Home
Kano-Nigeria Versus Pfizer Pharmaceuticals PDF Print E-mail
Written by Paul Adujie   
Friday, 15 June 2007
Kano-Nigeria Versus Pfizer Pharmaceuticals
By Paul I. Adujie
Lawcareer2007@aol.com
New York, United States
 
 
 
Pfizer used innocent Nigerian children in Kano to conduct an inhumane and barbaric tests of Pfizer’s unapproved and unproven drug, Trovan. Pfizer in clear violations of well established pharmacological protocols, proceeded to kill and maim our children in Kano Nigeria. Pfizer committed willful, criminal medical negligence against Nigerian children, as Pfizer conducted illegal, fraudulent and unethical clinical trials in Nigeria, evidences show.
 
Pfizer’s crimes against innocent Nigerian children and humanity are indefensible! Quite honestly, I find anyone who tries to defends Pfizer with trite public statements, as equally, as disgusting and dismaying, as Pfizer itself. In May 2006, The Washington Post newspapers wrote a very compelling and equally very revealing article, about Pfizer’s criminal acts, in Nigeria, an article written by Joe Stephens a Staff Writer with The Washington Post, published after a year-long investigation into overseas pharmaceutical testing. And now, suddenly, we have a shameless Nigerian trying to become an apologist for Pfizer? Despite all the facts and evidences? Despite evidence of Pfizer’s reckless disregard, for the lives of innocent Nigerian children, who Pfizer killed for profits?
 
A shameless Nigerian Pfizer apologist, is joining Pfizer to insult Nigerians and Nigeria, insult the memory of 11 dead Nigerian children. He insults the parents of the dead children and the very many children who were maimed as consequence of Pfizer’s egregious crimes! A shameless Nigerian, is volunteering defense for Pfizer, even as an American journalist and his newspaper, have detailed the magnitude of Pfizer’s criminality in Kano! Why would this shameless Nigerian, engage in these gratuitous insults to Nigeria? with his free defense of Pfizer, while an American lawyer Elaine Kusel with the law firm of Milberg Weiss, Bershad & Schulman, only have strong most critical words reserve for Pfizer; And she, and her law firm, have spent several years pursuing Pfizer on behalf of 30 Nigerians families, victims of Pfizer’s crimes.
 
Professor Dora Akunyili of NAFDAC, has also clearly stated, that Pfizer did not have the authority, before it engaged in its criminal enterprise, involving the lives of Nigerian children!11 Nigerian children are dead, so many other Nigerian children are maimed, as a direct result of Pfizer’s wrong-doing, why would any Nigerian call this, anything else, but, high crimes by Pfizer, for profits, profits, at the expense of Nigerian children!
 
Why would a Nigerian, shamelessly volunteer defense, for Pfizer? despite the public information and knowledge, as published by the Washington Post, information, to the effect that, the American authorities specifically informed Pfizer not to use the medicine on children, and so, the US FDA, never approved Trovan for treating American children! There is also, the additional, publicly available information, as to the liver damage and deaths associated with Trovan in adult Americans when it was used? Which led the FDA to severely restrict Trovan, according to the Washington Post. Or the fact that Trovan, the Pfizer drug in question, is completely banned by regulators in Europe. 
 
Pfizer is the world’s largest pharmaceutical company. Pfizer knows what the laws and ethical standards are. Pfizer is completely familiar with standard protocols, for clinical trials, Pfizer is not an upstart pharmaceutical company. Pfizer, in complete disregard for the value and worth, of the lives of our children in Kano, engaged in Tuskegee-like illegal experiments, with humans, as if lab rats. Pfizer’s only focus was the bottom line. Profits and more profits! Pfizer conducted its unethical experiments on our children, without the requisite informed consent, and without first obtaining regulatory approvals and or, authorization, from Nigeria’s appropriate authorities and agencies. Pfizer exploited innocent children for profits! Trovan grossed more than a billion dollars a year!
 
Pfizer, and all pharmaceutical and medical research entities on earth, are familiar with, The Belmont Report; The Helsinki Declaration; The Tuskegee Institute Syphilis Experiment
 
Pfizer’s criminal acts, and violations in Nigeria, were in clear violation of Nigerian laws, international laws and the international conventions or Declaration of Helsinki that governs ethical medical research, and the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child.
 
Those who  are writing favorable opinions for Pfizer, and attempting to shift blames,  blames, that rests squarely, on Pfizer’s corporate shoulders, should be ashamed of themselves. And unlike those  shameless self-seeking, conniving commentators, who are rushing to defend Pfizer and asking Pfizer to contact them, the only advice I have for Pfizer is to tell it, that, it is in a massive legal, ethical and huge corporate image mess!
 
How can any Nigerian shamelessly defend Pfizer, after it killed Nigerian children? And according to The Washington Post, an American Congressman, Tom Lentos a senior Democrat from the state California, described Pfizer’s criminal acts in Nigeria as, "absolutely appalling" Congressman Lantos also demanded, that Pfizer open its records for thorough scrutiny. Congressman Lantos, according to Washington Post, described Pfizer’s criminal acts in Nigeria, as "outrageous" even as I wonder why any Nigerian would conclude otherwise, despite all the available facts and evidences of Pfizer’s crimes?
 
The Foods and Drugs Administration or FDA, an American regulatory body, requires pharmaceutical companies and others, who are sponsors or are conducting medical research overseas, and seeking approval from the FDA, to show proofs that such overseas tests, have been reviewed in advance by regulatory authorities or ethics committee, in such overseas location of research. Pfizer neither sought nor received such review in Nigeria. Pfizer was in, all round, noncompliance, in Nigeria and in America! Pfizer was malicious and calculating, all for Pfizer’s only focus and concerns, profits, profits and more profits!
 

Pfizer killed Nigerian children for corporate profits. As Pfizer ignored all laws, ethics and industry standard practices. Pfizer engaged in the most egregious violations, as it engaged in its unconscionable experiments with the lives of Nigerian children. We must tell Pfizer that its criminal acts against innocent Nigerians children, stinks to high heavens!
 
The rest of the world must join Nigerians and Nigeria, in telling Pfizer that it is evil, to put corporate profit above and beyond, the sanctity of human life. Pfizer killed our children and that is wrong in every continent and in every culture and wrong in every climes!
 
Pfizer, in conducting its clinical trials in Kano, Nigeria, jettisoned and abandoned the medical gold standard, as Pfizer tampered with and tinkered with, every immutable acceptable clinical protocols. Pfizer conducted its trials on our children, against an active comparator. There are indications that Pfizer actually reduced the dosages of medicines, for children not on Pfizer’s experimental and unproven drug Trovan. This is criminal!
 
Pfizer caused the death of children who were being subjected to their unproven drug, just as Pfizer induced the deaths of our children who were not being treated with Pfizer’s drug! Pfizer exercised arbitrary, capricious and unfettered powers, over our children in Kano!
 
There is an outcome of investigations of Pfizer’s criminal activities in Nigeria, investigations by Nigerian medical professionals, which is very revealing and mind-numbingly painful. There are disclosures that Pfizer, for profits, deliberately conducted illegal and criminal clinical trials, in breach of all basic medical ethics, and standard protocols, that are known and observed worldwide. Pfizer chose profits, over the lives of Nigerian children. Pfizer’s misconducts, highlights the historical and persistence devaluation of African lives by non-Africans.
 
This devaluation and worthlessness that they have ascribed and attached to African lives, enabled slavery and enabled colonialism, without qualms; it also enabled the infamous Tuskegee Experiment, in which people of African descent in America, who suffered Syphilis, were deliberately left to die or maimed, as a kangaroo experiment went on, authorized by the American government.
 
This revelation of Pfizer’s criminal conduct in Kano Nigeria, should lead the world to re-examine and do a rethink, about the origin of AIDS, Ebola and such other epidemics. Pfizer’s illegal, fraudulent and unethical behavior in Nigeria, should cause Africans, and indeed, the whole world, to beam a searing searchlight on pharmaceutical companies. And oil companies, who brazenly pollute our environment, as the bilk billions of dollars!
 
The world should wonder aloud, whether pharmaceutical companies "manufacture" diseases for profits? The whole world should examine whether new and unexplained epidemics are consequence of unauthorized and unsupervised medical and pharmacological experiments? The world should be asking Pfizer and others like it, whether new and unexplained diseases, some of them drug resistant, are a creation of some pharmaceutical companies?
 
Could AIDS and Ebola be consequences of unauthorized and unsupervised clinical trials gone haywire, which induced mutations multiplied by mutations? In the past, I would have dismissed this line of thinking as conspiracy theory. But knowing what I know now, knowing that the largest multinational pharmaceutical company as Pfizer, killed and murdered children in Nigeria for profit, it is no longer far-fetched to think that, if Pfizer can kill innocent Nigerian children for profit, nothing is, most probably, beyond Pfizer! It is all coming together now, its all plausible now. Some companies will do, anything for profits!
 
A couple of years ago, an American judge dismissed a suit, brought against Pfizer, by a New York City law firm, which represents 30 Nigerian families, all, victims of Pfizer’s criminal acts, which killed and maimed so many innocent Nigerian children. The American judge claimed that his court did not possess jurisdiction or power to hear the case, the law firm in New York, is appealing that verdict. American courts have not lacked jurisdiction over Nigerians and Nigeria in the recent pasts! Especially in politically motivated cases to ridicule Nigeria?
 
But let us examine that verdict, I am familiar with several court proceedings against Nigeria, in American courts in New York, Chicago and Washington DC etc and these law suits, are over events and incidents that transpired in Nigeria. Several of these cases have been concluded, with the American courts clearly assuming and exercising jurisdiction over Nigerians and Nigeria, these, even though, the transactions and occurrences, were in Nigeria, and mostly between Nigerians in Nigeria.
 
Nigeria’s former head of state, Abubakar Adulsalami, was sued by Chief Enahoro and others, in Chicago, the issues being litigated in that suit, arose from the actions and omissions by the former head of state, during the tenure of Abdulsalami as head of state.
 
All parties to this suit are Nigerians resident in Nigeria. The American courts, have assumed jurisdiction in this, and other cases, involving Nigerians resident in Nigeria.
 
In particular, a Nigerian head of state or president has immunity from prosecution for actions undertaken in that behalf as head of state of Nigeria. Such Nigerian head of state, additionally, enjoys diplomatic immunity, all these, notwithstanding, American courts have assumed jurisdiction and have made vexatious pronouncements against Nigeria’s former head of state. Allowing some Nigerian politicians to make hay and political mileage, out of such law suits. This insults Nigeria, at least in my opinion.
 
Now, suddenly, an American court in New York, has refused to assumed jurisdiction to enable Nigerians litigate and establish their Human Rights, which were violated by Pfizer.
 
A UN Convention forbids and prohibit these sorts of criminal acts, in which Pfizer indulged itself in, in Nigeria, actions that killed innocent Nigerian children.
 
Pfizer also violated American laws, an American law that requires American corporations, sponsors of overseas medical research, to first obtain review committee, medical, ethical committees, approvals, prior to engaging in such research abroad, this, Pfizer did do or comply with, in Pfizer’s criminally negligent malpractices in Kano Nigeria. Pfizer is in wholesale violations of Nigerian laws, American laws, International laws, international conventions and protocols. Pfizer is in violation of  every basic medical, ethical, standards and in violations of rules, Pfizer is violations of, even decency and common sense!
 
An American court in New York suddenly lack jurisdiction over Pfizer’s crimes in Nigeria? Could this be because the devalued and worthless lives of Africans are the subject of the litigation? Are the lost lives in question so devalued, worthless and meaningless to some? Is a this refusal to assume jurisdiction merely because a giant multinational company in America would be compelled to account and be made responsible for its criminal acts?
 
Is Pfizer above the law? Is Pfizer too important to be made to account to Nigerians?
 



RobotRobot is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 1

Pfizer, and all pharmaceutical and medical research entities on earth, are familiar with, The Bel...Read the full article.

Posted by Robot| 16.06.2007 07:11

Reply Quote



Mikky jagaMikky jaga is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 2

Paul! Paul!! Thou speakest in parables!!!

Who is this "shameless Nigerian apologist" that is defending Pfizer? Please, with immediate effect, tell me his name and address, and in the spirit of patriotism, I am ready to call fire on his head.

Please, for the sake of those who are not aware, let your readers into what the man said, then we can join you in condemning what is obviously wrong.

Posted by Mikky jaga| 16.06.2007 11:31

Reply Quote



AuspiciousAuspicious is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 3

Hi, Mikky Jagga!

I'd like to know who this person is too - or why Paul is 'protecting' him or her. So Paul, pray, tell us who it is so that we don't start running to conclusions about the motive behind this latest piece from you.

Merci,

Auspicious.

Posted by Auspicious| 16.06.2007 11:51

Reply Quote



I Love NigeriaI Love Nigeria is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 4

Mikky Jagga and Auspicious, I did not want the focus to be on the Nigerian in question.

My article raised serious charges/issues ... how come the focus is on one person's comment?

The issues here are not about me or the commentator that I had criticized! The issues are about Nigerian children who were murdered, killed and maimed by Pfizer and I tried to relate that to the general lack of corporate good citizenship and corporate responsibility>>>>particularly<<<< when Nigerians or Africans are concerned
The issues here are grave, it would be nice for us to focus on those issues and especially Pfizer's criminal actions!

Well, here for the voyeur in all of us....

http://www.gamji.com/article6000/NEWS7096.htm To identify those who might be helpful to Pfizer solve this matter, they may contact the writer for advice. Please, don’t misunderstand my intendments, it’s just that there’s something smelly and fishy about this lawsuit brought this late, especially, 11 years after the incident, and besides, the Islamic community from Nigeria are not known to seek benefit from acts of disaster, especially when Allah’s wish has prevailed, and that was the main reason why no autopsy was conducted


Armtwisting Of Pfizer In Nigeria

To identify those who might be helpful to Pfizer solve this matter, they may contact the writer for advice. Please, don’t misunderstand my intendments, it’s just that there’s something smelly and fishy about this lawsuit brought this late, especially, 11 years after the incident, and besides, the Islamic community from Nigeria are not known to seek benefit from acts of disaster, especially when Allah’s wish has prevailed, and that was the main reason why no autopsy was conducted

Posted by I Love Nigeria| 16.06.2007 13:55

Reply Quote



I Love NigeriaI Love Nigeria is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 5

A detailed WASHINGTON POST .... INDEPTH INVESTIGATIVE REPORT BY JOSEPH STEPHENS

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/05/06/AR2006050601338_pf.html

Posted by I Love Nigeria| 16.06.2007 19:51

Reply Quote



AuspiciousAuspicious is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 6

ILN:

Trust me, I don't think anyone in his right senses will underestimate the seriousness of the issue involving Pfizer and the Kano State Government.

But as far as the content of your article reveals, the focus was on the Nigerian/s who offered legal services to Pfizer in the case brought against it by the Government of Kano.

The first few words of your article addressed the issue of this Nigerian/s who defend Pfizer..and you went further to justifiably excoriate them throughout the rest of your piece.

Somehow, I suspect this (the idea of a Nigerian defending Pfizer) is a rouse on your part to garner attention. I however apologize if I am wrong.

Auspicious.

Posted by Auspicious| 16.06.2007 20:06

Reply Quote



mulanmulan is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 7

Pfizer should be brought to book if the trial can show that they were actually wrong which IMHO they are. In the case they have bribed or been fooled and blackmailed by any Nigerian, in or out of government, they should fess up or face the music.

As for that writer that wants them to contact him, he is a shameless fortune hunter and a traitor to his country.

Why must some people see a negative conspiracy theory in everything involving Obasanjo and even in this case where the conclusion is to the disadvantage of poor put upon nigerians?

Posted by mulan| 16.06.2007 20:23

Reply Quote



I Love NigeriaI Love Nigeria is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 8

He is Mr. Mazi S. I. Ohuabunwa section 3.7.3 of the report.The frigthening thing, is this guy is a 'Pharmacist' and very dangerous as a person

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/05/06/AR2006050601338_pf.html

The FDA never approved Trovan for use in treating American children. After being cleared for adult use in 1997, the drug quickly became one of the most prescribed antibiotics in the United States. But Trovan was later associated with reports of liver damage and deaths, leading the FDA to severely restrict its use in 1999. European regulators banned the drug.

After The Post published its report, Nigeria's health minister at the time, Tim Menakaya, appointed a blue-ribbon panel of medical experts to look into Pfizer's actions, saying, "Let me assure you that my ministry will take all necessary steps to obtain details of this incident and make them known to the general public." The committee collected hundreds of documents and interviewed at least 26 people.

Pfizer had told authorities that a Nigerian doctor directed the experiment. The committee, however, found that researchers from Pfizer's U.S. office controlled the trial, and the inexperienced Kano doctor, Abdulhamid Isa Dutse, was the principal investigator "only by name."

Publications listed Dutse as the lead author of articles on Trovan, but the committee found that depiction "did not sufficiently reflect his role." Dutse indicated he was kept in the dark about the experiment's results and said he did not see at least one publication until the committee showed it to him.

"He was shocked that Pfizer could publish such data without showing him or intimating him with details," the report said, concluding that Dutse was "naive and exploited."

The report quoted Dutse as saying that Pfizer's motive was far from philanthropic.

"I have trusted people and am disappointed," Dutse told the committee. "I regret this whole exercise, I wonder why on earth I did this."

Dutse admitted that he created a letter after the experiment purporting to show that the test had been approved in advance by a Nigerian hospital's ethics committee. He then backdated the letter to March 28, 1996 -- a week before Pfizer's experiment began.

Pfizer used the letter as a key justification for the trial in discussions with reporters and submitted it to the FDA. U.S. regulations require the sponsors of foreign medical research seeking FDA approval to show that the tests have been reviewed in advance by an ethics committee.

The Post previously reported that the hospital had no ethics committee in March 1996 and that the letterhead stationery used was not created until months after the experiment's conclusion.

In a statement last week, Pfizer said that after that article appeared, the company investigated and found that the letter was "incorrect."

Posted by I Love Nigeria| 16.06.2007 21:03

Reply Quote



I Love NigeriaI Love Nigeria is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 9

Why are some NIGERIANS working so hard to find excuses for Pfizer? Why are some Nigerians interested only exonerating Pfizer? even as it is very clear that Pfizer operated over Nigerians' heads?

HERE IS WHAT THE AMERICANS ARE SAYING ABOUT PFIZER'S CRIMINAL ACTS IN KANO!

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dr-peter-rost/dead-children-an-unappro_b_20594.html
even Pfizer's own researchers protested. According to a separate lawsuit, "Dr. Juan Walterspiel, a Pfizer infectious disease specialist assigned to the Trovan test, repeatedly told Pfizer management that the company was violating international law, federal regulations and medical ethics standards." And what did Pfizer do? "Dr. Walterspiel was subsequently dismissed." According to an overseas article Pfizer later settled with Walterspiel, which presumable is one reason we haven't heard from him lately. And this begs the next question: What did Pfizer really know and who within Pfizer fired Walterspiel, later agreed to settle with him, and why?

Posted by I Love Nigeria| 17.06.2007 10:23

Reply Quote



Mikky jagaMikky jaga is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 10

Thanks ILN for the latest information provided. It now makes the story very interesting indeed.

Your frustration and justified anger at what these Nigerians are doing (trying to defend a very wicked act in order to protect their pay checks) are exactly what fellow Nigerians felt when you deployed all your energy to defend the disenfranchisement of large percentage of Nigerians through fraudulent elections, just because you wanted to protect your paycheck(?). Now that you see how frustrating it is to see people defending the outrageous acts of others even in the face of evidence to the contrary, I hope you will have cause to change your tactics in future.

That said, I believe Nigerians should not allow this case to rest until all culprits are brought to book and Pfizer is made to pay heavily for its crime against humanity. A prohibition of Pfizer from doing business in Nigheria will not be out of place at all.

Posted by Mikky jaga| 17.06.2007 11:03

Reply Quote


Last Updated ( Thursday, 24 April 2008 )
 
< Prev   Next >