Nigerian Citizenship Should Be Redefined NOW!

Written by Paul I. Adujie

Lawcreer2007@ aol.com

New York, United States

On Sunday, August 23, 2009, I read on the internet, a news report by one Mr. Samuel Aruwan reporting from Kaduna state in Nigeria. The news story related how full-fledged citizens of Nigeria, who were ordinarily resident in Lagos, were bundled and stripped of their properties and shipped from Lagos, by the government of Lagos state and then, deposited and dumped in Kaduna, just like that! This is an illegal act. It is an unconstitutional act, as it is equally immoral, and a very shameful and disgraceful act on the part of Lagos state.  I can only hope that no other state in Nigeria follows this extremely foolish and illegal act. As it is clearly a bad example!

First, upon reading this most ill-conceived action by Lagos state, I was thrown into a state of suspended disbelief. The governor of Lagos state is lawyer, a Senior Advocate of Nigeria at that! This is particularly surprising, because Mr. Fashola is lawyer and the action he sanctioned, is obviously unconstitutional and illegal and plainly immoral and unjustifiable! Mr. Fashola’s illegitimate action on this score, makes me wonder if he has misplaced his copy of the Nigerian constitution? How could a state governor order such action which flies in the face of decency, morality and constitutionality? Such an urbane governor as Mr. Fashola, a man who rather a very young politician? What informed this offensive and discriminatory act?

The illogicalities, the illegalities, the unconstitutionaliti es in every sense of these, made me at first to wonder, if this news story is untrue! How can a state actually do this without wide outrage and outcry nationwide in Nigeria? Where is censure and reprimand for this kidnapping engineered by a state in Nigeria? Are some Nigerians so warped and twisted now, in our sense of what is legal, fair, decent and moral? Are we now so far in a state of anomie and beyond shock? Are some Nigerians now so shockproof even from the debased and most profane of conducts by public officials? When did we stop being our brothers and sisters’ keeper? What in the world have happened to our psyche?

Nigerians should as the governor of Lagos state several questions to determine his “reasons” “rationale” for his decision to throw Molotov cocktails and live grenades into our already volatile state of national unity? Why did the governor, and government of Lagos state decide to act as flamethrowers against our country? I have lived in Lagos in the past and there was at that time, no physical fitness tests. No physical or fiscal inspections or determinations before a Nigerian could become a Lagosian, Lagos City used to be Nigeria’s New York City, Lagos welcomed all comers, all Nigerians. What changed? Why did Lagos engage in this opprobrium?

May Nigerians now be told, what the minimum income, and minimum wealth and minimum physical disability, which a Nigerian have to have to be accepted or tolerated as resident of Lagos state? What is the cutoff point, monetarily and in physical attributes for a Nigerian desirous of residency in Lagos? What is the litmus test of physical dexterity and fiscal suitableness for Nigerians citizens who desire to make Lagos state their home state, regardless of ethnicity or “state-of-origin”? There had been press reports suggesting that the governor of Lagos state, Mr. Fashola, had commenced a rebirth and rehabilitation of Lagos into the much talked about megacity or megalopolis. But cleaning and beautifying Lagos state or any state for that matter, certainly cannot be the poor excuse for abducting, kidnapping and bundling proven citizens of Nigeria, from whatever state of birth and dumping them outside of Lagos!

We know that money is tight in Lagos, in Nigeria and in fact, everywhere else in the world. But tight budget, tight finances cannot be the excuse, refusal or neglect by Lagos state to seek alternative solutions or other options to street begging! Lagos would have had support, if Lagos sought to rehabilitate beggars, Area Boys or the so-called street urchins, and as a consequence, Lagos created a shelter or even takes the extraordinary steps of creating a colony, for such purpose within Lagos state. Even so, it would be possible that some may see such measures as drastic, if draconian. But, here we are faced with a much worse and much more drastically senseless abductions and kidnapping of some Nigerians as a policy of a unit of government in my federal republic! Tufia! Haba Lagos!

If these citizens had swine flu or some other disease determined to be contagious, even at that, no state government should abduct, kidnap and expel Nigerians from one state to the other. If infected persons or even livestock must be quarantined, such confinements must be undertaken within the state of established presence of such infected persons or livestock. Bundling and expelling Nigerian citizens should never be contemplated by any sane Nigerian! This is class warfare too. This is class discrimination this is a unique discrimination against Nigerians with disabilities. There ought to be a law against all discriminations, but, more particularly so, laws to punish those who would engage in the egregious discriminations of all, against disable people who are not able to fend for themselves!  The “crimes” of these citizens of Nigeria, “deported” by Lagos state, is that they are poor and, on top of it, they have the misfortunes to be disabled or have disabilities. Would Lagos state or any state deport Dangote, Otedola or Iwuchukwu whether they were blind or quadriplegics on wheelchairs? No! They would react, Naira for Naira! And with 100 Senior Advocates of Nigeria representing them.

Too much unpalatable news emanates from Nigeria and this dastardly act by Lagos state is just rank –rancid wrong-headed public policy! As I understand it, the governor of Lagos state is a lawyer, a nice urbane Nigerian, who is said to have done a lot for Lagos. Those accomplishments, if they are sustainable and not mere cosmetic, warrant the applause of all Nigerians. But now does this? Common!

All Nigerians must take strong exceptions, the strongest exceptions, to the malevolent treatments by Lagos state, meted out to bona fide citizens of Nigeria. Any citizen of Nigeria should have the right to live where ever whichever part of Nigeria such Nigerian citizen chooses and prefers. And such choice should be left to such Nigerian citizen regardless of wealth, health, ethnicity, state or region of origin or religion. Once a Nigerian has established proof of his citizenship, where he chooses to live should not be a discussable transaction by any branches of our government, be it local, state or federal. No state, Lagos or Plateau or Edo or Anambra should tell me where I can live within Nigeria! Lagos must not get away with this unconstitutionality and illegality, just so, no other state may in the future engage in this sorts of mindlessness of the unhinged. Lagos should be fined. Governors who discriminate should be impeached and removed from office! This is because these sorts actions endanger Nigeria’s national security and national unity and cohesion. It is treasonable to endanger our national security. What if Kaduna retaliates and uses whatever criterion Kaduna may chose? Deport every college graduate from Lagos who lives in Kaduna? Or deport any Lagosian in Kaduna who weighs over 200 kilograms?

I am thoroughly embarrassed that there are some people here applauding the Lagos state government! Lagos should be ASHAMED! Those poor citizens deserve better than that from Lagos state and every other state in Nigeria… and from the federal government too! A citizen of Nigeria is a citizen of Nigeria is a citizen of Nigeria! A citizen of Nigeria should be free to live where ever she chooses! It is irrelevant whether such Nigeria is a billionaire or destitute!

The illegal and unconstitutional action by Lagos state against some citizens of Nigeria is most unwarranted. It is discrimination and there is simply no excuse. Clearly, it is unacceptable that Lagos is discriminating against some Nigerian citizens on the bases of ethnicity, state and region of origin and on the basis of disability and wealth! There is nothing to be said in favor of Lagos state! 

NOTHING! The Federal Executive Council or FEC should table Lagos for discussion, for censure and reprimand for this offensive and discriminatory act.

"Deportation" of Nigerians by some other Nigerians should be condemned by all of us. That act on the part of Lagos state, my Eko Akete, surely smacks of elitism in particular reference to the stations in life and wealth and disability of the Nigerians who we talk about here.

A good society, with human refinement, is judged or measured by how such society treats/handles/ deals with her under-privileged citizens. Lagos state has just failed this acid test!

Citizenship in Nigeria should not be a fleeting and an ephemeral thing! My Nigerian citizenship should entitle me to equal protection in every of Nigeria's 36 federating states, and the Federal Capital Territory inclusive.  I have in the past written that “Nigerian Citizenship Should Be Redefined” which was published onFriday, 18 June 2004 http://www.nigeriav illagesquare. com/...redefined .html

 But with this act by Lagos state, and the unrests in Plateau a couple of years ago, then the bloodletting which followed the Boko Haram extremism accompanied by gory violence, there is now no better time for Nigeria’s National Assembly to swing to action, amend the constitution, to define citizenship of Nigeria, as among other things, a citizen of Nigeria is a citizen of the locality and state, which such Nigerian has adopted and where such Nigerian has lived in, meaningful and where such Nigeria may choose and such Nigerian has demonstrated and indicated, whether she is Adamu, Bola or Chima!

And this, definition should be regardless of whether Adamu’s grandparents were originally from Kaduna as Adamu has chosen Lagos as his home state, from where he can be the best Nigerian he can be. This will be regardless of whether Bola parents or grandparent are originally from Ondo, and now, Bola has adopted Yobe state as her home state, Yobe would suffice for Bola. And Chima should be free to create wealth, health and happiness in Ogbomosho, regardless of the fact that his grandparents and parents were originally from Nnewi or Oguta. A Nigerian’s home state should be where he chooses. Where she reside etc Nigerian citizenship should be tenable everywhere in Nigeria. It should not be fleetingly flimsy!

Robot  # 1 | 24.08.2009 19:18

...Read the full article.

LoveNigeria  # 2 | 24.08.2009 21:04

Baloney!! Nigeria was never a nation to begin with -all those fancy arguments are just moot. We can pretend all we want. Rule of law -pleeeaasse!! We don't even get to elect our leaders -they choose them for us. Fashola did the right thing, let everyone cater for their own. Why should Fashola shoulder the responsibilities of the Federal government and those irresponsible Sharia governors and elites in the North ? The Sharia governors introduced sharia without an effective rehabilitation on ground !! If the state is going to cut off a man's hand the state should also provide something for him to do to eat -that's just common sense. But instead Lagos is now flooded with these eyesore Sharia beggars. Common give Fashola a break !!

RoyalPalm  # 3 | 24.08.2009 22:05

Especialy that some of these beggars have no other home than Lagos as they have been in Lagos for generations imemorial. BRF is alone on this one, wait until the next line of action gets implemented. This reminds me of the Prime Minister who said he does not do God, his status changed swiftly!

valteena  # 4 | 25.08.2009 08:30

=>But with this act by Lagos state, and the unrests in Plateau a couple of years ago, then the bloodletting which followed the Boko Haram extremism accompanied by gory violence, there is now no better time for Nigeria’s National Assembly to swing to action, amend the constitution, to define citizenship of Nigeria, as among other things, a citizen of Nigeria is a citizen of the locality and state, which such Nigerian has adopted and where such Nigerian has lived in, meaningful and where such Nigeria may choose and such Nigerian has demonstrated and indicated, whether she is Adamu, Bola or Chima! And this, definition should be regardless of whether Adamu’s grandparents were originally from Kaduna as Adamu has chosen Lagos as his home state, from where he can be the best Nigerian he can be. This will be regardless of whether Bola parents or grandparent are originally from Ondo, and now, Bola has adopted Yobe state as her home state, Yobe would suffice for Bola. And Chima should be free to create wealth, health and happiness in Ogbomosho, regardless of the fact that his grandparents and parents were originally from Nnewi or Oguta. A Nigerian’s home state should be where he chooses. Where she reside etc Nigerian citizenship should be tenable everywhere in Nigeria. It should not be fleetingly flimsy! Absolutely right. Should be the ideal situation but is unfortunately not as we've seen time and time again. There is so much about that country of ours that needs to be redifined, renegotiated and re whatever honestly.

I Love Nigeria  # 5 | 25.08.2009 09:25

LoveNigeria? Just Lagos? You wrote, among other things, that: ……and those irresponsible Sharia governors and elites in the North ? ….But instead Lagos is now flooded with these eyesore Sharia beggars. Common give Fashola a break !! Your brain is not firing full throttle or is it? In your argument, Sharia cause people to be quadruplegic? Sharia cause people to be crippled and have disabilities? In fact, Sharia is the cause of abject poverty in Nigeria? Mr. LoveNigeria/only Lagos? I say :no::no::no::no: You need to seen a brain surgeon, if you really think what you have stated above! AND, Yes Valteena, a redefinition is crucially important. We should debate/negotiate. Even if we have to hold our noses during such negotiations. The benefits of Nigerian unity outweighs the perils of Nigeria's possible disintegration! Nigeria is an imperfect union, that much we know and it is hereby conceded.

tonsoyo  # 6 | 25.08.2009 09:52

Nigeria citizenship is properly defined as it is, it needs no redefinition. It is you that needs to brush up your knowledge of the law. The Nigerian Constitution recognizes both State and National citizenships. Every Nigerian has a right to RESIDE in any part of the country of his choice, not a right to LIVE under bridges, public parks, streets etc. Residency by all legal and grammatical definition connotes a home with an address. You are not availed of that right when: You do not a have residence - you cannot reside - common sense, I THINK You constitute yourself a safety and health hazard when you have to ease, bath and let-off the "major" in public places You constitute yourself a public nuisance by constantly obstructing the free flow of traffic or deprived others of the quiet enjoyment of their own homes, like the residents of Kano Street in Ebute-Metta Lagos. You have become a public charge, because you do not have any visible means of livelihood. You are not residing in that state because it is your state of choice, within the contemplation of the Constitution, but in furtherance of a crime of slavery and obtaining under false pretences. Most of these beggars are that, and more. Good riddance to stinking rubbish. GO FASHOLA!!! YOU ARE THE BEST!!!

I Love Nigeria  # 7 | 25.08.2009 10:14

tonsoyo you a spouting emotions and giving it the coloration of Nigerian constitution and laws? Hogwash! The constitution of Nigeria does not use income or property ownership as a means test or litmus test to determine freedom of movement and freedom to reside in any of the federating states in Nigeria, including the federal capital territory of Abuja. The issue here is simple. Lagos state unconstitutionally and illegally, remove bona fide citizens of Nigeria, from Lagos, the preferred abode of these citizens of our republic. This is a violation of the Fundamental Human Rights and Mr. Fashola and Lagos deserve censure and reprimand from all of us for this opprobrium! Read Below this poverty argument, as I see it. Because state of origin, is an accident of birth and not a choice any Nigerian made. You were born in Lagos into opulent wealth of caviar, wine and even champagne? Me? I was born in Kaduna into destitution of Almajiri life You could have been born into destitution in Kaduna yourself, as I was! You are wealthy and I am poor God bless rich and poor Nigerians Nobody I know likes life on shoe strings budget or finances You could have been born in Kaduna just as I was.... Most of you here talk about these beggars, albeit, fellow humans, fellow Nigerians... you talk about them in devalued human life terms... which is what most people accuse governments in Nigeria, at every strata, of equally devaluing and demeaning the human dignity of Nigerian citizens... so, how are you guys here different from the political elite? You guys devalue these poor beggars, in order to dismiss them as non-humans deserving none of your love, attention or care! That is not the Nigeria that I want or that we all should want.

tonsoyo  # 8 | 25.08.2009 11:10

=I Love Nigeria;383605>tonsoyo you a spouting emotions and giving it the coloration of Nigerian constitution and laws? Hogwash! The constitution of Nigeria does not use income or property ownership as a means test or litmus test to determine freedom of movement and freedom to reside in any of the federating states in Nigeria, including the federal capital territory of Abuja. The issue here is simple. Lagos state unconstitutionally and illegally, remove bona fide citizens of Nigeria, from Lagos, the preferred abode of these citizens of our republic. This is a violation of the Fundamental Human Rights and Mr. Fashola and Lagos deserve censure and reprimand from all of us for this opprobrium! Read Below this poverty argument, as I see it. Because state of origin, is an accident of birth and not a choice any Nigerian made. You were born in Lagos into opulent wealth of caviar, wine and even champagne? Me? I was born in Kaduna into destitution of Almajiri life You could have been born into destitution in Kaduna yourself, as I was! You are wealthy and I am poor God bless rich and poor Nigerians Nobody I know likes life on shoe strings budget or finances You could have been born in Kaduna just as I was.... Most of you here talk about these beggars, albeit, fellow humans, fellow Nigerians... you talk about them in devalued human life terms... which is what most people accuse governments in Nigeria, at every strata, of equally devaluing and demeaning the human dignity of Nigerian citizens... so, how are you guys here different from the political elite? You guys devalue these poor beggars, in order to dismiss them as non-humans deserving none of your love, attention or care! That is not the Nigeria that I want or that we all should want. ILN, This is not suppose to be an emotional argument but legal (since you are a Lawyer) and common sense argument. I am NOT using "income" or "property" as measurements either, what I have done is to use the ONLY reasonable grammatical, common sensical and legal definition of the word "RESIDE" emplyed by the crafters of the Constitution. But you keep on with this emotional hyperventilation. You do not need to have an income or own a property to meet the definition of "reside" millions of residents in Lagos do not have both, what are you talking about? Our courts are courts of law, not courts of emotion or Oprah Winfrey Show, where you go to show how much oppressed you have been to draw public sympathy. FYI, I was not born into opulence or whatever you are imagining. I was born into an average family and many times went to school in torn shoes. So quit pandering to emotion, it won't work with me.

I Love Nigeria  # 9 | 25.08.2009 11:26

tonsoyo No pandering here, not from ILN! When you insist that citizens should be deported because they do not have evidences of livelihoods, WHAT exactly are you insinuating and alluding to? You are emphatic in your income-means-and property tests! and you have done so innumerably. There is no wiggle room for you on this score. How many Nigerian millionaires live under bridges and public parks? tonsoyo, wrote the following, and more!: The Nigerian Constitution recognizes both State and National citizenships. Every Nigerian has a right to RESIDE in any part of the country of his choice, not a right to LIVE under bridges, public parks, streets etc. Residency by all legal and grammatical definition connotes a home with an address. You are not availed of that right when: You do not a have residence - you cannot reside - common sense, I THINK You constitute yourself a safety and health hazard when you have to ease, bath and let-off the "major" in public places You constitute yourself a public nuisance by constantly obstructing the free flow of traffic or deprived others of the quiet enjoyment of their own homes, like the residents of Kano Street in Ebute-Metta Lagos. You have become a public charge, because you do not have any visible means of livelihood.

I Love Nigeria  # 10 | 25.08.2009 11:40

tonsoyo is responsible for what is written below... the highlighted parts are my queries to tonsoyo in response Residency by all legal and grammatical definition connotes a home with an address. You are not availed of that right when: (ILN asks tonsoyo, does any Nigerian citizen choose not to have address, given the means to do so?) You do not a have residence - you cannot reside - common sense, I THINK You constitute yourself a safety and health hazard when you have to ease, bath and let-off the "major" in public places You constitute yourself a public nuisance by constantly obstructing the free flow of traffic or deprived others of the quiet enjoyment of their own homes, like the residents of Kano Street in Ebute-Metta Lagos. You have become a public charge, because you do not have any visible means of livelihood. (ILN says to tonsoyo, “Visible-means” means income and property (financial ability) All of the above represent your thought processes and the core of your argument so far. They are self-explanatory, requires no constructions/interpretations. The primary meanings of what you have written, are succinctly clear to everyone here… even Stevie Wonder can see through you!

---

The conversation continues in our forum. Click here to read all comments

---