Home arrow Authors arrow Guest Articles arrow Vacation Dispatch: A Taste of Black on Black Racism in Jamaica
Vacation Dispatch: A Taste of Black on Black Racism in Jamaica Print E-mail
Written by A. G. Ahmed   
Tuesday, 11 March 2008

 

I came to Boscobel Beach on vacation but what did I get? A rude awakening to the real world of racial profiling in Jamaica. An awakening to the fact that no matter who you are or where you are, as long you are black, you will be treated poorly even by another black man. I am so disgusted by the blatant differential and discriminatory treatment that was meted out to me at my hotel that I could not sleep through the night. I kept turning and tossing and couldn’t get the incident out of my mind so I wrote this at 2:00 am in the hope that I could go to sleep afterwards.

So what was it that I am upset about? Having arrived at this resort and unable to access the internet for over 24 hours, I decided to approach the front desk for assistance. Yes, I am very cognizant of my addiction to the internet. At the desk, I saw three men standing at a computer and waited for over ten minutes for help. I was completely ignored. Please note that I was the only customer for the entire period. Soon, a Caucasian family - a couple and their two children - arrived at the desk and were instantly accorded a red carpet reception by the staff who still hadn’t acknowledged my presence. I couldn’t believe what had just happened. I had just been told that I was too black to be noticed by a fellow black man from Jamaica. I felt insulted.

I never expected this in Jamaica of all places. But what was I thinking? I should read the ominous signals correctly. The signs were written everywhere, from the doorman’s attitude to cleaning lady’s demeanour, from the dinning room to the poolside. I sensed something different from the moment I arrived at 3 o’clock this morning. Some of the problems include insufficient toiletries, no hot water, and being ignored in the restaurants. What a place? I have been to Jamaica before but this is my first time at Boscobel Beaches and you bet it is my worst experience.

So what did I do about it?  Well, concerning my front desk encounter, I requested to speak with the manager on duty. A lady came up and introduced herself as the manager. I asked if we could go into her office because I wanted to save her the embarrassment of letting the world know that racism exists even in Jamaica.  I was later made to understand that the phenomenon is classism, not racism. In her office, I proceeded to tell her what had just happened. Another lady showed up midway and also introduced her self as the manager. I repeated my story to the second manager (too many chiefs eeh?).

The two ladies “apologized” on behalf of their staff and defended their organization. In the ten-minute encounter with these managers, I was lectured on how far and wide one of the mangers had travelled. I was told that in Jamaica, the colour of your skin does not count but your social class does. I was told that in Jamaica, racism is not a problem but classism definitely is. I was made to understand that since there was no way the front desk staff could tell my social class, they had to resort to a default mode: treat all black men, including Jamaican blacks, as less important. You read me right. A black man has only one role at Boscobel Beach, Ocho Rios and that is as a servant. No more.

The manager probably did not understand the import of what she said but I heard her loud and clear. As a black man, my place in society is well defined for me by the system and the people in that system regardless of my economic or academic status. The manager reminded all of us, including the three front desk staff, that “One Love” (a popular Jamaican slogan) does not translate to “Equal Right and Justice”. Although Bob Marley tried, his legacy is fading away very fast in Jamaica. Bob’s kin are treating fellow blacks with disrespect right here in Jamaica. “Yea mon” no matter where you come from as long as you are a black man, you don’t have a say if a Caucasian is present.  Why? Because whiteness equals affluence and black equals poverty in Jamaica.

By the way, you wonder whether the manager asked me what I wanted at front desk in the first place and attempted to solve my problem, don’t you? Well, she did not have the time for that. She was too busy protecting her staff and the interest of “the right social class” to consider my plight to be of any significance. I love Jamaica and I will be back but I don’t know when. I have decided to write this but I honestly don’t know what to do with it. I will for sure not share it yet with my fourteen, twelve, and eight-year old children. I really want them to have a different experience on this vacation. But I want them and their generation to know that one “One Love” means “Equal Right and Justice” regardless of your social class or the colour of your skin.

Whenever I come back to Jamaica, however, I will like to stay in a place where my family and I will be treated with dignity; a place where I will not be too black to be noticed; a place where I shall not be told by a fellow black that my colour automatically places me in a lower social class; a place where the doormen, waitresses, managers, lifeguards, and other staff treat people of all races equally. In a few days, my family and I will head back to Canada where I am treated with dignity because there is justice. The guarantee of individual rights and freedom makes Canada a place where there is One Love. Canadians will always “get together and feel alright” regardless of race. Well, we have no choice anyway for it is too cold to be on your own, eeh!

 




RobotRobot is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 1

Posted by Robot| 12.03.2008 11:59

Reply Quote



PalamedesPalamedes is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 2

A. G. Ahmed, sir, don't come here asking for sympathy if you can't even name the hotel where you stayed. I am not sure if it was “Boscobel Beach” or “Ocho Rios”. WHY wouldn't you name the hotel that treated you so poorly, so that other Africans who read this article might avoid it.

You have left us all in the dark on the identity of the hotel; and some unfortunate African is going to spend a fortune to fly from one part of the world to holiday in the very hotel and get the same treatment. You have CHANGED nothing but covered up for them.

When Europeans have terrible holidays—even in another European country, they name and shame the hotel on radio phone-in, newspapers and TV but what did this African do? He writes an article but conceals the hotel name and location. You are a testament of why nothing changes for Africans.

Posted by Palamedes| 12.03.2008 14:53

Reply Quote



ILN TOOILN TOO is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 3

Thanks Abba Gumel, for bringing this issue to the fore. sometimes, there is more racism amongst black people than between black people and other races. Here in Nigeria, it is ethnicism. And it is very ugly. And what's more, some very highly educated black people are also the most zealous ethnic bigots. it is unfortunate but will be with us until the day came when ethnic and religious tolerance would be used as barometers for academic achievement. but i digress.

Yours is probably different because you were discriminated based on perceived social class. Unfortunately, the vast majority of black people are at the bottom of the hierarchy when it comes to social stratification. Obviously, there are very many successful black people (and i am sure you are one of those) but this does not change the fact that the vast majority of black people wherever they might be, are not doing well. this is the sad truth.

You are a great mathematician. but how many great mathematicians are black? tell me euler is black. or gauss is black. or lagrange is black. or cauchy is black. or newton is black. surely, we must have some black people that have achieved prominence in that field? but where are they? what should i tell my children when they ask me?

Posted by ILN TOO| 12.03.2008 17:59

Reply Quote



ILN TOOILN TOO is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 4


=Palamedes;4294995432>A. G. Ahmed, sir, don't come here asking for sympathy if you can't even name the hotel where you stayed. I am not sure if it was “Boscobel Beach” or “Ocho Rios”. WHY wouldn't you name the hotel that treated you so poorly, so that other Africans who read this article might avoid it.

You have left us all in the dark on the identity of the hotel; and some unfortunate African is going to spend a fortune to fly from one part of the world to holiday in the very hotel and get the same treatment. You have CHANGED nothing but covered up for them.

When Europeans have terrible holidays—even in another European country, they name and shame the hotel on radio phone-in, newspapers and TV but what did this African do? He writes an article but conceals the hotel name and location. You are a testament of why nothing changes for Africans.



Palamedes,

Don't you think you are over reacting? i think you are right in demanding that the hotel be named and shamed. but Abba is not trying to conceal the hotel's identity. he is trying to conceal HIS OWN identity. Only God knows why.

Posted by ILN TOO| 12.03.2008 18:11

Reply Quote



ayoka1ayoka1 is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 5

Finally, an article that talks intelligently about something serious on this website. Thanks for sharing your experience. I think the one thing we can continue to do is carry ourselves with dignity and demand that we be treated respectfully. No one can make us feel inferior without our permission.

Posted by ayoka1| 12.03.2008 18:25

Reply Quote



Ochi DabariOchi Dabari is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 6

Please name the hotel fully. We want black people (who don't want to be humiliated) to avoid it. I don't want to visit Jamaica some time in the future and have a very bad experience. You may not feel it that much as it is not your first time to Jamaica.

Please name the hotel, so that we can avoid it. The black staff there do not want to serve a black person; they can continue to live their slave lives and serve their massas.

ochi

Posted by Ochi Dabari| 12.03.2008 23:31

Reply Quote



Pius72Pius72 is offline 
JJC

avatar
 # 7

Folks,

Softly. softly. A.G. Ahmed is not Abba Gumel and he is not trying to conceal his identity. A.G Ahmed is A.G. Ahmed. He is an Ottawa-based Physician, one of the leading lights of our Nigerian community here. The piece, I believe, is not ambiguous. The circumstances in which he wrote are clearly stated: 2 am, after the experience and the long flight from Canada. So, he is just venting but he also addresses the crucial issue of intra-racial prejudice and classism. Let's keep our eyes on the ball.

Pius Adesanmi

Posted by Pius72| 13.03.2008 00:26

Reply Quote



ILN TOOILN TOO is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 8


=Pius72;4294995542>Folks,

Softly. softly. A.G. Ahmed is not Abba Gumel and he is not trying to conceal his identity. A.G Ahmed is A.G. Ahmed. He is an Ottawa-based Physician, one of the leading lights of our Nigerian community here. The piece, I believe, is not ambiguous. The circumstances in which he wrote are clearly stated: 2 am, after the experience and the long flight from Canada. So, he is just venting but he also addresses the crucial issue of intra-racial prejudice and classism. Let's keep our eyes on the ball.

Pius Adesanmi



Pius,

Thanks for educating me. apologies to AG Ahmed and Abba Gumel.

Posted by ILN TOO| 13.03.2008 04:39

Reply Quote



AbujaboyAbujaboy is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 9

I don't know -- the writer has come to a huge number of conclusions based on what is pretty flimsy evidence. As a white person living in Nigeria, there are times without number that I have been treated badly by a business or a person, and it seemed to me a black person got better treatment. Was it racism? Quite possibly. But to draw huge conclusions from ONE encounter with a business or person would be premature.

Seems to me to be the same with this story about Jamaica. Was the Jamaica case racism? Quite possibly. But he's talking about one encounter. Maybe the white family was a friend of the owner, and had been long anticipated. Maybe they were staying in the most expensive suite, and whoever stays there gets that treatment, black or white. Maybe the staff didn't notice him, and for ten minutes he himself did not make his presence felt.

Bottom line, to condemn the hotel, and then ALL OF JAMAICAN society (!?!) as racist seems really premature. Notice how he apparently had no other specific trouble for the rest of his stay? He mentions none. One would expect that a racist hotel would have given him a multitude of reasons to complain. It's a little hard to believe that "insuffficient toiletries" and "no hot water" were because of the color of his skin!

Posted by Abujaboy| 13.03.2008 06:23

Reply Quote



RanterRanter is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 10

There are two sides to a story,as we wouldn't hope to hear from the hotel on this site,may be the writer could have volunteered the name hotel may be someone here might know someone that writes a travel advisory that can pass on his bad experience at this place.
If it were me , i would have made my presence by calling out to them with names like , hello emperor, do you think u fix my internet woes like in the next 10 mins or 2 weeks?
Whenever I feel I'm not treated with deserved respect i call people names like Doctor, General,Chairman, Sir or anything that makes them important then I follow with something like 'Erm ,Can you get me two clean beach towels if it wouldn't be a bother?
The writer could have called them over and asked for his needs, they are up that late to serve their customers and he is one of them.

Posted by Ranter| 13.03.2008 07:16

Reply Quote


Last Updated ( Thursday, 24 April 2008 )
 
< Prev   Next >