Giwa, and he will never come close. A man who writes for fear of losing a limb or face among the ruling elite and the powerful cabal of politicians operating contrary to the people, is not a man of conscience. Col. Abubakar Dangiwa Umar, a man who comes from a part of Nigerian I resent, has even done a better job than Mr Abati when it comes to telling the truth and damning the consequences.

Sabella, I hope you know what you are doing?

User Avatar
lifted1976lifted1976 is offline

 # 3 | 18.02.2009 09:22

My brother, Reuben Abati has responded though it came pretty late check Sahara Reporters

User Avatar
Ofunwa VillagerOfunwa Villager is offline

 # 4 | 18.02.2009 10:39

The interesting thing here is that you called Abati a truth teller and not with a quote. Maybe we should have called Obasanjo an honest, selfless President rather than the rogue that he is.
Abati is just like the rest of the media men/women in Nigeria, who scream through newspaper columns everyday, not because they expect the ruiners of the system to have a change of heart but because they seek the attension of the same ruiners.
The media in Nigeria is the direct opposite of what the media is in countries where the business of governance is done with sanity, where government is accountable to the people. In those climes, its not for governments or their
officials to err, the result would be imprisonment or resignation.
Ehud Olmert was forced out of the leadership race for Kadima party based on a yet to be proven allegation that a business man gave him 'envelop' when he was the mayor of Jerusalem. The Japanese finance minister is forced to resign for addressing a press conference 'drunk'.
Little allegations the lots in Nigeria will simply sweep under the carpet. Governors, presidents, ministers and lawmakers sleep around with girls so horribly young and underage, not in secrecy but before the naked glare of the press and such is hardly news for the Nigerian media.
State house reporters are daily treated to expensive banquet by the same person they are meant to monitor and report, they practically beg politicians for money and food and dish out favourable reports in return.
Can Abati swear before the shrine of Ogun that the Abuja land was the first ever gift the corrupt establishment in Nigeria ever used to buy his silence?

User Avatar
bakoso2000bakoso2000 is offline

 # 5 | 18.02.2009 11:07

Read Abati's reply to Abujalandgate. Report culled from Saharareporters.com

"Dr Reuben Abati Breaks His Silence "
Monday, 16 February 2009 10:33 By SOC Okenwa
I guess I should commence this rejoinder by confessing that the uproar raised by my 'involvement' in the Abuja land allocation by the ex-Minister Modibo to the EFCC strongwoman and others including top editors of my generation had pricked my conscience. For many decades I have been practising journalism (which has culminated in my reaching the zenith of the noble profession in the Guardian) I have never been associated with any scandal of this kind, one publicly revealed by an 'opposition' online news source, 'SaharaRaporters'. Of course Omoyele Sowore, my friend, and his anonymous reporters must have believed stumbling on a 'scoop' with the sole aim of tarnishing the good images of those mentioned in the so-called land 'deal' on their minds as they went about publishing same. I salute them all for their efforts and bear no grudges!

Watch the latest videos on YouTube.comLet me declare here without any equivocation that I am neither shocked nor perturbed by the furore the report has generated within Nigeria and elsewhere outside our shores thus far. Whoever thinks that I am having sleepless nights over the exposé is deceiving himself or herself. But I must say nevertheless that I never knew before now that I had many detractors cum 'enemies' who are now feeding fat over a non-issue. I decided to remain silent before now to be able to come to terms with the limits of people's anger and indignation and the capacity of man to over-reach himself in matters that ordinarily should not be his business.

If the former Minister of the FCT decided, in his sound judgement, to reward patriotic citizens like us who have the courage to remind government of their responsibilities and failings what is the fuss about that? Even if we fight against the ills of the society including corruption through our media outfits does that preclude us from receiving government's largesse? The land gift we received had no strings attached to it, so we shall continue to criticise where criticism is called for and commend where commendation becomes necessary. It is not everybody in government that is corrupt or evil. We have those we can safely brand as 'paragons' even when we have many of their opposites within!

Apart from my parents who sent me to school it is only the Ibru family and God that can demand for any personal account from me or my transaction with those wielding power, some of whom are my friends. It is therefore ludicrous for some mortals operating mainly in the internet to want to put me down. While some are seeking attention through my name others are unhappy about my journalistic excellence; I refused to dignify their rantings with a response but for some passionate appeals from well-meaning Nigerians at home and abroad.

In Nigeria we often hear of people working hard without a good pay packet. We often hear about pensioners dying while waiting for the peanuts they took home as pension. In a nation where millionaires and billionaires are churned out daily by hook or by crook it is strikingly baffling how people expect me not to join the bandwagon of the rich and powerful. Journalists the world over do their job for fame and reward. Some are stupendously rich by the strenght of their characters, connections and 'right deals'. Others are living fairly well and waiting for mother luck to smile on them.

I never bargained for any land with anybody but it is not good as an African (and above all as a Yoruba elite) to reject a gift given without any condition attached -- and if one was attached then it is not to my knowledge. When the ex-Minister released the list of the land allotees and my name was included my happiness knew no bounds. That meant that those in authorities recognised the sharpness of one's pen and the power of readership one wields as a national and international columnist.

The damage control measures I had smartly applied seems to have failed me spectacularly. The hard-core critics are not impressed and they are hardening up their positions of antagonism. By writing studiously about the scammers that had wanted to play a fast one on me and my friends, the police and their raped Queen, the 'goat-robber' of Ilorin, and the St. Valentine of love and lust I had sought to comically relieve my detractors of their frustrations. But they are not pacified, rather they have kept up the pressure asking probing questions about the Abuja land with my hard-earned reputation doing the Naira dance of fluctuation.

Is it a crime for prominent journalists to be officially recognised and rewarded for their patriotic contributions to national development? Is Olusegun Adeniyi not doing well as President Yar'Adua's spokesman? Or other journalists in the state capitals providing their loyal services to the 'oppressors' we had collectively condemned yesterday? Does common sense not dictate that if you cannot beat the system (or change same outrightly) you join the system? Why are people not minding their businesses?

The inglorious era of wretched journalists or poor journalism is gone for good! We do remember with pathetic nostalgia when journalists would go to Oshodi market for suit and shoes or struggle for apartment in Ajegunle with thugs ('Area Boys' if you like). Now we are proud owners of choice plots of land, bungalows; we ride in modern cars and buy our attires in the best boutiques in choice capitals of the West: London, Paris New York!

I sincerely wish to thank those brave internet warriors (apologies to Prof. Pat Utomi) for standing up on my behalf to the malicious critics seeking my downfall. Special mention goes to 'Tonsoyo', my defender-in-chief, for his remarkable capacity as an 'Abati-abater'. His resilience has impressed me very much indeed! His reward awaits him the moment he steps his feet on the Nigerian soil and signals his presence at Rutam House.

Please someone should tell the glorified holier-than-thou critics like Rudolf Okonkwo, SOC Okenwa, Taju Tijani, Wale Akin, Okpia Egbe, Osita Mba and others to wait for their own turn. Whenever government remembers them (as I have deservedly been remembered) and decides to give them their own plots of land I swear by my grand mother's grave never to do any commentary on that. I shall overlook that for other dramatic things happening daily in our great nation whose full potentials has never been realised.

To conclude I crave your indulgence friends and well-wishers far and near. My major concern here is not found in the controversy sorrounding my latest material acquisition. Rather my apprehension stems from the fact that by taking legal possession of the parcel of land in our federal capital city I should soon start putting up a befitting country home. However upon completion of the building one is worried that another crazy dimunitive FCT Minister in the mould of El-Rufai could be appointed and acting dutifully on petitions, demolition of the structure like that of our own 'Chemical' Ali could well set in; or another EFCC Chair like Ribadu replacing Mrs Waziri could happen and setting off an investigation of yours sncerely's precious gift in this regard.

I promise my faithful readers around the world one thing: I will be as critically analytical as before, as pungent as ever. I have neither 'sold out' to the oppressors nor allowed them to compromise my position against corruption, a cankerworm tearing down our national edifice. Remain mobilized everyone for the struggle ahead is a tasking one.

User Avatar
overdryvoverdryv is offline

 # 6 | 18.02.2009 11:18

I saw this piece about Abati breaking his silence two days ago on SR and wondered why it is not on NVS. I only hope Big-K would allow discussion on it. Abati main revelation which some of us have hinted, is that the land was a gift from the "hon." minister. This puts to rest insinuations by Abati defenders that he applied and paid for the land. In Nigeria one can fire on as anti corruption crusader after accepting a land gift from a very corrupt minister. This seems quite in place with any thing Nigerian.

User Avatar
busangabusanga is offline

 # 7 | 18.02.2009 12:16

At the minumum one will expect Sabella to tell us what Abati is accused of. Not one line in the article on what the accusations are? Sabella, please fill the information hole...not good enuf. Give us gist.

User Avatar
tonsoyotonsoyo is offline

 # 8 | 18.02.2009 12:18

Abati should respond to what please?:icon_ques :confused1

User Avatar
Ofunwa VillagerOfunwa Villager is offline

 # 9 | 18.02.2009 12:20

Did Abati contradict anything we 've saying all along? His defenders truly owe all of us an apology and come to think of it, there is one person among his defenders he forgot to thank, 'big K' sorry for the omission.

User Avatar
mathelizemathelize is offline

 # 10 | 18.02.2009 12:33


=tonsoyo;326947>Abati should respond to what please?:icon_ques :confused1



Land issue.
 

Services : E-mail news | RSS Feeds | Podcasts
Links:   About the NVS | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies | Advertise With Us
All Rights Reserved. NigeriaVillageSquare.com