"Nigerians abroad are inconsequential" - Frank Nweke Print E-mail
Written by Laolu Akande   
Monday, 27 November 2006
LAOLU AKANDE
NEW YORK
 
What really is the view the Nigerian government regarding Nigerians abroad?
 
Many abroad are no longer certain pointing specifically to two incidents. One an outburst on VOA TV by the Information Minister that Nigerians abroad are inconsequential and are ignorant of events back at home. The other is a recent advert in a national paper implying that Nigerians abroad are considered in adversarial terms by the government.
 
Indications are that Nigerians abroad are concerned that the federal government continue to send conflicting signals about them. The controversial statement made by the Information Minister Frank Nweke on a Voice of America television program recently is causing ripples among Nigerians here in the US.
 
Professor Steve Nwabuzor, a college teacher and President of the Nigerian Leadership Foundation criticised the Minister saying the comment "reminds one of an ignoramus. In countries where those in government are responsive to the needs of their people, such a comment should have not arisen. Nweke is spouting the unpatriotic inclinations that have infected the current crop of Nigerian leaders."
 
Another Nigerian community leader here Alhaji Salisu Abdullah, the National Treasurer of the Zumunta Organisation, an ethnic association of Nigerians from the North based in the US also expressed surprise.
"I am very surprise at the comments made by the Minister of Information. This is directly opposite to the speech he delivered to us during the Diaspora Day in Abuja on July 26, 2006.  
 
 
In that VOA TV programme, Africa Journal, a panel discussion moderated by host Vincent Makori,  Nweke in response to critical reviews of the Nigerian government by two other panelists, had said on the live broadcast that Nigerians abroad are "inconsequential," and are ignorant of what is happening in Nigeria.
The panel included Makori, Nweke and also Sunday Dare, Hausa Service Chief of the VOA and Emmanuel Ogebe, a Washington D.C. based US Special Legal Consultant on Nigeria. Both Dare and Ogebe are US based Nigerian professionals.

Nweke's outburst is seen as a marked departure from its often repeated stance on the importance of  all Nigerians including those in the Diaspora to the development of the country.

Other members of the panel, particularly the 2 other Nigerians, Dare and Ogebe persistently queried the Information Ministers on why Nigerians remained largely poor after 7-8 years of democratic rule and inspite of the fact that Nigeria remained the 5th largest oil supplier to the US.

But Nweke also pounded the panel back saying it was not as if America itself was perfect pointing to the Katrina Hurricane tragedy, and such other "inconsistencies" in the United State of America, adding that  "we come there a lot so we know what is going on (in America) as well."

At a point, a live caller from London later called during the show describing the response of the Minister as similar to having a "conversation with the deaf."
A high-point during the live panel chat was when Dare, challenged the minister's claim that the Obasanjo government has made Nigeria better than it met it in 1999. Dare cautioned the Minister and the Obasanjo administration not to take ordinary Nigerians for granted.

In response, a visibly shaken Nweke lost his cool and accused Dare of inciting Nigerians against the Obasanjo government on prime time American television. An accusation, Dare swiftly rejected, insisting he was exercising his right of free speech as a Nigerian and a professional journalist.
Reacting to the VOA TV show, a US based Nigerian pointed to yet another example of what he called mixed signals from the federal government to Nigerians abroad.

According to Professor Bolaji Aluko, a chemical engineering teacher at Howard University, Washington DC he saw an advert in a national weekly(Sunday Punch, November 19, 2006, page 33,) put out by the Federal Ministry of Information and National Orientation, for the Heart of Africa project. The advert he said had imposed pictures of the handsome face of a pensive young man, and then another of himself, his wife and new-born baby.

Quoting from the advert, Aluko read the words attributed to the man out thus: "I was 24 years old. Now I'm 30. I read Secretarial Administration in Auchi Polytechnic and graduated with a lower credit at age 24. I went into bee farming when I could not secure a job. A number of my friends traveled abroad. I chose to remain in Nigeria. Many of them are frustrated in foreign lands. I've become very successful today. WHY? I chose to believe in myself and my country. You can do the same. Believe in yourself. Believe in Nigeria."

He then observed that  "the adversarial implications (of the advert on Nigerians abroad) speak for themselves, stressing that "there is simply no excuse for the tone of the advert, unless that is what it really means. It is part of the mixed signals that various members of this Administration send out," to and about Nigerians abroad."

The Chairman of the federal government-backed Nigerians in Diaspora Organization, NIDO, in the Americas, himself a very successful medical doctor, and entrepreneur based in Canada, Ola Kassim in his reaction could not believe that the Information Minister made the reported remarks that Nigerians abroad are inconsequential on the VOA TV and therefore chose not to believe it.

He said he will reserve "my full comments on the statement" of Minister of Information. Kassim observed that such a statement  " is totally out of character for Mr. Frank Nweke Jnr. to have made."
But when confronted with the advert that Aluko had seen in a major Nigerian newspaper, the NIDO chairman Ola Kassim could no longer take it, noting that the advert placed by Nweke's Information Ministry is "extremely distasteful. The ad has the potential to promote an adversarial relationship between two groups of Nigerians--those based at home and those living abroad." He threatened to "send a letter of protest to Mr Frank Nweke Jnr., The Hon. federal Minister of Information."
 
 
But Nwabuzor added that the comment about the 'inconsequentiality of Diasporan Nigerians' tells a lot about the effect these Nigerians are having in exposing the deceit, hypocrisy and shenanigan that are running the failed state called Nigeria, and for which Nweke as Minister has knowingly accepted to be the epitome of misinformation and denial."

Salisu Abdullah wondered "How can anybody describe the money the Nigerians in Disapora wire through Western Union estimated to be about $5B, to be considered "inconsequential."? What about the computers, medical services, equipments etc that we give freely to our communities back home? He should go and tell our families back home and see if they will agree with him."
Abdullah wondered how somebody like Nweke "work with us to help develop our country?"

A panelist on the VOA TV show where Nweke made the statement, Emmanuel Ogebe also stated that he was dumbfounded by the comments especially "since I was at the Diaspora event in Nigeria a few weeks ago and Okonjo Iweala commended us for the over billion dollars we injected into the economy. The president said the same thing to me on that visit."

According to Ogebe, "Nweke is joining a long line of ministers who believe it is their duty to sacrifice themselves on the altar of psychophancy just like the Abacha era when a Minister accused Mandela of being mental because of his time in prison. He is not the first or the last Minister of information who will betray his generation for political expedience."
 
In a similar vein, Mr. Bukola Oreofe, an accountant and Secretary of the Nigerian Democratic Liberty Forum asked " How in the world would someone say that a population of "10million people" do not matter?"He went on to say "the failure of the Nigerian government to economically provide for the people at home would have had worse impact without the billions of dollars in remittances by Nigerians abroad. "
Oreofe said the Minister needed to know the policy of the government he serves which initiated and supports the Nigerian Diaspora Organization (NIDO), whose members were also invited to the failed constitutional review conference.

His words: "This preposterous comment mirrors the intelligence of this cabinet member who actually meant to say that Nigerians are inconsequential regardless of where they reside. Otherwise if Nigerians matter how does he explain seven years that has recorded the most revenue in the history of the existence of the country and this period has also recorded most people being pushed below the poverty line?
 
Oreofe continued: "How does he explain to the people the ridicule and opprobrium the country is brought to through the laundering of state funds using the presidential aircraft by the aide of the president and part of the funds used to procure equipment for the Obasanjo farms and government has accorded that a deafening silence because the people are inconsequential? If Nigerians matter the President, Vice Presidential etc. would not have presided over the death of public schools while they shamelessly build private schools and universities for the children of the rich while the children of the poor masses are left uneducated."

The New York based accountant then observed that "If this is the mindset of a federal minister we should not be surprised why our country is what it is today."



RobotRobot is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 1


What really is the view the Nigerian government regarding Nigerians abroad? Many a...Read the full article.

Posted by Robot| 27.11.2006 10:27

Reply Quote



techsistatechsista is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 2

Nweke is probably not aware of the work done by development economics professor, Una Okonkwo Osili on remittances from Nigerians in the US to their families back in Nigeria. Looks like he also hasn't seen the IMF figures that show over $1.3 billion dollars in remittances to Nigeria from Nigerians in the diaspora between 1995 and 1998. The IMF report estimates that the amount remitted to Nigeria by Nigerians in the diaspora equals the capital flight from Nigeria and the foreign direct investment in Nigeria during the period studied. In other words, Nigerians in the diaspora soften the blow that results when corrupt politicians stash Nigerian money in overseas bank. If they stopped the remittances cold, Nweke and his ilk would probably be necklaced and roasted in public like common thieves by an irate population determined at last to hold poor Nigerian rulers accountable for their mismanagement. He should be grateful.

Posted by techsista| 27.11.2006 13:36

Reply Quote



AbraxasAbraxas is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 3

Hi, folks!


=techsista;139868>Nweke is probably not aware of the work done by development economics professor, Una Okonkwo Osili on remittances from Nigerians in the US to their families back in Nigeria. Looks like he also hasn't seen the IMF figures that show over $1.3 billion dollars in remittances to Nigeria from Nigerians in the diaspora between 1995 and 1998. The IMF report estimates that the amount remitted to Nigeria by Nigerians in the diaspora equals the capital flight from Nigeria and the foreign direct investment in Nigeria during the period studied. In other words, Nigerians in the diaspora soften the blow that results when corrupt politicians stash Nigerian money in overseas bank. If they stopped the remittances cold, Nweke and his ilk would probably be necklaced and roasted in public like common thieves by an irate population determined at last to hold poor Nigerian rulers accountable for their mismanagement. He should be grateful.



Would it not have been better if Nweke and his ilk are necklaced and roasted in public like common criminals by an irate population determined at last to hold Nigerian rulers accountable for their crass incompetence, mind blowing corruption, and gross mismanagement?

Consequently, should remitances from the Nigerian Diaspora to Nigeria be stopped, if only to enable the roasting of the common criminals to begin in ernest?

Muchas gracias.

Don Juan Carlos ABRAXAS (III)

Posted by Abraxas| 27.11.2006 14:11

Reply Quote



villageHeadMastervillageHeadMaster is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 4

I agree in part to the comments attributed to the honourable Minister of Misinformation.
IMHO, Nigerians in the Diaspora (NID) are inconsequential when it comes to influencing the policies and actions of the current pseudo-democratic dispensation.

Of course, one cannot dispute the fact that NID like many other African donors, have pumped in their own fair share of billions into Nigeria. However, what tangible difference have these monies made other than increase the divide between the haves and have-nots (- e.g. those who don’t have people abroad to remit to them are still languishing in poverty)?

Furthermore, techsista says that stopping remittance will result in the demise of the Minister and his ilks. I don’t agree for two reasons:

1. I don’t see NID collectively stopping the flow of remittance and thus influencing the actions of the people or the people who govern them in the manner suggested by techsista; and

2. Even if NID (unlikely as it may seem) is somehow able to collectively stop remittance, the Minister and his ilks don’t depend on NID’s funds or public goodwill to carryout their nefarious activities.

I think NID will do well in taking the Minister’s criticism (constructive or otherwise) as a challenge to up their ante and go from sending Western Union cash to their relatives and friends (much of which is wasted and not used to create wealth) to making their influenced felt in the very important sphere of governance; for it is here, I bellieve, that they are most likely to make the most impact.

Posted by villageHeadMaster| 28.11.2006 02:20

Reply Quote



AkinyiAkinyi is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 5

They will not establish avenues for you ( the nigerian diasporan) to vote in absentia.

They do not give a 'fork' (you know the real FU word) whether you languish in jail.

They (the naija democrazy govt) do not give a rat's ass if you are arrested and tortured in any foreign land.

They don't even care about you so they close the available consulates here and there.

Does your embassy care about Nigerians in diaspora-- Nigerians in London have written numerous articles about how our affairs are treated there. Nigerians in Lebanon wrote an article about a non existent evacuation during the debacle between Israel and Hezbollah. Such evacuation was however widely written and advertised in the nigerian useless newspapers as if an evacuation really took place.

Why is Minister Nweke's outburst any surprise to you? Your are surprised? Then you are not a diasporan Nigerian. If you are, you must ask why you left Nigeria in the first place.

Posted by Akinyi| 28.11.2006 03:58

Reply Quote



GASHIGASHI is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 6

Now, that Nigerians in the Disaspora know what the regime in Abuja thinks
about them, will they learn to reduce their fawnings and yessiring before OBJ
each time he appears in their locations and gathers them to dish out one of those his outdated ideas?

Posted by GASHI| 28.11.2006 06:16

Reply Quote



Bolaji AlukoBolaji Aluko is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 7

Dear Colleagues:

I have met the young, dynamic and passionate-about-Nigeria Minister Frank Nweke a number of times - including once in July 2006 for about one hour in his office in Abuja, just three of us (Frank, another colleague and I) - and he does sincerely value the contributions of members of the Diaspora.

Consequently, I sincerely believe that Nweke should be given some slack: I do not believe that he believes that we in the Diaspora are "inconsequential."

However, I was far more troubled by the adversarial Punch advert, which might have been the result of very poor vetting.

The advert should be pulled, and such like it which places staying back in Nigeria as a litmus test for patriotism should not be repeated.

I rest my case.


Bolaji Aluko

Posted by Bolaji Aluko| 28.11.2006 06:49

Reply Quote



techsistatechsista is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 8


=Bolaji Aluko;139922>Dear Colleagues:

I have met the young, dynamic and passionate-about-Nigeria Minister Frank Nweke a number of times - including once in July 2006 for about one hour in his office in Abuja, just three of us (Frank, another colleague and I) - and he does sincerely value the contributions of members of the Diaspora.

Consequently, I sincerely believe that Nweke should be given some slack: I do not believe that he believes that we in the Diaspora are "inconsequential."

However, I was far more troubled by the adversarial Punch advert, which might have been the result of very poor vetting.

The advert should be pulled, and such like it which places staying back in Nigeria as a litmus test for patriotism should not be repeated.

I rest my case.


Bolaji Aluko



Thanks Prof. Aluko for giving us more information on the minister. I'll take it that he got a little hot under the collar at the line of questioning he received and lashed out without thinking too hard.

@villageHeadmaster
I think you misunderstood my point. If you remove the amount that Nigerians in the diaspora send home (note: - they don't send money only to the "haves", - the impact of the money for say building a house is gainful employment for many), ordinary Nigerians would feel the full brunt of their rulers' corruption and maybe do something about it. I'm not suggesting that anyone should stop sending money to their relatives and friends, just pointing out what the consequences would be if they did. We insulate the population from some of the effects of corruption and we also provide a lifeline to some families in need. Every other diaspora is proud of their contributions to their home countries. Why should Nigeria's be any different?

@Akinyi
Many Nigerians have lodged complaints about shabby treatment at various ports of entry. It's more effective when a Nigerian ambassador does it in his/her official capacity than when individuals take up that task. If you look at the rest of the world, people are cautious in mistreating citizens of a country when they know that country will aggressively defend its people, not because they are afraid the individual mistreated will lodge a complaint. You are right about the Nigerian govt not caring - security guards at the consulate general in New York chased away Nigerians who ran there during the September 11 attacks (don't know what those Nigerians were thinking anyway). That treatment prompted someone I know to finally get US citizenship!

That said, we have a seven year old democracy. In time, Nigerians in the diaspora will lobby for voting rights and will be able to point to countries like Senegal and Rwanda that have granted this right to their citizens abroad.

Posted by techsista| 28.11.2006 07:39

Reply Quote



Tunde meeeTunde meee is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 9

I don't know why Prof. Aluko came to the rescue of this man at this point in time. He should have left us to send a meesage through him to his boss and all his likes who erroneously thought staying back in Nigeria is a test of patriotism.

The pain is that this errorneous opinion is not held by the rulers alone, belief it or not some of your contemporaries also hold same opinion. Once, a guy (on holiday from Nigeria) appeared on a phone in political programme in London and expressed such opinion. By the time he had the worst of about six other caller's tongue, he had to call back to apologise and confess that he was ignorant of a lot of things which other callers had explained (albeit abusive).

Some of this ignorants does not even know that people in the diaspora are much more better placed to understand the situation at home than even those in there. The only aspect of it we don't know (and we pray never to know again) is the personal experience of the current situation.

Posted by Tunde meee| 28.11.2006 08:46

Reply Quote



GASHIGASHI is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 10

Policy Framework For A Mutual Beneficial Relationship Between Nigeria And Nigerians In The Diaspora
------------------------------------------------------

REPORT OF THE DIASPORA POLICY REVIEW GROUP

http://naijanet.com/news/source/2006/nov/21/1000.html

Posted by GASHI| 28.11.2006 08:55

Reply Quote


Last Updated ( Thursday, 24 April 2008 )
 
< Prev   Next >

Services : E-mail news | RSS Feeds | Podcasts
Links:   About the NVS | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies | Advertise With Us
All Rights Reserved. NigeriaVillageSquare.com