It is one thing for the Nigerian Finance Minister, Dr Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala to claim that her government is “increasingly successful” in its anti-corruption crusade and another to accuse Mr Michael Peel of ignoring these so-called successes.

" /> Re: Dr Okonjo-Iweala's response to Michael Peel - Nigerian Village Square

23

Oct

2005

Re: Dr Okonjo-Iweala's response to Michael Peel PDF Print E-mail
By Kennedy Emetulu

There is no doubt that those truly familiar with the writings of Mr Peel - whether as contributor to the regular FT Special Reports on Nigeria or in separate reports - would find it hard to accuse him of ignoring anything, especially where they are facts relating to the issue he writes on. The man is a consummate professional who knows more about Nigeria than most top journalists out there. He’s not given to sensationalism, but rather presents the facts in a way that the reader is left in no doubt that he’s done all he can as a journalist to provide the relevant information. In the criminally contrived opacity that is the Nigerian public service, Mr Peel’s determination to ask the uncomfortable questions and shine the light where angels dread to tread is a breath of fresh air.

Now, while I’m not going to waste time here detailing the countless corruption cases that are being conveniently overlooked (including allegations against the President, some of his children, family members and political affiliates), suffice it to say Mr Peel is absolutely right when he observed that “while a few important changes have been made, other measures are more complicated or less impressive than they might seem”. In fact, his claim that many Nigerians “have very mixed feelings about the corruption prosecutions, welcoming the start of action they see as long overdue while noting that those being pursued appear mainly to be enemies of President Olusegun Obasanjo or otherwise politically expendable” is the unvarnished truth. It is instructive that the minister did not contradict anything Mr Peel said, but merely offered excuses. At best, she’s trying too hard to sell the so-called successes.

Dr Okonjo-Iweala will have to deal with the facts as they are, not question those of us, like Mr Peel, discerning enough to notice the huge chinks in her government’s armour. What she considers as successes are to some of us minimalist and sometimes hypocritical responses to the huge challenges she herself acknowledges. They smack more of attempts to create an impression than genuine efforts at addressing the problem.




Your Comments

Please make The Square an enjoyable experience for everyone by refraining from gratuitous ad-hominem contributions, defamatory comments and off-topic posting. Such posts will be removed.

User Avatar
RobotRobot is offline

 # 1 | 23.10.2005 08:00

Link to the article is here

User Avatar
iyke_101iyke_101 is online

 # 2 | 23.10.2005 09:28

The contribution of Mr. Kennedy Emetulu on the Finance Minister is somehow dubious. I find it hard to understand why we all tried to pursue shadow instead of the issue.

The question that some of us ask is; Since the introduction of Dr. Mrs. Okonjo-Iweala as Finance Minister, has there been changes in the way that government is run, especially as regards transparency in the nations finances.

The answer to this is YES. I think that we need to appreciate the fact that prior to her coming to office, the finance ministry under Chiroma, stinks. Today, it might not be at the best but there is hope that we are going somewhere- somewhere better.

Mr. Peel has the right to his opinion but that does not mean it is what the general opinion is. Some of you in the diaspora need to come home and make your contributions instead of criticizing the efforts of those willing to make the difference. If we agree that the problem of Nigeria is enormous, then we should also put into cognizance the simple fact that it is easy to destroy but takes longer to build. Especially when you need to change a system like ours where corruption is the \"norm\"
norm

User Avatar
mhbmhb is online

 # 3 | 23.10.2005 11:04

\"All these jealousy and envy coming from my enemies\", apology to Tupac Shakur.

Mr. Emetulu, who has been a jealous and jobless lawyer from time immemorial, has found another energy to continue the show of envy against the Hon. Minister who is deserving of every cent/dollar received since assuming office.

Mr. Emetulu does not have credibility here on NVS and after a couple of years wasted by trying to discredit credible people, he decided to lay low only for him to rear his ugly head again when the Hon. Minister\'s name was mentioned again.

My only question for him now is, would he accept the same deal if he were the Hon. Minister and in the same circumstances? If yes, then shut up for good. If no, then, may be he should lobby hard for an appointment or elective office or even join or establish an NGO in promoting a better Nigeria, where he would give all of his energy and time for a pittance after having established himself and his family abroad like the Minister has done.


myhotbrain.


User Avatar
shitbrain.comshitbrain.com is online

 # 4 | 23.10.2005 13:52

how do u sleep at night defending looters with so many wives, do u understand that some of these woman were taken from a dudu brain like urs.

User Avatar
GoddyGoddy is online

 # 5 | 23.10.2005 14:03

Mister, it\'s high time someone told you to go get a life! Abeg, why are you always miserable? Na so so whine whine! Don\'t you ever see anything good in any one except your posturing, righteous self?

User Avatar
GuestGuest is online

 # 6 | 23.10.2005 17:01

right time for you to mind ur sleezy business. if this is sign of miserable then you\'re in full blown assault. l imbibe in my righteousness, motivation to say it like is it. if you don\'t have answers to my questions then comment on the subject. you obviously need another set of eyes or douse of I.Q to see good.

User Avatar
KennKenn is offline

 # 7 | 23.10.2005 17:14



Iyke,

>>>The contribution of Mr. Kennedy Emetulu on the Finance Minister is somehow dubious. I find it hard to understand why we all tried to pursue shadow instead of the issue.

The question that some of us ask is; Since the introduction of Dr. Mrs. Okonjo-Iweala as Finance Minister, has there been changes in the way that government is run, especially as regards transparency in the nations finances.

The answer to this is YES. I think that we need to appreciate the fact that prior to her coming to office, the finance ministry under Chiroma, stinks. Today, it might not be at the best but there is hope that we are going somewhere- somewhere better.

User Avatar
KennKenn is offline

 # 8 | 23.10.2005 17:16



Iyke,

I do not intend to turn this into a prolonged exchange between us, but I feel it is necessary to set you straight on the issue here. Now, you think the issue is whether or not the stewardship of Mrs Okonjo-Iweala has brought some changes (positive, I suppose) “in the way that government is run, especially as regards transparency in the nations finances”; but I don’t think that is the issue here, even though I have my own opinion about the changes she might have brought to that office.

The fact of the matter here is that Mrs Okonjo-Iweala is not speaking only on behalf of her ministry or what she is doing; she is acting as the spokesperson for the entire government and its supposed fight against corruption. She is not the Minister of Information or the Secretary to the Government of the Federation, but she possibly felt that she has the credibility and name big enough to counter Michael Peel of the Financial Times. So, she’s taken it upon herself to speak for the entire government.

Now, as I mentioned above, it’s one thing for her to eulogize whatever her government is doing (even if some of us do not agree with her assessment), but it’s quite another thing to try to discredit a consummate professional like Mr Peel. I personally do not know Mr Peel, but I know his editor and I know how much effort they put in to get their story right.

By reputation, I know Mr Peel is regarded as a very credible member of their African team; he’s lived in Lagos, traveled widely within the country and have written extensively on Nigerian issues. To accuse him of ignoring the “increasing successes” the government is making simply because he’s discerning enough to see that the corruption fight is “half-hearted”, even as he acknowledges that “some few important changes have been made” is unfair.

The worst thing you can accuse a principled journalist of is to say he ignores facts. Mrs Okonjo-Iweala could have simply said he may not be aware of these facts. In that case, Mr Peel would have been compelled to show that he’s aware of these things Mrs Okonjo-Iweala describes as “increasing successes”, including pointing out those he considers as real successes and those he thinks are “half-hearted”. However, to say he ignores them is to imply that he knows, but for reasons best known to him, he’s not acknowledging them. Mrs Okonjo-Iweala is attacking Mr Peel’s credibility and it is left for those of us who’ve known him through his writings and who happen to believe this very report of his to defend his integrity.

So, I’m not concerned here at least with whether or not Okonjo-Iweala is a successful or failed Finance Minister or whether she is better or worse than her predecessors, not only because such a question is otiose within the larger picture of the general perception of this government, but also because, as I said, it is simply not the issue here. Here, she’s acting as a spokesperson for the whole government and in doing so she impugns the professional integrity of the person she’s responding to. All I have done is to point out that Mr Peel got it right.

Ironically, the fact that Mrs Okonjo-Iweala admits to the case of oil theft (oil being the “soul” of our nation) simply supports Mr Peel’s assertion. Two navy top brass and a few criminal elements stealing oil are not the real problem. You know and I know that serving and retired military officers and very well-connected persons at the top, Nigerians and foreigners, are behind this affair. Mrs Okonjo-Iweala may actually not know much about this since the President is the Minister of Petroleum as well. Thus, I would have expected her to defend her work and what she’s doing at her ministry, rather than choose to speak for the entire government. However, having done so, she must be ready to be held to the standard expected.



User Avatar
GuestGuest is online

 # 9 | 24.10.2005 00:50

Grow up and get a real job. Agbaya.
 

Services : E-mail news | RSS Feeds | Podcasts
Links:   About the NVS | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies | Advertise With Us
All Rights Reserved. NigeriaVillageSquare.com