Nigeria may cancel arms deal with Israeli firm Print E-mail
Friday, 02 June 2006
By Yossi Melman
haaretz Newspapers, Israel

Following a Haaretz expose, Nigeria may cancel arms deal with Israeli firm
referent report: Israeli drones under African skies

In recent days, several Israelis arrived in the Nigerian capital of Abuja to staff and develop the offices of Aeronautics Ventures. Maoz Steinhauer stands at the helm of the company, which is listed abroad. Aeronautics Ventures is the operant branch in the largest arms deal ever landed by the Yavneh-based Aeronautics Defense Systems company. A report regarding the $260 million deal appeared in Haaretz about a month ago.

The deal involves sales of land and sea drones (that operate from ships) to be used in the defense of the Niger River Delta region. This is the region in which Nigeria, the largest oil-exporting nation in Africa and one of the largest in the world, produces its black gold. During the last year, armed bands of guerrillas and pirates have been systematically attacking pipelines in the region and kidnapping employees of foreign companies, disrupting the function of the oil industry, which is Nigeria's main source of income.

If the deal goes through, it will also be one of the largest in the history of Israel's relations with the African continent (with the exception of the massive military assistance that Israel extended to the apartheid regime in South Africa).

'I was not involved'

Since the Haaretz report, there have been a few new developments in the controversial transaction, and additional information has become available. The central development is a failed attempt by Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo to amend the constitution in order to present his candidacy for a third term in office. Another development is the in-depth report in the widely read Nigerian daily newspaper The Punch and reactions by figures in the Nigerian opposition to the Haaretz report.

As a result of these developments, several individuals credited with a role in the deal were quick to express their reservations and shake off suggestions of any involvement. They may feel that connections with this deal could complicate their future lives. The first among them was the president's national security adviser, General Aliyu Mohammed Gusau. In a telephone conversation with Haaretz, initiated by Gusau, General Gusau emphasized: "I was not involved in negotiations to promote the deal and I was not a partner in it."

Gusau, in his 50s, has been mentioned in the press as a potential candidate in coming presidential elections slated to take place in April, 2007. In the conversation, he described himself as a "friend of Israel" and said that he has visited Israel several times. Like many others in the world, he has tried to help Israel learn the fate of missing navigator Ron Arad. In the second half of the '80s, Gusau served as the head of military intelligence and later as chief of staff of the Nigerian armed forces under former-president General Ibrahim Babangida. Babangida is also mentioned in some circles as a possible candidate for the presidency.

Nigerian Ambassador to Israel Dr. Anthony George Manzo also wished to emphasize several points in relation to the arms deal. The ambassador, a physician, has served in Israel for two years. According to him, he was unaware of the deal and read about it in the Nigerian press following the Haaretz report. "The embassy was not involved in the deal," he said. "We do not have military attaches here and our military attache in Paris fulfilled that function."

Is it natural that the embassy be excluded from a deal like this?

"Absolutely. We are not aware of every financial transaction. It is natural and it happens in many nations around the world." According to Manzo: "Despite the impression left by the [Haaretz] report, the transaction was accepted in a proper and normal decision-making process by the [Nigerian] Ministry of Defense not by the President's Office."

Further investigations by Haaretz, with the assistance of knowledgeable sources in Nigeria, reveal that the President's Office the President and his aides were indeed involved in the decision. President Obasanjo was the nation's military ruler when, in 1979, he became the first ruler on the African continent to return the governing of the nation from the military to the citizens. When he retired from military service, he established an enormous agricultural farm with the assistance of Israeli experts, including Elisha Cohen. The late Cohen, a wealthy contractor, was exposed a few years ago for his involvement in organizing together with the Nigerian intelligence service the attempted kidnapping in London in 1984 of Dr. Umaro Diko. Cohen hired three Israeli mercenaries in order to bring Diko, a former minister of transporation, to trial in Nigeria.

In 1995, Obasanjo was imprisoned following accusations of planning a coup to overthrow the military dictatorship of former president Sani Abacha. In 1999, when the government was, once again, transferred from the army to the citizens, he was elected president of Nigeria and, in 2003, reelected to a second term by a majority of 60 percent.

Unexplained withdrawals

In Obasanjo's attempt to amend the constitution to seek a third term in office, he and his constituents launched a massive and extremely costly campaign to persuade members of the Nigerian House of Assembly to permit him to run for a third term. Nigerian sources claim that a series of questionable transactions and agreements, worth billions of dollars, were signed to provide funding for the pricey campaign. These are mainly government transactions funded by money obtained from oil royalties, controlled by the president, in the nation's central bank. The latest issue of the Nigerian magazine, The News, published an investigation of unexplained withdrawals from oil royalty accounts and revealed that, between October, 2005 and the end of March, almost $2.5 billion were withdrawn. Official spokesmen in the president's office and the government completely deny these claims.

As for the Aeronautics Ventures deal, experts estimate that, according to the value of the equipment, and even if Aeronautics profits from the deal reach 100 percent, the scope of the deal will not exceed $150 million.

The Aeronautics deal is surprising for a number of reasons. First, this is a relatively new company, established less than a decade ago by CEO Avi Leumi. It is true that the company has far-reaching connections in the defense establishment, mainly because retired general Avigdor (Yanush) Ben Gal, former head of the Shin Bet security services Yaakov Perry, and former chief-of-staff and transportation minister Amnon Lipkin-Shahak were members of the board of directors in the past. But Perry left the company more than a year and a half ago, and contrary to information published in the previous article, Lipkin-Shahak also is no longer connected with the company. Only Ben Gal continues to play an active role.

Aeronautics Ventures has never operated in Nigeria, where there is broad activity on the part of Israeli companies. Among others, retired brigadier general Shlomo Ilya and his partners Ben Gal and Meir Dagan (before he was appointed to lead the Mossad) were very active in exporting arms to Nigeria until a few years ago.

How did Aeronautics land the deal ahead of veteran drone producers like the Elbit aeronautics industry? There is no clear answer to this question only speculation. First and foremost, there is no question that the firm successfully spun a web of connections that reached the president of Nigeria. The deal was mediated by Israeli businessman Alon Nelken from Savyon. Nelken, who has played an active role in Nigeria for 25 years, owns the gigantic Mega-Plaza mall in Lagos.

Nelken mediated the transaction despite the fact that he lacks a permit from the Israel Defense Ministry's security assistance division to conduct negotiations involving security exports. He and his partner, Amit Sadeh, held contacts with senior figures in the president's office and the Defense Ministry to promote the deal. Among others, they were in contact with presidential aide Dr. Andy Uba, one of the most influential figures in Nigeria. These contacts culminated in a meeting between Aeronautics CEO Avi Leumi, the president, and Uba. Guidelines for the deal were apparently concluded at that meeting.

The Aeronautics Company refused to respond in this matter.

During the phase in which it became clear to Leumi, Nelken, and Sadeh that the president's office supported the deal, they began to step up the pace of the process from the planning to the implementation stage. Recently, they received an advance which, according to one source, is 10 percent of the deal, while another source maintains that they have already received 50 percent.

At some point, they also contacted Maoz Steinhauer and appointed him to direct the subsidiary company, Aeronautics Ventures. Steinhauer was previously employed, for about six years, by the HPI firm, listed in Switzerland. HPI mainly builds Nigerian seaports.

The Israeli community in Nigeria, which includes a few hundred individuals employed in agricultural, construction, industrial, security, and communications ventures, is abuzz with rumors that Steinhauer "abandoned" his former employers to move along with the deal to Aeronautics. But Steinhauer firmly denies these claims.

In a telephone conversation from Abuja, he responded, "There is no truth in these claims. It is true that I worked for HPI for six years. I decided to leave more than a year ago, and took leave of the company without any anger. It was an amicable resignation with no problems. I traveled to the United States for a given period and was then contacted by Aeronautics. Until then, I knew nothing about the drone project. As far as I know, HPI did not compete for the project at all and was unaware of its existence."

Some maintain that the deal will not go through now that the president has failed to amend the constitution.

"That is completely unrelated. I believe and hope very much that the deal will go through."





RobotRobot is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 1

Posted by Robot| 02.06.2006 08:46

Reply Quote



Citizen KaneCitizen Kane is online 

avatar
 # 2

I stated on an earlier occasion (Read Below) that this deal stinks to high heaven. It is a shame that an Israeli outfit had to do the investigative report on this scandal. Where is the EFCC when people like Alon Nelken (Mega Plaza), Major Anyaya PICCOMS, Amit Sadeh (Professional Israeli Con), Minister of Transport Sekibo etc... are walking around with fat pockets. I hope this is not going to be swept under the carpet and I seriousely doubt if Nigeria can recoup the money already paid Aeronautics


04.05.2006 10:51
#3
Citizen Kane
Re: .Israeli drones under African skies
Scandal: I will tell you people I know a lot more about this deal and I am glad it is coming out. The Federal Government has already paid for half of this contract $130,000,000 not $26,000,000 as the article says. Additionaly, the cost of the entire project should not be even close to $60,000,000. The CEO of the company Avi Lomi has been flying in and out of Nigeria on his private jet and boasting of his ability to buy any Nigerian official with the conivance of Alon Nelken (Mega Plaza). Nigeria is being taken to the cleaners on this one BIG time. Any investigative reporter who really digs into this deal will find it stinks to high heaven. This Avi Lomi guy is not good for Nigeria, Alon Nelken should have been deported long ago as an economic saboteur (find out how much he has paid in custom duties) . God help Nigeria.

Posted by Citizen Kane| 02.06.2006 09:38

Reply Quote



ObserverObserver is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 3

This is a good example of 'TRANSPARENCY' at work. President Obasanjo's major achievement, supporters argue, is his administration's war against corruption. This deal is supposed to be a major defence contract and yet the contract was never advertised either for pre-qualification or for tender. No defence contract can be signed today in any part of the world in secret. Can someone please explain to me the role of 'Due Process' in the deal.

Instead of trying to alleviate the sufferings of the people of the Niger Delta, Obasanjo is busy looking for means of shooting at the people from drones in the sky. Obasanjo should learn that the best way to protect the resources of the Niger Delta is to use the people of the Niger Delta themselves.

This deal is just one of many that have been used to siphon funds from suffering Nigerians. Apart from Obasanjo, the Ubas should also get ready to face the music post-29 May, 2007. I hope the Immigration Service will take note of those whose passports must be seized before the hand-over date next year. This way, they will not be able to escape justice.

Posted by Observer| 02.06.2006 10:03

Reply Quote



AuspiciousAuspicious is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 4

Haha! Maybe - just maybe - there's no use for the drones anymore
because '3rd Term' has been shot-down like a bird in the sky. Hehe!
No need to police the state (Nigeria) with drones that would have been
needed to patrol our skies if '3rd Term' had sailed through causing
tensions to rise and feelings to boil - riots etc. Maybe that's why this
deal 'may' be cancelled. Just a thought.

Posted by Auspicious| 02.06.2006 12:41

Reply Quote



ocnusocnus is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 5

Here's the original article...
Israeli drones under African skies

Yossi Melman, Ha'aretz 21/5/06

A few days ago, the American ambassador in Nigeria met with the Nigerian defense minister, Dr. Rabiu Kwankwaso. The ambassador complained about a major weapons deal that the Nigerian defense ministry had recently signed with the private Israeli company Aeronautics Defense Systems. He was upset that the deal had been given to an Israeli company without an international tender, thereby preventing American companies from bidding. Kwankwaso promised to clarify the issue and get back to him.

But despite the company and the Israeli Defense Ministry's concern over the American intervention, Israeli officials are convinced that the deal will go through.

The deal reflects only a small part of the operations of Aeronautics, a Yavneh-based company that manufactures drones and makes every effort to keep away from the media.

Largest arms deal

This is the largest arms deal that Israel has ever made with Nigeria. It was signed in the Nigerian capital in March between a local daughter company of Aeronautics and the Nigerian defense ministry. The Israeli company has agreed to design, develop, manufacture, install and prepare for operation three Aerostar Unmanned Aerial Vehicle intelligence systems and three Seastar systems for aerial and marine use. Each Aerostar system includes between three and six small unmanned planes, and each plane is equipped with sensors and cameras with both day- and night-vision capabilities. The drones can remain in the air for up to 14 hours.

The Seastar systems have drones that operate from ships and will be used by the Nigerian navy in the Delta region of the Niger River, an oil-rich area that in the last few months has become a battlefield where militias and guerrilla groups are fighting the federal government.

The increasing demand for oil and the hike in oil prices has turned the area into a strategically important region that serves as a focus of activity for American, British and French oil companies - and recently, also Chinese, Russian and Korean companies.

The Aeronautics deal is unusually large for Nigeria, which recently agreed to purchase 15 warplanes and flight training planes from China for a quarter of a billion dollars - $10 million less than it is paying for the Israeli deal.

The aggressive operating and marketing methods practiced by Aeronautics, which was founded in 1997 and is not selective in its choice of clients, have embroiled it in international scandals and a police inquiry over the last two years.

The company's expertise lies in supplying intelligence systems, primarily via drones. At first it won a tender to supply drone services to the IDF for activity in the Gaza area.

Aeronautics beat out Israel Aircraft Industries by offering its services at low prices. With an IDF contract in its pocket, Aeronautics was able to boast, as other manufacturers do, that the system had "proven itself in battle."

The early success whetted the appetite of the small company, which soon began ogling international markets. Aeronautics began operating in African countries, in the midst of civil war, whose corrupt regimes had a rich history of civil-rights violations, such as Equatorial Guinea.

The company's official Web site states that it is now active in India, the United States, England, Ethiopia, Russia, Nepal and Taiwan.

Ivory Coast dealings

In 2005 Aeronautics sold drones to the army of the Ivory Coast, involved in a civil war, while a French peace force was located there. A French unit gained control of Aeronautics equipment and destroyed it.

The Israeli involvement angered France, which demanded that Israel's Defense Ministry instruct Aeronautics and other Israeli companies to cut all ties with the Ivory Coast immediately and obey UN sanctions.

After a delay of several months, Israel was compelled to join countries around the world in imposing sanctions and halting the export of weapons to the Ivory Coast.

It was another episode that led to a police investigation of Aeronautics. The inquiry centered around the suspicion that the company had transferred information to a company in Russia without the Israeli government's permission. The Defense Ministry official responsible for security, Yehiel Horev, has been able to demand serious indictments for similar, suspected violations in the past, but the case was closed in this instance; the official reason was that the company was suspected of "technical violations."

A blind eye

This forgiving attitude toward Aeronautics gave people involved in the security export field the impression that the company had high-level patrons. Its board of directors and consultants include Major General Avigdor ("Yanush") Ben-Gal and former IDF chief of staff Amnon Lipkin-Shahak, and previously included former Shin Bet security service head Yaakov Perry as well. Perry said he left the company more than a year ago and was not involved in the Nigeria deal. Ben-Gal did not respond to a Haaretz request for comment.

Two Israeli businessmen - Alon Nelken from Savyon and Amit Sadeh, who represents him in Nigeria - mediated the Aeronautics-Nigeria deal. Both are well-connected to Nigerian government officials. To seal the deal, they enlisted the help of former Nigerian president General Ibrahim Babangida, who convinced the country's national security adviser - Lieutenant General Aliyu Mohammed Gusau, a powerful figure in Nigeria - of the importance of the Aeronautics deal.

Nelken, 52, came to Nigeria about 25 years ago as a representative of Israeli construction company Solel Boneh. He stayed there, working as a real estate entrepreneur and the owner of a security consulting company. He owns, among other projects, the Mega Plaza mall in Lagos.

The Nigerian government has already paid an advance of 10 percent ($26 million) for the Aeronautics deal, and some $5 million of that amount has been allocated to various agents.

Nelken and Sadeh are not listed in the Israeli Defense Ministry's security assistance division, apparently indicating that they are not allowed to be involved in security exports from Israel or even to conduct negotiations related to such imports. In response to a query on this matter, Aeronautics said: "This is a question that Nelken must be asked." Nelken confirmed that he had been involved in the deal, but refused to describe the extent of his involvement. The Defense Ministry did not respond to questions on the matter.

Nelken and Auronautics said the company had won the tender legally, beating out an American company, and is operating with the coordination and approval of the Israeli Defense Ministry.

History of close ties

Israel and Nigeria - the most populated country in Africa - share a history of close ties. Israeli companies operate in Nigeria in the fields of infrastructure, communications and agriculture. Hundreds of Israelis live there and ships belonging to the Israeli Zim shipping company stop at Nigerian ports. The two countries have long had security ties, and Israeli companies have previously sold Nigeria weapons for its police and military forces and its intelligence services.

Until a few years ago, Israeli Brigadier General (Res.) Shlomo Ilya was one of the major players in the supply of arms and security equipment to Nigeria. At the time, he was joined by Ben-Gal and Meir Dagan, now head of the Mossad.

Several Israeli companies operate in the Niger Delta, including JDP, which is owned by the Ashtrom International construction group and SCC, owned by Yosef Kalish from Haifa (who also owns the Sharbiv construction company in Israel.)

These companies are involved in infrastructure and agriculture initiatives and employ hundreds of workers.

Good for the State of Israel?

The Israeli embassy in Abuja was in on the secret contacts. Ambassador Noam Katz refused to discuss the issue, but an official Israeli source said that the deal involved "equipment that doesn't shoot," and that it was good for the State of Israel, especially in light of Nigeria's strengthened position as one of the world's major oil exporters.

However, some Israelis - and not just business competitors - are criticizing the deal. They say they are concerned that the presence of Israeli arms in Nigeria, especially in the Delta region, is liable to have negative ramifications. An Israeli businessman warned there was a fear that "due to the deal, the local population, with which we have excellent ties, will identify Israel and Israelis with its enemies."

Posted by ocnus| 06.06.2006 12:00

Reply Quote


Last Updated ( Wednesday, 23 April 2008 )
 

Services : E-mail news | RSS Feeds | Podcasts
Links:   About the NVS | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies | Advertise With Us
All Rights Reserved. NigeriaVillageSquare.com