The Case Against Atiku – By EFCC Print E-mail
Written by Nuhu Ribadu , Chairman EFCC   
Saturday, 30 December 2006

The Case Against Atiku
BY Nuhu Ribadu    

A PRESENTATION BY EFCC CHAIRMAN TO SENATE AD HOC COMMITTEE ON THE PROBE OF PTDF


In July 2003, during the first SULLIVAN summit in Abuja, the US Congressman Williams J. Jefferson met with officials of Netlink Digital Television (NDTV) and introduced them to Mr. Vernon Jackson, the Chief Executive Officer of a US based information technology company called iGate. This led to the establishment of business relationship among them. NDTV is a private company in Nigeria established to carry out the business of telecommunications among others.
 

Consequently, the two companies agreed on a $44,943,400 contract in which iGate would transfer its technology to NDTV for use in Nigeria. Under this arrangement, NDTV agreed to pay the sum of $6.5million to iGate representing 15% of the contract sum, while the balance of 85% or $38.2million was to be financed by US EXIM Bank. Subsequently, there was an ensuing business dispute between the parties which persisted that led the US Congressman to write President Olusegun Obasanjo on the matter.


The letter to the President by the US Congressman dated May 28, 2004 alleged among other things: that the Chief Executive of iGate, Mr. Vernon Jackson, reported to him that he was deeply disturbed by comments made to him [Jackson] by the Managing Director of NDTV, Mr. Ahmed Vanderpuije; that the funds were delayed on the NDTV/iGate contract because they were expecting funds allegedly related to Petroleum Technology Development Fund (PTDF) fixed deposit to pay for the rest of the project. Mr. Jackson was worried that this source of money might be improper or perhaps even illegal.

Mr. President, in a letter dated June 9, 2004, replied the congressman, promising him that he would ensure full investigation of PTDF activities in order to establish the extent of the allegations made on the use of its resources to settle the obligation of a private company. The President directed the EFCC vide a letter ref. PRES/72/-2 dated January 18, 2005 to carry out a thorough investigation on matter. Consequently, the Chairman of NDTV, Otunba Fasawe and the Executive Secretary (ES) of PTDF, Alhaji Hamisu Yusuf Abubakar were invited and interrogated on the matter.


Otunba Fashawe through NDTV and Mofas Shipping Company Limited collected some so-called loans totaling over N1.5billion from Trans International Bank (TIB) Plc. The Bank packaged these loans that were characterized by many irregularities including lack of collateral and compliance with conditions preceding disbursement. The sum of N100million was recovered from him and the money had already been remitted to TIB (now Spring Bank).


During an interview with the ES of PTDF, he admitted that on August 1, 2002, the Fund awarded a contract to a UK-based company called Univation Limited for the upgrade of Petroleum Training Institute (PTI). This company was used as a conduit pipe through which millions of Naira went into the ES’ pocket. The Upgrade was supposed to have cost PTDF $3million but was inflated to $5million while the difference of $2million was paid into numerous companies incorporated and owned by him for the payments of phony contracts he claimed they did for Univation. The sum of N200million was recovered from him and had since been remitted back to PTDF.


On June 22, 2006, the authorities of the US Government sent to the Commission a Mutual Legal Assistance Request (MLAR) which led to further detailed investigation, in line with the EFCC Establishment Act 2004, Section 6(k) which states that it is:


“responsible for dealing with matters connected with extradition, deportation, mutual legal and other assistance between Nigeria and any other country involving Economic and Financial Crimes”.


The Request called for bank records relating to any payment or transfer of funds from the Petroleum Technology Development Fund to any account held by NDTV, Vanderpuije, Fashawe and Kachikwu among others (including but not limited to any accounts held at the Trans International Bank). Other requests include the following:


  1. Provide U.S. Law enforcement authorities whatever information the government of Nigeria may have with respect to the witnesses (Fashawe, Dumebi, Vanderpuije, Egunjobi,  including employment history, history of travel outside Nigeria, criminal history and other biographical information. In addition, permit for U.S. law enforcement authorities, including the prosecutors and agents who will travel to Nigeria, to communicate directly with the lead investigator in Nigeria involved in collecting this information.

  1. Provide the certified copies of the listed documents, records and articles of evidence stated below.

  1. Any and all documents in the possession of NDTV and its present or former officers, employees, or representative (including, but not limited to, Otunba Oyewole Fashawe, Ahmed Vanderpuije, Dumebi Kachikwu) relating to or involving some of the above listed individuals and entities.
  2. Any and all documents in the possession of any Nigeria public official or agency - including but not limited to the Nigerian Communications Commission, Ministry of Communications, Nigerian Embassy in the United States, NITEL and its Managing Director - relating to or involving some of the above listed individuals and entities.
  3. Correspondences between United States Congressman Williams Jefferson and Vice President Alhaji Atiku Abubakar relating to any U.S. based business venture in Nigeria.
  4. Correspondences between United States Congressman Williams Jefferson and Jamilah Jennifer Atiku-Abubakar, wife  of  Vice President Atiku Abubakar, relating to any U.S. based business ventures in Nigeria.
  5. Correspondence between iGate, including its officers and representatives and Vice President Alhaji Atiku Abubakar and any other Nigerian public official.
  6. Correspondence between NDTV, including its officers and representatives and Vice President Alhaji Atiku Abubakar and any other Nigerian public official.
  7. Correspondence between Vice President Atiku Abubakar (or any of his subordinates or representatives), and any government official or agency, including NITEL relating to some listed individuals and entities including
  8. Any and all documents in the possession of Rosecom.Net and its present or former officers, employees, or representatives (including Suleiman Yahyah) and any Nigerian public official or agency (including NITEL and its officials, employees or representatives) relating to business ventures involving iGate or W2-IBBS Limited.
  9. Any and all documents in the possession of the Nigerian Embassy in the United States related to any travel to Nigeria by Congressman Williams Jefferson in connection with U.S. business ventures in Nigeria, including, but not limited to
  10. Records from the Sheraton Hotel & Towers related to the stay of Congressman William Jefferson, Vernon Jackson, and any other party affiliated with Jefferson and Jackson during the February 2004 trip.
  11. Records from the Sheraton Hotel & Towers related to the stay of Congressman William Jefferson, Vernon Jackson, Patrick Gerdes, Adolfo Lambaren, BK Son, and any other party affiliated with Jefferson and Jackson during the May, 2004 trip.
  12. Records and filing relating to some of the listed entities. The requested documents include, but are not limited to company formation documents, shareholder documents, ownership record, management documents, documents relating to payment of fees related to company filings, and any other company information. The request was particular on Diverse Communications Limited, a company associated with William J. Jefferson through which he was to collect kickback in form of percentage of profit for his official act in respect of NDTV/iGate deal.
  13. Bank records of accounts held by  Ahmed Vanderpuije, Otumba Fashawe NDTV, and Dumebi Kachikwu from January, 2003 to present, including, but not limited to, accounts held in Trans International Bank, Transcontinental Bank, Citizen International Bank, Standard Trust Bank, and Continental Trust Bank.
  14. Bank Records of accounts held by Maureen Scurry, also known as Maureen Edu, from January 2003 to the present.
  15. Property transfer records and loan/mortgage records (including applications, correspondences, and documents referring to collateral or security for the loan) relating to the purchase of plot 555 Adetokumbo Ademola Crescent, Wuse II, Abuja (Location of NDTV office).
  16. Correspondences and communication (electronic or otherwise) between officials, agents, or employees of Standard Trust Bank and Maureen Scurry, also known as Maureen Edu, related to financing on behalf of NDTV and/ or IGate.

Government Ministries, Parastatals and Agencies affected, as well as individual witnesses identified were invited for interviews and they volunteered written statements. Among the individuals invited were Mr. Kachikwu, who provided useful information and documents that unraveled the mystery behind NDTV, Mr. Uko Nwafor (the then Assistant General Manager, Finance of PTDF), Mr. Egunjobi Olusegun (the then Branch Manager of TIB, Abuja), Umar Pariya (Personal Assistant to the Vice President), Musa Garba (a friend and business associate of the Vice President), Nda Yakubu (the then Assistant Director Special Duties, Office of Accountant General of the Federation) among others. The Vice President was contacted through letter, dated 18/08/06 to clarify issues raised in relation to his alleged role and he responded in writing. Bank statements of accounts, copies of cheques, vouchers, correspondences, etc. were also received by the Commission for analysis/examination together with the books of accounts of PTDF from 1999 to 2006.

Although investigation did not reveal direct transfer of PTDF funds to NDTV or iGate, the request directed our attention to the relationship between the various ‘loans’ collected by NDTV and its directors and the timing of the transfer of PTDF funds to the bank that granted the facilities.



1.         Petroleum Technology Development Fund (PTDF)

PTDF was established following the repeal of the Gulf Oil Company Training Fund (GOCTF) Act 1964 and the promulgation of Decree No. 25 of 1973 for the purpose of training and education of Nigerians in the petroleum and gas industry. The source of money for the Fund is the balance of monetary assets in the account of the GOCTF, all further sums payable to or received by the Minister of Mines, Power and Steel in term of any agreement made by the Government and any company in relation to petroleum oil prospecting or mining concessions and any other sums freely donated or accruing to the Government or the Funds for the training and education of Nigerians in the petroleum and industry.


The fund is empowered in the Act to:

                     i.      Provide scholarships and bursaries wholly or partially in universities, colleges, institution and in the petroleum undertaking in Nigeria or abroad

                   ii.      Maintain, supplement, or subsidize such training or education as mentioned above

                  iii.      Make suitable endowments to faculties in Nigerian Universities, colleges, or institutions approved by the Minister

                 iv.      Make available suitable books and training equipment in the institution aforesaid

                   v.      Sponsoring regular or as necessary visits to oil fields , refineries, petrochemical plants, and for arranging any necessary attachments of personnel to establishments connected with the development of the petroleum industry;

                 vi.      Financing of and participating in seminars and conferences which are connected with the petroleum industry in Nigeria or abroad


On September 4, 2000, the VP inaugurated an Interim Management Committee (IMC) to manage the Fund.. The IMC comprising six members representing the six geopolitical zones of the country with Yusuf Hamisu Abubakar as Executive Secretary was constituted and inaugurated with the mandate to review the existing laws of the Fund, make suggestion for its amendment, come up with a programme of action to guide the activities of the Fund and make further recommendation that will meet government aspiration and target, especially on capacity building in the petroleum and gas sector of Nigerian economy.


To realize these objectives, funds were released to PTDF from time to time by the Federal Government after due processes have been followed through approval by the Federal Executive Council (FEC). On April 10, 2003, the Presidential Adviser on Petroleum & Energy, Alhaji Rilwan Lukman, wrote to the President and passed through the VP requesting for funds to implement PTDF projects during 2003 fiscal year.  The memo specifically listed the following as the projects to be implemented by the Fund.


  • Capital expenditure on Phase II of the upgrading the of facilities and infrastructure of the Petroleum Training Institute, Effurun;
  • The establishment of Offshore Technology Development Centres (OTDCs) for training of manpower for off-shore petroleum activities
  • The strengthening and expansion of on-going programs for the universities; provision of quality laboratory and library facilities in the petroleum technology-related areas, with special attention to basic and applied research on petroleum technology
  • Establishment of a Central National Petroleum Laboratory for inter-university and industry collaboration, expertise enrichment, and information flow, with a comprehensive network of on-line inter library system
  • Establishment of a National Geodata Base, in line with current practice in all oil exporting countries, to be a national repository and storage facility for all oil exploration and production data for easy retrieval, analysis and utilization
  • Indigenous capacity building to enable Nigerians engage themselves in the gas sub sector and preserve and protect our long-term national interests in the West African and Trans-Saharan Gas Pipeline projects
  • Commencement of feasibility studies and need analysis on the establishment of the College of Petroleum Studies, Kaduna
  • Indigenous capacity building in solid minerals development in line with the statutory schedule of the activities added to the PTDF in the draft amendment law now before the National Assembly. 

In the memo, the Special Adviser requested FEC’s approval for the sum of US $125Million to the operational account of the PTDF for the implementation of the PTDF projects outlined above and for the overall sustenance of the PTDF, which was duly approved by Council after the initial anticipatory approval by the President.


Contrary to the normal procedure and practice, another request of US$20million for PTDF was made by the ES on October 14, 2003  and referred to the VP for approval without the knowledge of the Presidential Adviser who is supposed to have made the request. The VP approved the request and release of the additional funds on October 18, 2003, without reference to FEC, through the President. It is worthy to note what was stated in the letter to the VP requesting for the additional funds:


‘‘in the course of the execution of the projects, we observed the need to achieve uniformity and complete spread of the projects, also the project have some linkages with the existing programmes of the institutions, therefore, it has become expedient to ensure that the projects are executed as scheduled. These needs have consequently exposed some funding gaps which have to be filled through an urgent supplementary release”.


The question one may likely ask is; what was the rationale for additional funds when it was hardly three months earlier that $125million was released, which the VP and the ES were fully aware of, and which were even invested in TIB and ETB, contrary to the insinuation that the projects had started. It is also important to note too that the placements were even done at below Minimum Rediscount Rate (MRR) of the CBN, as evidenced in a memo dated 28/08/2003 addressed to the ES by his Assistant General Manager (AGM)-Mr. Uko U. Nwafor.


It is true that as a Fund, it is supposed to be its financier but PTDF lost several millions of Naira through placements even below the prevailing MRR which is not supposed to be so. The liquidity created by the deposit of PTDF funds led to the packaging of so called loans by  TIB to a friend and business associate of the VP, Otumba Fashawe, through his companies; Mofas and NDTV.  The Fund also lost the income that would have accrued on the $23.75million that could not be returned to CBN in line with Federal Government directives since 2004.


The purpose of the “urgent” need for the supplementary release of the additional $20million in 2003 for “immediate” implementation of the Fund’s projects was therefore defeated. PTDF would have also lost huge funds as there must have been upward review of the cost of the projects/contracts.


2                    Trans International Bank (TIB)- (now Springbank Plc)
This was one of the banks the VP approved for the deposit of $10million out of the initial $125million meant for the execution of the various PTDF projects. On July 16, 2003 the fund was placed in term deposit and subsequently rolled over severally. The additional USD $20million approved unilaterally by the VP was also fixed with TIB for 360days at 1.75% on December 24, 2003 contrary to the request made for their release.


On 20/10/03, shortly after the first placement of USD$10m by PTDF, the bank packaged a so called loan of N400million to NDTV, a company owned by Otunba Fashawe, a friend and associate of the VP. On October 22, 2003; the same Otumba Fashawe, using his other company Mofas Shipping Company Limited, collected another ‘loan’ of N420m;  Yet on October 23, 2003, Ahmed Vanderpuije, the Managing Director of NDTV also collected a ‘loan’ of N300million through his other company, Transvari Services Limited, pretty much in the way Fashawe did. Ahmed Vanderpuije, who is a Ghanaian, is now a fugitive from justice elsewhere.


Sometimes in January 2004, NDTV again collected a ‘loan’ of N730million after the deposit of the USD20million from PTDF in December 2003. It is important to note that the loan was not reflected in the account of NDTV until a year later.


It is pertinent to note that all the various ‘loans’ collected by Mofas, NDTV and Transvari were without adequate and proper collateral. Thus, $23.75 million of the $30million deposited by PTDF in this bank was stuck. This is contrary to claims from some quarters that the safety of the fund and the health of the bank were major considerations before the placements.




3.         Netlink Digital Television (NDTV)
This company was incorporated on June 6, 2002 to provide a high quality digital services and modern telecommunication services. The board members are Otunba Oyewole Fashawe (Chairman), Ahmed Vanderpuije (Managing Director), Dumebi Kachikwu (Director) and Martin Wright representing Kites International Holding. For the provision of this technology, sometimes in July 2003, NDTV went into an agreement with iGate, a US based technology vendor. There was a provision in the agreement that US Export-Import Bank is to finance 85% or $38.2million of the project, while NDTV through TIB, was to make a contribution of 15% or $6.5million. This transaction involving US Exim Bank is questionable. This subsequently led to the beginning of relationship between NDTV and TIB which led to the financing of their 15% contribution. While this NDTV/TIB relationship was being cemented on the one hand, on the other hand PTDF funds where being deposited in TIB, within the same period, to improve the bank’s liquidity.


NDTV used the proceeds of the first so-called loan, collected from TIB after the deposit of $10million by PTDF, and paid for the balance of N170million for the purchase of a property located at No 555 Adetokunbo Ademola Crescent, Wuse II, Abuja, which serves as its office. The property was bought at N200m and the initial payment of N30million was made on January 7, 2003 by Marine Float Ltd, an account domiciled in Bank PHB Plc, being controlled by the VP. The VP confirmed in his response to a letter from the Commission that he gave the N30million to NDTV from Marine Float Ltd as a loan.


NDTV also used some part of the proceeds of the ‘loan’ from TIB to transfer $1.5million to iGate, a US based technology vendors associated with Congressman Williams Jefferson, as part of their agreement for the acquisition of right to use iGate technology in Nigeria.

NDTV collected another presumed loan of N730million from the TIB after the deposit of $20million by PTDF, and wired $5million to iGate in line with their agreement to contribute 15%. Similarly, and from the same ‘loans’, the following payments were made by NDTV:


·                    Mrs. Maureen Scurry, now Maureen Edu, a former employee of US Exim Bank as a Business Development Specialist on Africa, who at that time represented US Exim Bank during the NDTV/iGate deal, was wired the sum of USD100, 000 on February 27, 2004 to her personal account with FSB Washington DC.


·                    The sums of USD 133,870 and USD 40,312 were paid to Sofitel Incorporated USA as commitment and processing fees for the refinancing of the USD6.5milliom paid to iGate.


·                    A US based Lawyer, Jean Michael Malek P C was also paid the sum of USD 5,000 as legal fee in part, as a lawyer representing NDTV in the US over the project with iGate. These are all independent of the $6.5million NDTV wired to iGate.



4.         Mofas Shipping Co. Limited (Mofas)
Mofas is a group of merchandize importers, exporters, manufacturers, clearing and forwarding agents. It is also engaged in business relating to shipping generally. The company was incorporated on October 8, 1990 with the following persons as Board Members: Alhaji Zannah Mustapha Deribe, Mr. Johnson Oyewole Fashawe, Mr. Adamu Abubakar, Prince Emanuel O. O. Olagbegi and Olusegun Aina.  


Contrary to the VP’s claim that he has no business dealings with Fashawe whatsoever nor is he involved in anyway or with his companies or businesses, Adamu Abubakar, a director of Mofas is his first son. The signature of Adamu Abubakar in the Memorandum and Article of Association of the company was simply “Turaki”, which is the title of the VP [Probably he was a minor at that time.].  “Turaki” was also the signature of Hajiya Fati Abubakar as evident in a document of Meenat Trading Company Limited. The VP was also a referee to NDTV at Nigeria Communications Commission. The same VP paid the initial deposit of N30million to acquire a property that is the Head Office of NDTV. The VP forwarded a letter on the business venture between iGate and Rosecom.Net to the Honourable Minister of Communications when the interface between iGate and NDTV ruptured thereby necessitating a new business venture.


The company opened an account with TIB Abuja branch on 14/05/03, barely two months to the first PTDF deposits of $10million in the bank on 16/07/03. By October 22, 2003, Otunba Fashawe through the company secured a ‘loan’ of N420million meant to augment its working capital. This facility was granted without adequate collateral and the fulfillment of the conditions preceding disbursement. The same house purchased with the loans granted Otumba Fashawe, which was not even enough security, was used as collateral for the loan. Contrary to augmenting its working capital as agreed, the money was disbursed to other companies, organizations and individuals. The balance in the account of the company as at 31/5/06 was still in debit to the tune of N1, 083,755,459.44.


It is important to note that the VP has interest in Mofas as evidenced by the payments of N61milion on 29/01/03 to him, N250million to Marine Float Ltd. on 18/2/03, over N104million at various times to Alhaji Umar Pariya (the P.A to the VP), N60million on 22/06/02 to Musa Garba (a friend of the VP and a contractor handling ABTI University project). As earlier stated, Adamu Abubakar, is the son of the VP. The reference to these payments in isolation by Mofas is only to show the interest and long standing relationship of the VP in the company.


Ahmed Vanderpuije also used the proceeds of the N300million loan collected after the $10million PTDF deposit to finance the publishing of Nda Yakubu’s book titled: ‘Nigerian Laws on Public Finances’. Nda Yakubu was the then Assistant Director, Special Duties in the Office of the Accountant General. The claim being investigated against him is that: ‘‘by virtue of his long stay in AGF’s office, he was privy to the various financial status of the Federal Government and where the funds were kept. That he used to divulge the information to Alhaji Ahmed Vanderpuije who was a business associate of Otumba Fashawe who eventually got the VP informed”. Though no direct evidence was obtained, it is curious to note that the $20million additional request by the ES of PTDF coincided with the only remaining balance in the account of PTDF with the Accountant General of the Federation from where the money was transferred on the instruction of the VP. This suggests that there was information from the OAGF on the balance of PTDF funds.


5.                  Equatorial Trust Bank Plc (ETB)
Otumba Mike Adenuga is the Chairman of this bank and it was the second bank, where $I65million PTDF funds were fixed at various times. The first placement was on June 25, 2002 in the sum of USD50million transferred from its account in UBA Plc, New York, US. After the deposit, Mr. Mike Adenuga, an associate of the VP, paid the sum of $20million sometime in 2002 as part payment for Globacom’s license. Some few months after the receipt of the $50million, Mike Adenuga, through one of his accounts called Deep Sea Ltd, gave Marine Float Ltd the sum of N300million (on 27/11/02). Deep Sea Ltd is an internal account in ETB funded by another related account, Yuletide Ventures, whose source of funds was unauthorized overdrafts granted by the bank. Another N22 million was also given to Marine Float on 06/03/03 by same Mike Adenuga through Deep Sea Ltd. These funds were transferred from Lagos to Messrs Akinyera and Ajibade in Abuja but drafts were raised in favour of Marine Float Limited. These payments showed direct benefit of the VP in ETB. There was another ETB draft of N21million issued in favour of Alhaji Umar Pariya, an aide to the VP around the same time the $50million deposit was made. Messrs Akinyera and Ajibade are close aides of Otumba Mike Adenuga just as Alhaji Umar Pariya is a close aide of Alhaji Atiku Abubakar.


The trio of VP, ES of PTDF (Alhaji Yusuf Hamisu Abubakar) and Otumba Mike Adenuga met in the office/residence of the VP to discuss the placement of the USD115million in ETB by PTDF.  It was at this meeting that Hamisu Yusuf Abubakar was introduced to Otumba Mike Adenuga as the chairman of ETB. Immediately after the meeting, the placement of the $115million by the PTDF in ETB followed and Mike Adenuga rolled out his Globacom Network in the country.


A scrutiny of Globacom revealed its ownership structure as follow; Conpetro Limited-51%; Alhaji G. Subair-24%; Prince Babatunde Akinyera-12.5% and Festus Okechukwu Igbomor-12.5%.  This is contrary to Otumba Mike Adenuga’s statement of being the sole owner of the company. The given address of Alhaji G. Subair of 2/3, Dawaki Road, Kaduna, was found to be a property belonging to Mohammed Badamasi Babangida. When the other addresses of the shareholders were checked, they were found to be non-existent.


Mr. Jeffrey Tesler, a business associate and friend of both Ibrahim B. Babangida and Mike Adenuga facilitated the payment of $180milion for Globacom license. Jeffrey Tesler also facilitated the granting of a loan of $700million to Con Oil, a company owned and controlled by Otunba Mike Adenuga.


The ES was rewarded with a so called loan in excess of N200million by ETB after the placements of the $165million in the bank, for transportation/dealership business with Conoil, a company belonging to Otumba Mike Adenuga. The duos are now fugitive from justice.


The business of banks is basically to mobilize funds (deposits) and advancing them as loans to their customers, among others, but not as unsecured and unauthorized loans that was distributed to companies, relations and politicians. It is clear that these monies were paid to companies and individuals contrary to the original intention of the so called loans.



6.         iGate Inc. US (iGate)

iGate is a US based technology company that is into  communication technology. Sometimes in June 2003, while in Nigeria, Congressman Jefferson introduced the officials of NDTV (Otumba Fashawe, Dumebi Kachikwu and Ahmed Vanderpuije) to Vernon Jackson, the Chief Executive of iGate Inc. Through various negotiations, NDTV ultimately entered into a Distributor Agreement with iGate whereby NDTV agreed to pay iGate $44,943,400 for the rights to iGate’s technology and to distribute its products in Nigeria. By January 2004 and in accordance with the agreement, NDTV paid approximately 15% or $6.5million to iGate as an advance for the right. $1.5million was initially remitted to iGate and the balance of $5million was later wired to iGate being the balance of the 15% with the remaining 85% or $38.4million expected to be financed by US EXIM bank.


Business relationship between NDTV and iGate became strained towards the end of 2003 and ultimately broke off in 2004. Consequently, NDTV hired legal representative, Jean Micheal Malek, in the US to seek the refund of the $6.5million it paid iGate. The sum of $5000 was paid to the lawyer as his fee to facilitate the refund to NDTV.


iGate agreed to return $4million after negotiation but only $1.7million had been refunded to NDTV through TIB, leaving a balance of $2.3million unpaid. It was at this stage that Congressman Jefferson wrote to the President in defense to an alleged petition sent to the president by Otumba Fasawe. Jefferson wrote that Mr. Vernon Jackson had told him that before the payments to iGate, the MD of NDTV, Ahmed Vanderpuije, informed him that they were expecting funds from PTDF which would be used for the payments for the contract between NDTV and iGate.


After the business relationships between NDTV and iGate soured, Congressman Jefferson continued to look for an investor in telecommunication venture that would utilize iGate’s technology and products. This effort yielded fruits with the agreement between Rosecom. Net, an Internet Service Provider (ISP), and iGate Inc. for the use of iGate technology to provide internet services in Nigeria over Nitel’s copper wire infrastructure (Co-location). However, Nitel refused to allow the co-location agreement to subsist because it had already entered into another agreement with a Chinese based company for the same purpose.


As a result of Nitel refusal, Congressman Jefferson decided to enlist the cooperation of the VP, first, for assistance in extinguishing the $2million debt to NDTV relating to the previous NDTV procurement of the right to use iGate technology in Nigeria and secondly, for assistance in gaining Nitel’s cooperation for the co-collocation of iGate technology at Nitel’s facilities.


It is pertinent to note that on May 3, 2006, Mr. Jackson pleaded guilty to charges of conspiracy to bribe and bribery in the US. He claimed to have bribed Jefferson with more than $400,000 in cash, company stock and shares in iGate technology business ventures in Nigeria and other African countries.


7.                  The VP, Atiku Abubakar
Atiku Abubakar is the Vice President of Nigeria and he was the one overseeing the activities of PTDF. He inaugurated the Interim Management Committee of the Fund in September 2000.

He played prominent roles in the approvals for release of PTDF funds and their placements in two banks.  The VP had an outstanding interest in the placement of the PTDF funds in these two banks. For one, even the $125million for the implantation of some specific projects was not utilized for that purpose, rather caused their diversion to their placements in the two banks (TIB & ETB). Prior to the placements of the PTDF funds, the VP held several meetings with either the ES alone and sometime the ES and Mike Adenuga to discuss modalities regarding the placement of the funds either in TIB or ETB. The placements were done at the detriment of the Fund as they were made at interest rates below the average CBN Minimum Rediscount Rate (MRR) even when he was strongly advised against that.
                    
The request for the release of the $20million, was predicated on the issue of the ongoing projects being executed by the Fund, whereas it was not so. The funds were released again by the VP and were sent straight to the same placement in TIB. This second release was done without the knowledge and approval of the Presidential Adviser on Petroleum and Energy, Mr. President and the FEC. As these funds were hitting the two preferred banks, “loans” were packaged by TIB, even without adequate collateral, for his long time friend and business associate, Otumba Oluwole Johnson Haliru Fashawe through NDTV and Mofas. In Mofas, one of the directors is Alhaji Adamu Abubakar, a son of the VP. Though the VP’s name was not stated as a director of Marine Float, evidence abounds that the account is controlled by him. First, the VP admitted he paid N30million for the property from that account; secondly, most of the beneficiaries from the account are his friends, associates.

Similarly, as the funds were hitting ETB, Otumba Mike Adenuga made  $20million deposit for Globacom license, the second national carrier. A little scrutiny of the equity ownership structure of the company revealed that Otunba Mike Adenuga lied about the ownership of the company. When the transfer of the $50million by PTDF from its account in UBA Plc New York was made in ETB, Mike Adenuga gave the VP the sum of N322million (i.e N300m on 27/11/02 & N22m on 06/03/03) through his Marine Float account domiciled in Bank PHB Plc through his aides - Akinyera and Ajibade.       The sum of N21m was paid to the VP through a draft raised in the name of  Umar Pariya, his Personal Assistant.

The VP held several meetings with the US Congressman Williams J. Jefferson both in Nigeria and abroad in relation to business ventures which included NDTV and Rosecom.Net, an ISP. When the business relationship between NDTV and iGate collapsed, his assistance was sought to extinguish the outstanding approximately $2million already paid by NDTV. Even though he denied assistance on extinguishing the amount, he accepted conveying a letter from US Congressman Jefferson to the Honourable Minister of Communication, Chief Cornelious Adebayo in relation with iGate and Rosecom.Net business venture.

The VP’s business interest in NDTV was confirmed when he made an initial deposit of N30million on January 7, 2003 from his Marine Float account in Bank PHB Plc for the purchase of the N200million property being used as NDTV Head Office. His interest also influenced the placement of PTDF funds in TIB from where Otunba Fashawe obtained ‘loan’ and completed the payment of N170million for the property at Wuse. The VP’s interest in NDTV is further buttressed by the fact that he even acted as a referee to Otumba Fashawe for the sourcing of the licensing of NDTV in Nigeria Communications Commission (NCC).  Ref. Appendix AB.  Investigation also revealed that the VP severally met contractors of NDTV at Jada, his hometown on his interest in the company.
 
 
Distinguished Senators, this is submitted for your necessary action.
 
Thank you very much.
 
 
NUHU RIBADU
EXECUTIVE CHAIRMAN
Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC)



 




RobotRobot is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 1

The Case Against Atiku
BY Nuhu Ribadu
...Read the full article.

Posted by Robot| 30.12.2006 09:59

Reply Quote



blackscorpionblackscorpion is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 2

Dear Mallam,

You deserve commendation for a seemingly thorough and open investigation.One is however a bit worried by growing insinuations that these investigations are selective ordered by the state house.It is obvious that our number two man is neck deep in graft but stories abound that his ways are representative of how governance practiced in the land.

The underlisted links open a series of allegations against public officials as reported in the media.You will be doing Nigerians and our image a lot of good if these can be investigated,proved to be fault or confirmed with reasons why nothing is being done.





http://saharareporters.com/dn001.php?dnid=219,

http://saharareporters.com/dn001.php?dnid=219,

http://saharareporters.com/eLibrary/

http://saharareporters.com/eLibrary/

Regards,

Kunle

Posted by blackscorpion| 30.12.2006 13:01

Reply Quote



blackscorpionblackscorpion is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 3

Dear Mallam,

You deserve commendations for a seemingly thorough and open investigation.One is however a bit worried by growing insinuations that these investigations are selective and are ordered by the state house.It is obvious that our number two man is neck deep in graft but stories abound that his ways are representative of how governance is practiced in the land.

The underlisted links open a series of allegations against public officials as reported in the media.You will be doing Nigerians and our image a lot of good if these can be investigated and proved to be false or confirmed with reasons why nothing is being done.





http://saharareporters.com/dn001.php?dnid=219,

http://saharareporters.com/dn001.php?dnid=219,

http://saharareporters.com/eLibrary/

http://saharareporters.com/eLibrary/

Regards,

Kunle

Posted by blackscorpion| 30.12.2006 13:05

Reply Quote



edojiedoji is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 4

Atiku: Obasanjo Took N10bn PTDF Money for 3rd Term

The ill-fated third term agenda re-echoed yesterday in Abuja at the public sitting of the Senate Committee on Petroleum Technology Development Fund (PTDF) when Vice President Atiku Abubakar alleged that President Olusegun Obasanjo approved the immediate release of N10 billion in the thick of the battle to push the agenda in the National Assembly.
Atiku, whose one-hour and 17-minute appearance before the 13-member committee headed by Senator Victor Ndoma-Egba (SAN) was characterised by humour and friendly exchanges between him and members, tasked the committee to investigate what happened to the money.
According to him, “on the 10th of May, 2006, at the height of the evil tenure elongation plot, the PTDF requested, under circumstances that were at best cloudy, for N20 billion for its projects as well as the immediate release of N10 billion.
“The request was made by the PTDF management and approved by the President on the same day. There is no evidence that the N20 billion was released to the PTDF, and there is nothing to indicate that the approval of the Federal Executive Council was sought and obtained for both amounts.
“You may wish to investigate into the N20 billion. Where was it placed, and what was it used for? he asked. “As at December 2005, the PTDF had N20 billion and 150 million dollars in fixed deposit, N533 million and 6.3 million dollars in its current account”.
According to Atiku, “you may want to find out how that money was expended, and what happened to the foreign exchange component? You should request for the Auditor-General’s Report on the PTDF from January to June 2006. That audit report is quite revealing and I believe that your investigations will not be complete without it”.
Atiku, who told the committee that he was not guilty of any wrong doing, arrived at the venue of the public sitting in Senate Hearing Room One at 11.25 a.m., after his advance security team had taken adequate security measures in and around the premises of the venue.
He was accompanied by some of his political associates, including Alhaji Lawal Kaita, Alhaji Abubakar Rimi, Chief Dubem Onyia, Mr. Yomi Edu, Chief Gbazuegu Nweke Gbazueagu, Alhaji Abubakar Hashidu, Alhaji Bashir Dalhatu and Dr. Usman Bugaje, among others.
Chairman of the Committee, Senator Ndoma-Egba welcomed the Vice President and put it on record that he was the one who wrote to indicate his willingness to appear before the Committee an act, which he said was courageous.
He gave a background to the Senate investigation of the PTDF activities and told the Vice President that the Committee Secretariat had made photocopies of the presentation by the Chairman of the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), Malam Nuhu Ribadu ready in case he (Atiku) requested for it. “As I speak, I am not sure any request has come from you, but you are still at liberty to have them.
“If you are ready, please tell us so that you can be on oath”, Ndoma-Egba said. The Vice President said he was ready, and the oath was administered on him at 11.35 a.m. to set the tone for his presentation, which began at 11.38 and ended at 12.35 p.m. He read from a 14-page booklet titled: “PTDF: The Facts, The Fiction: A Presentation to Senate Ad-Hoc Committee on Investigations into the Affairs of the Petroleum Technology Development Fund”.
But before he made his presentation, his aides had submitted a small box of documents, comprising annexure and appendices referred to in his presentation, to each member of the Committee. His presentation was as revealing as the documents submitted as annexure and appendices to the committee. Having given insight into the PTDF and its operations under his supervision, he had gone ahead to address all allegations against him in the EFCC report. Under the sub-title, “PTDF-A beehive of Irregularities”, the Vice President stated: “As you can see, I am a victim of a well-orchestrated and vicious smear campaign aimed, principally, at preventing me from offering myself for service to the nation at the highest level.
“To conclude my presentation, it is necessary for me to provide you with an insight into the activities of the PTDF in recent times for you to see for yourselves the irregularities, mismanagement and outright looting that now characterises the operations of the PTDF.
“Here, you will find evidence of PTDF resources being diverted to schemes and activities that are not only unbudgeted for but also clearly outside the mandate of the Fund in line with its governing statutes. Indeed, the PTDF has, in recent times, been turned into a slush fund for all manner of inexplicable transactions for the convenience of the very people who falsely accuse me of wrongdoing”.
According to the Vice President, “PTDF monies are now regularly and whimsically doled out to individuals, groups and causes that catch their fancy. A few examples will suffice. Establishment of an Institute of Science and Technology in the FCT: In August 2006, the President approved the sum of US$25 million from the Fund for the establishment of a so-called African Institute of Science and Technology, Gulf of Guinea Affiliate, in Abuja.
“The money was released. Distinguished Senators may wish to investigate and find out to whom the money was paid, and where such institute is located. More importantly, there is no enabling law setting up the Institute and no money was appropriated by the National Assembly for it (see appendices 11a, 11b, and 11c)”.
On the Registration of Galaxy Backbone Plc and Payment of Legal Fees, the Vice President said: “In September 2006, the President approved the payment of the sum of N250 million from the PTDF to his personal lawyer, Chief Afe Babalola of Emmanuel Chambers, for the mere act of registering a company, Galaxy Backbone, with the Corporate Affairs Commission (see appendices 12a, 12b, and 12c). With a share capital of one billion naira, the actual amount paid to the Corporate Affaires Commission is N23 million. Distinguished Senators, is the establishment and funding of Galaxy Backbone within the mandate of PTDF? Is it justifiable for a President who claims to be fighting corruption to authorise the payment of N250 million of public funds to his personal lawyer for the mere registration of a company?”
On Purchase of Computers for Civil Servants, he stated: “You may also wish to note that on July 28, 2006 the President approved the sum of ten million dollars from the PTDF fund for the purchase of computers under the Computers for All Nigerians Initiative (CANI) (see appendices 13a, 13b, 13c, 13d).
“As laudable as CANI may be, the question should still be asked whether PTDF is the right government agency with the capacity to organise, manage and support a revolving loan for the ownership of computers by civil servants.
“And considering the need for legislative oversight for such major project, why was this programme not included in the normal budgetary process?”
Other alleged irregularities, according to him, include: “Note Purchase Agreement Between UBA and other Banks and PTDF: Distinguished Senators may also want to look into the scandalous lending of billions of naira of PTDF money to the United Bank of Africa (UBA) from which, strangely, the Federal Government then borrowed to buy vehicles (see appendix 14).
“It is also interesting that the President went on to draw a personal loan of N200 million from the UBA, which according to his spokespersons, was used to purchase the 200 million shares he owns in Transcorp. We hope that this N200 million ‘loaned’ to the President is not a trade-off for the deposit, which he approved for the bank. Distinguished members of this Committee may wish to investigate this”.
On PTDF Bank Deposits and Interest Rates, he said, “I was accused of authorising the deposit of PTDF funds in a bank without the approval of Federal Executive Council. Distinguished Senators, as at 31st May 2006, the PTDF had nearly N19 billion deposited in various banks in the country. It may interest you to note that there was no Federal Executive Council approval for these deposits, which buttresses my point that I did not require any additional approval for the deposit authorised by me (see appendix 15).
“Approval Limit for Expenditure of PTDF funds: Distinguished Senators, in trying to find out who has been mismanaging PTDF funds, it may interest you to note that on 4th April 2006, without recourse to the Federal executive Council, the President raised the limit of the amount of money that the Executive Secretary of PTDF can approve from N700,000 to N10,000,000 (see appendix 16). This new approval limit seems to have provided an opportunity for a renewed assault on the resources of the Fund.
“Contract Award to PDP National Working Committee Members: You may also want to know that contracts were awarded from the PTDF on 17 July, 2006 to companies many of which are suspected to belong to members of the National Working Committee of the PDP to induce them to support the President’s total destruction of internal democracy within the PDP. You will also discover in your investigations that some of the companies to which these contracts were awarded were not even duly registered by the Corporate Affairs Commission (see appendices 17a and 17b).
“PTDF Contracts for the President’s Aides and Cronies: “As further evidence of the abuse to which the PTDF has been subjected by the very people accusing me of wrong-doing, companies linked to such aides of the President as his current Political Adviser, Ministers such as those of the FCT and Science and Technology; and a long list of his close political associates, were favoured with mouth-watering contracts from PTDF.
“Millions of naira have also been doled out by the PTDF management for some phoney community relations consultancy. “In order that he is not left out of the party, the new National Security Adviser is currently being processed as an external solicitor to the PTDF through his own legal firm, A.S. Mukhtar and Company. I urge you, distinguished Senators, to investigate these thoroughly (see appendices 18a, 18b, 18c, 18d, 18e, 18f).
“Progress Report on Obasanjo Administration and Photographs for State House Library: As a further example of the gross abuse of PTDF funds, the President’s Media Office is on production of progress reports and payment for photographs for the State House Library (see appendix 19a, 19b, 19c, 19d).
“Award of Contracts for ICT Projects: Distinguished Senators may also note that in August 2006, a Federal Executive Council memo was presented for approval for the award of contracts for the establishment of ICT centres in 102 Unity Schools, 20 Federal Colleges of Education and 24 Universities.
“However, Council did not know that these contracts worth billions of naira and over US$20 million were awarded mostly to the aides and cronies of the President.
“Earlier on, on the 24th of February 2006, the President approved the sum of N2.5 billion for the supply of so-called ‘Skill G’ science and technology equipment to senior secondary schools, technical colleges, and polytechnics/colleges of technology. You may also wish to find out whether these projects are within the PTDF mandate (see appendices 20a, 20b, 20c and 20d).
“DICON Rehabilitation Account: The PTDF, in absolute and flagrant violation of its mandate, was directed to dole out N1 billion to the Defence Industries Corporation of Nigeria (DICON) even as this investigation had commenced. This payment was made via a Prudent Bank cheque dated October 10, 2006. And the N1 billion is being spent for one of the President’s vanity projects: naming a gun after himself, the so-called OBJ 006. I have always advocated the resuscitation of the DICON and the repositioning of the Nigerian Armed Forces in general but it is clearly illegal to do so with PTDF resources (see appendices 21a and 21b).
“Purchase of Vehicles: Distinguished Senators may recall that this administration took a decision to do away with all categories of official vehicles, except those meant for essential services that are to be placed under a common pool.
“In violation of this same policy, in May 2006, the President granted the PTDF an approval to purchase 6 units of Toyota Corolla, a unit of Peugeot 407 and a Toyota Hilux at a cost of N41 million. The Toyotas and Peugeot were designated as official vehicles, and allocated to officials of the agency as official vehicles (see appendices 22a, 22b and 22c).
“Inflation of Contracts and Frivolous Rehabilitation of PTDF Headquarters: The management of the PTDF spent a whopping N60 million on the purported rehabilitation of its headquarters in 2006. This includes N36 million expenditure to procure a lift for the two-storey building. The expenses also include the cost of putting Jacuzzi in the PTDF Headquarters”.
The Vice President added: “It may interest you to know that some of these actions which I have itemised here have been retroactively approved by the Federal Executive Council in recent days. This shows the depth of contempt in which the Senate is held by my accusers.
“In fact, some of these illegal actions were brought to Council for ratification on November 1st, 2006, the very day that the Senate Ad-Hoc Committee was supposed to commence sitting but for the unfortunate ADC plane crash. This frantic and desperate effort to retroactively ratify PTDF’s transactions after the Senate began its investigations is itself an admission of wrong-doing by my accusers.
“As you know, an action that is ipso facto, illegal, especially in matters of appropriation, which the Constitution has wisely placed in the domain of the National Assembly, cannot be justified or legalised by mere FEC approval or ratification (see appendices 23a, 23b, and 23c).”
Atiku, who said that no money of the Fund was lost through his actions while he supervised the PTDF, thrice declared to the Committee that the allegations made against him and the actions orchestrated by the Presidency were all aimed at scuttling his 2007 presidential aspiration.
He said: “Let me also point out that you can only fully understand why these allegations have been made against me by locating them within the context of the political persecution that I have been subjected to by the President and his people in the last few years.
“These include the sacking and/or harassment of my aides, friends and associates, my being portrayed on national television by the President as disloyal, the persistent and illegal use of security agents to raid and ransack my campaign office and my bank records, my illegal suspension from the PDP and the orchestrated, persistent, and dangerous denigration of the Office of the Vice President”.
He said at the outset of his presentation that the EFCC, without any just cause had accused him of conspiracy, fraudulent conversion of funds, corrupt practices and money laundering, adding that “in relying on the report of the EFCC, the FEC (of which, by virtue of my position, I am Vice Chairman) has purportedly found me guilty of fraud and embezzlement, all in a bid to satisfy the callous and mischievous aims of those who seek to rely on the provisions of Section 137 (1) (i) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 to prevent me from contesting the presidency of our great nation or any election for that matter under the said constitution”.
While rebutting the EFCC allegations, he described them as “spurious and irresponsible”, adding that he was making his presentation to “clear the web of lies, deceit, duplicity and falsehood that has been spun around this matter in the past few weeks; to clear my name and restore honour and dignity to the Office of Vice President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria”.
He said that in February for instance the Technical Implementation Committee (TIC) through its Chair, Dr. Rilwanu Lukman, presented a memo requesting for the approval of funds to be transferred to the PTDF from the bid proceeds of the current licensing rounds, as provided by law, to fund and sustain the activities of the PTDF in line with the specific projects outlined in the programme of action (see appendix 3).
“The President-in-Council approved this memo and authorised the transfer of the sum of US$125 million to the PTDF for the funding and sustenance of the Fund as requested. It is necessary to point out here that the ‘specific projects’ referred to above (as contained in the programme of action) are mostly projects that are open ended in scope in that they are projects which the PTDF will continue to implement for as long as it remains in existence.
“More importantly, it is also necessary to point out that contrary to the erroneous and misleading impressions created by the EFCC, the sum of US$125 million approved to be transferred to the PTDF was to be added to, and to form part of, its capital to be invested and the income accruing thereon be expended in funding the PTDF activities.
“It was in the light of this that the Executive Secretary of the PTDF wrote to me on 29th April 2003 (see appendix 4) to seek my approval to convert the approved sum of US$125 million from foreign currency (where interest yields were about 1 to 1,5 per cent per annum) into naira (where interest yields were about 14 to 15 per cent per annum) and invest this in the money market in Nigeria with Equitorial Trust Bank, Plc, and Trans International Bank. Plc, respectively, to maximise the yield accruing from the funds.
“It is pertinent to note, as can be seen from paragraph 3 of appendix 4, that the Executive Secretary stated clearly in his memo that ‘a substantial portion of PTDF’s funds were already invested in the local money market’. As a matter of fact, the PTDF at that time had various money market investments with at least 14 commercial banks in Nigeria.
“It is also pertinent to note that both ETB and TIB were, at all material times, on the Accountant-General’s list of banks authorised to receive government funds and deposits”.
The Vice President said that he was persuaded by the “reasonable argument of the Executive Secretary that investing these funds at the rates prevailing in the money market at that time would yield to the coffers of the PTDF a sum of approximately N1.235 billion as against N161 million were the investment not approved.
“Mr. Chairman, what sins has Atiku Abubakar committed in assenting to the request of an agency he oversees to maximise its potentials for realising the objectives for which it was established? Am I to be crucified for my actions in making the PTDF to earn N1,235 billion as against N161 million it would have earned by my inaction?
“Need I mention, Mr. Chairman, that the funds invested with ETB have been returned to the PTDF on the due date together with the interest accruing thereon? In the same vein, the funds invested with TIB (now part of the Spring Bank consortium) have been restructured due to the banking consolidation exercise and repayment has already commenced (see appendix 5)”.
Atiku told the Committee that “In addition to the above, the EFCC has mischievously alluded to my approval of an additional US$20 million as funding for the PTDF’s activities as an unauthorised transaction.
“Firstly, as I have said repeatedly about this matter, I approved this additional sum of US$20 million for the PTDF based on the Executive Secretary’s memo in which he informed me that the additional funds were required to achieve uniformity and geo-political spread in the implementation of the projects that they were then undertaking.
“Secondly, it is quite misleading to say that this transaction was unauthorised. I am astonished, shocked and filled with indignation to hear claims that I acted unilaterally in approving a sum such as this. For the avoidance of doubt, I wish to state categorically that I discussed this mater with President in person and he did not object.
“It was within this context and global approval already given by the President to fund and implement the PTDF’s programme of action that I gave the approval for this US$20 million. In any event, this disbursement was authenticated by the Honourable Minister if Finance (se appendix 6).
“In other words, contrary to the baseless, specious, irresponsible and insulting claims of the EFCC in its report, no funds have been ‘embezzled’ since the entire funds invested with the two banks have either been repaid or are now being repaid. This is not taking into account the huge interest that has accrued and been paid in respect of these deposits”.
The Vice President also spoke on the ETB/Globacom/Otunba Mike Adenuga; TIB/NDTV/Mofas Shipping/Otunba Johnson Fasawe; Marine Float and the EFCC/Administrative Panel of Inquiry, stressing in respect to the latter that “I will say, however, that it is extremely curious to me that it is this time that the President would deem it necessary to set up an ‘Administrative Panel of Inquiry’ to look into a report compiled by the EFCC, especially where no public funds have been lost.
“When the same EFCC compiled a damning report alleging widespread fraud and embezzlement of over N53 billion of public funds from the Nigerian Ports Authority, the President did not deem it necessary to set up any Administrative Panel of Inquiry.
“It is also very curious to me that the very same President who has publicly accused his Vice President of disloyalty sees nothing wrong in appointing his cronies to sit in judgment over the supposedly disloyal Vice President and expect that a fair hearing will be conducted therefrom”.
He said: “In concluding this part of presentation, I would like to state categorically that the findings of the EFCC as contained in its report dated 24th August 2006 and the contents of the reports of the so-called ‘Administrative Panel of Inquiry’ based on the EFCC report, as they purport to relate or refer to me, are totally false, baseless and unsupportable by the facts in this matter (and) I would urge you to address your minds accordingly and consign these reports to the dustbin where they belong”.
He continued: “Having now seen how the PTDF has been abused in recent times by those who have falsely accused me, it is important that you consider ways in which the National Assembly can strengthen the procedures for accessing the Fund and provide strong sanctions for the disregard of those rules and procedures. You may consider amending the PTDF Act to take care of our changed priorities as the National Assembly may deem appropriate”.
In the course of cross-examination, the Vice President made clarifications that his son, Adamu Atiku Abubakar is not a director of Moffas and that the committee can check the records with the Corporate Affairs Commission to ascertain the veracity of the claim. He said that there was no company associated with the PTDF that he or any member of his family was associated with, saying that the EFCC looked at “all my accounts, my son’s accounts, my wife’s accounts and company where she signed as Fati Turaki all in a bid to establish connection, but they could not find anything.
“Like I said, I am the most investigated Vice President in the whole world. If the only thing they got is that I approved the placement of PTDF money in banks, what have they got?” At the end of the appearance, the Committee commended the Vice President's courage, saying that “if all public officers would subject themselves to public scrutiny the way he has done, the country would be the better for it.”

Posted by edoji| 30.12.2006 17:06

Reply Quote



I Love NigeriaI Love Nigeria is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 5

BRAVO Mallam Nuhu Ribadu and the EFCC!

A million thanks for doing the crucially necessary work of claning the augean's stable!
Riding Nigeria of those who pillage and plunder Nigeria of resources ... is job number one!
Sweeping corrupt public officials such as Atiku, will guarantee Nigeria's development and greatness


It would appear that Atiku has become a desperado! And in his state of desperation, he is a drowning man, who is clinging to all straws in extreme futility? It is clear that he has so far failed in his attempt to shield himself from the massive corruption probe by the EFCC. We know and trust Mallam Nuhu Ribadu and his EFCC to always, always, get their man!

The Case Against Atiku – By EFCC Written by Nuhu Ribadu , Chairman EFCC
Mallam Nuhu Ribadu and the EFCC deserves the support of all reasonable Nigerians and friends and well-wishers of Nigerians and Nigeria

The fear of arrest, prosecution and imprisonment upon any attempt to return to Nigeria


Mallam 'WMD' Nuhu Ribadu and the EFCC, should be encouraged to please keep up the EXCELLENT work!

Posted by I Love Nigeria| 30.12.2006 17:20

Reply Quote



BiafranPrincessBiafranPrincess is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 6

Ribadu, thanks a lot for this clearly well investigated case. I hope the VP is made to face the music in accordance with the law.

Mallam Ribadu, I would truly wish you'd also investigate the case against the other guilty party of the PTDF SAGA WHO IS NO OTHER THAN MR. PRESIDENT HIMSELF. Infact if Atiku gets 5 years over the PTDF case, then OBJ should get 10 because his own gross misconduct and abuse of the funds is just shocking.

Also could u do us a favor and investigate El Rufai's Abuja land scam scandals? A thief no matter how well groomed and brilliant, is still that-A THIEF. (Also be very careful with the likes of El Rufai who would just want to use u for blanket effect. He knows that if he's associated with u, ur corrupt free persona will falsely rub off on him and he'll look 'clean')

While you're at it, pls could you also investigate Andy Uba's presidential aircraft-money laundering saga and the connection to Otta farm.

Who's fooling who? The EFCC should be making a case for the impeachment and subsequent arrests of both OBJ and ATIKU. Anything short of that is actually going to do this nation more harm because it would amount to catching a small thief and letting the KINGPIN go free. He only ends up breeding more thieves. The good thing in all these is that Atiku is going down with OBJ, (OBJ REALLY miscalculated where Atiku was concerned). its just a matter of time. I have a feeling I have a pretty good idea of what Atiku's final jokers against OBJ would be and if it plays out that way, gosh we're all in for a jolly good ride!

I hope for better things for my country come 2007.

Posted by BiafranPrincess| 30.12.2006 23:17

Reply Quote



killerboykillerboy is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 7

Good work. I still have some reservation about your performance until I see Obj, Atiku, Igbenedion, Bode George and Odili in jail. By the way, is Obj a clog in the wheel of progress in your investigation of Odili?

Posted by killerboy| 31.12.2006 02:50

Reply Quote



Tunde meeeTunde meee is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 8

This is the business as usual we have been complaining about all this while, that same thing Obasanjo promised will not happen in his own time which unfortunately as been the case since he came to power. The unfortunate thing about the whole saga is the way Nuhu ribadu is going about it. His method smacks vendatta or errand boy who has been ordered to do whatever to get Atiku nailed. Otherwise why has he been the prosecutor and the Judge at the same time. Why is he not presuming innocence until proven guilty and why only Atiku among even worse indicted cases of embezzlememt as we have in Bode George and Tony Anenih. His method has made even avowed enemies of corruption to fight for Atiku and thus made them look like they support corruption whereas what they fight against is the obvoius unfairness in the way Atiku is being treated.

Posted by Tunde meee| 31.12.2006 07:30

Reply Quote



gwobezentashigwobezentashi is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 9

A rehash of the same old and tired spurious and fuzzy logic. Did the same Obasanjo not describe Nuhu's similar allegations against some governors as "spurious"? How did the courts describe this report and the Administrative Panel report that flowed from it? Anyone describing the hyperbole as "thorough investigation" probably has never known what a thorough investigation is. The claims can sell tabloid newspapers but can never stand the test of judicial cross examination or scrutiny.

We have debated this report on these pages before and a regurgitation of its shortcomings and demerits do not need restating here. Suffice it to say that it is not worth the paper it is written on and has been shown in the courts to be completely bereft of justiciability. The litany of illegalities committed by the President and his supporters in the management of the economy has somehow escaped Mr Forensic Nuhu in the course of his boju boju "investigations".

The agenda that has unravelled before our eyes remains that of a sit tight despot and Nuhu and his fellow travellers are simply its facilitators. That is the lesson we need to draw from all of this and the hallelujah choristers need to take a chill pill. No one is fooled!


Aluta!



Gwobezentashi

Posted by gwobezentashi| 31.12.2006 08:09

Reply Quote



MrOneNaijaMrOneNaija is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 10

NUHU RIBADU: THE CASE AGAINST A RABID ATTACK DOG

That Nuhu Ribadu is Obasanjo's partisan attack dog is no longer in doubt. Through his vile, reckless and illegal activities carried out in the name of that Gestapo called the EFCC, the tout extraordinaire has consistently preferred to operate from the only comfort zone he knows - the gutter of perfidy and mendacious grandstanding.

My commentary on this vermin of Nigerian politics can be accessed at the following link:
http://www.nigeriavillagesq...

DRIVING NUHU RIBADU OUT OF TOWN

Written by Aonduna Tondu
Sunday, 08 October 2006
DRIVING NUHU RIBADU OUT OF TOWN

The EFCC is a good example of a noble idea gone awry. Faced with the rabble-rousing histrionics of its mercurial head called Nuhu Ribadu and the glaring evidence that both the outfit and its chairman have become tools in the service of a dictator and his anti-people fantasies, Nigerian democrats and those who wish our country well must be alarmed at the prospect of letting Ribadu and the contraption he pretends to lead continue to desecrate our democratic spaces with his resort to violent and illegal tactics that clearly are an affront to the sensibilities of decent, law-abiding citizens. If the truth be told, Nuhu Ribadu has constituted himself into an uncouth loudmouth with a penchant for mafia-style antics. As things now stand, Ribadu’s EFCC has joined the police and the SSS in particular as one of the notable instruments of state being deployed in a criminal and outlaw fashion by His Majesty to constrict Nigeria’s democratic environment with an aim to perpetuating the status quo – a sinister proposition that cannot be in the short or long-term interest of the average Nigerian.


Yet, history has taught us that the type of fool’s paradise being sought after by Obasanjo and his allies is the ultimate challenge or danger that a community can be confronted with. And how well members of that community respond to such a threat to their collective patrimony is bound to determine the course of future development in the society. That is why the next time Ribadu descends on any community with his fellow thugs in the furtherance of the script laid down by his political master, all men and women of goodwill should rise and chase the rascals out of town for the likes of Ribadu and Obasanjo cowardly hide behind the tapestry of pseudo-constitutionalism in order to prosecute their petty agenda of corrupt self-preservation and political partisanship.


There is no gainsaying that Nigerians who have been bruised by decades of corrupt practices on the part of their so-called leaders are yearning for good and morally-conscious representatives. Those who tell them they will fight the plague of 419 and do actually commit themselves to the pledge should become instant heroes. But the moment the initial mission is hijacked and its agents conscripted for unwholesome purposes as is the case in the current witch-hunting and grandstanding the EFCC’s Ribadu has graduated into, Nigerians should not hesitate to call the apostates and their supporters to order. Beyond the obviously selective posture of his relentless, if reckless hounding of figures who in the main are considered as political enemies or associates of enemies of Obasanjo, there is the worrisome question of process, namely, the evidently illegal manner Ribadu, an agent of the Aso Rock tyrant, is going about his supposed business of fighting corruption. The lack of due process that keeps manifesting itself in the EFCC’s actions is troubling and raises more questions as to the commitment of Obasanjo and his henchmen to the sustenance of democracy in Nigeria. As I did stress elsewhere, the corrupt and illegal use of state structures in the so-called anti-corruption campaign is doing more harm than good. The lack of trust in government processes should be a constant source of worry for all. Already, the corrupt use of Ribadu, his EFCC and other fixtures, has ensured that governance at the federal level has been paralyzed for some time now. This is taking its toll on the Nigerian psyche. The Nigerian nation is being held hostage by loathsome types with a disdain for democratic governance. These unpatriotic characters cannot be allowed to have their way. The stakes are just too great for the country.


While Nuhu Ribadu pontificates and noisily denounces politicians and other individuals not considered as politically willing to play ball with Obasanjo, he studiously keeps mute or, worse, obfuscates by wallowing in meanderings of inconsistency and duplicity when confronted with the sleazy and thieving conduct of his master and the cabal he belongs to. For those genuinely seeking after the truth, it must be mentioned that a recent document written by retired Col. Abubakar Umar on the dishonest and hypocritical way the anti-corruption war is being pursued by Ribadu and his gang should be considered as a critical part of any intelligence on the state of the nation under the regime of Baba Aremu. In his sweeping and disparaging remarks against state governors at the National Assembly recently, Ribadu was careful to leave out mentioning where much of the corruption in government offices takes place, namely, the presidency of Matthew Okikiolakan Obasanjo. And one should not ignore the fact that Obasanjo’s family members and henchmen like Bode George, Tony Anenih, and Ahmadu Ali have cases to answer regarding their respective roles in the handling of public money. Surely, Ribadu cannot be taken seriously. He has developed into a quantity of tragic proportions. And the tragic posture of which Ribadu and the EFCC are now an embodiment has once more been on display, this time, in places like Ekiti and Plateau.


In a show of shame reminiscent of the ‘coups d’état’ in Bayelsa and Oyo, Nuhu Ribadu has arrested sitt