15

Jun

2009

Harvard University Denies Agreement With Governors PDF Print E-mail
By Patrick Nwadike

Harvard University denies agreement with Nigerian governors.

Email from Harvard

Dear Friends: 

A number of you have written to me asking for further clarification about the putative discussion between myself and the Nigerian Governor’s Forum.

The MOU in question was quickly drafted by the Forum and my Program immediately after a very friendly visit in May to Cambridge, Mass. by a delegation from the Forum. The MOU was meant to be the first step in the exploration of a possible training program and as a means of signifying the intent on both sides to work together to craft such a program. Neither that document nor even the possibility of developing a joint Forum-Harvard Kennedy School training project had as yet been brought before the Kennedy School for consideration or approval, so it was premature for an announcement to have been made in Nigeria.

After the initial announcement of the discussions between the Forum and my Program on all-Africa.com, I wrote to the Forum reiterating that the MOU was a promise only to work together to develop a formal agreement that could be put before the Harvard Kennedy School for consideration, and that the MOU was only between my Program and the Forum and could not be construed as any kind of agreement with Harvard. A few days later, on 2 June, the Forum replied, fully understanding “the difference between signing an MOU with your Program and signing a contract between Harvard University and the NGF.”

Regardless, I take full responsibility for the confusion that ensued after the Governors’ visit to Cambridge. As previously noted, the MOU was intended merely to indicate my willingness to explore the possibility of developing a capacity building workshop series for the Nigeria Governors’ Forum. In hindsight, the MOU may have gone too far in noting specific elements of any such program, including speculating on specific dates, and likely helped contribute to this unfortunate confusion.

That is and should be the end of the story. As I said last week to many of you, there is no agreement between the Forum and Harvard. To suggest that there is adds to a public misunderstanding, which I and others very much regret.

Best wishes

Robert Rotberg


Citizen Investigations by Majek Adega

It has been reported in some of Nigeria’s newspapers and Internet portals that Harvard University recently entered into an agreement with the Governors' Forum to train Nigeria’s governors’ on capacity building. The Guardian newspaper’s editorial of June 11, 2009 also addressed the issue in very harsh language. I forwarded a copy of Guardian’s editorial to Harvard University. 

At the end of their jamboree and return to Nigeria, governor Akpabio, the spokesman for the group, held a press conference in Calabar and briefed members of the press about the reasons for the alleged agreement between the Governors Forum and Harvard University. He cited lack of understanding of the Constitution and preparedness for the job they willingly sought as the reasons behind the agreement. This is the same job that some of these governors considered “a do or die” affair and were willing to do anything to get. Pathetic will be a friendly way to describe governor Akpabio’s utterances.

Personally angered that the trip was nothing more than another avenue for the governors to engage in the squandering of scarce public resources; that history has taught Nigerians that most Nigerian politicians would not engage in any endeavor that does not provide an opportunity for looting of the treasury, even if such an endeavor is the acquisition of skills needed to improve their own on-the-job performance; that the trip to Harvard University may have cost the Nigerian taxpayers millions of dollars in airline tickets for the governors and their retinue of assistants/girlfriends, payment of bloated official allowances and hotel accommodation; that notwithstanding the egregious nature of the above-described components of the trip one’s indignation is further exacerbated by the realization that the trip may actually have been a ruse or decoy for squirreling looted funds out of Nigeria and into American bank accounts, I decided to get to the bottom of the story by contacting Harvard University.

I started my investigations by contacting Jake Ackman of Harvard University’s Communications Office (1-617-495-1115). Although he acknowledged reading news reports about the purported agreement, he denied knowledge of its existence. My Ackman then referred me to the office of Prof. Robert Rotberg, head of the Office of the University’s Intrastate Conflict Program (1-617-496-2258) . Prof. Rotberg’s Intrastate Conflict Program coordinates the “capacity training” the governors claim to be interested in. An assistant in Prof. Rotberg’s office who did not want the name published also denied the existence of an agreement between the school and the Governor’s Forum. I was further informed by the assistant that Mr. Rotberg was in a meeting but would be happy to respond to my email. I was given Prof. Rotberg’s email address and I promptly fired off an email to him.

In my email to Mr. Rotberg, I expressed my disappointment that an esteemed institution like Harvard University would be involved in an enterprise as sleazy as the one involving the governors. I told him that Nigerian governors do not need Harvard University workshops or degrees to know that provision of water, electricity and shelter are basic rights of citizens. That they do not need Harvard University workshops or degrees to know that treasury looting is a crime against the people and the state. That they do not need Harvard University workshops or degrees to understand that the money they spent on the needless trip to Cambridge-Massachusetts could have been better spent providing basic amenities for the people; that at a cost of $2,500.00 a borehole, a community of 50-100 people/Nigerians can be given year-round access to clean water that would reduce the risks associated with water borne diseases.

I further told him that the real victims of the Harvard University jamboree are the ordinary Nigerian people who could have had several boreholes installed for them with the resources spent on the jamboree. That the real victims are the new born babies and mothers dying due to lack of basic medical supplies, including incubators. I also explained that ordinary Nigerians “are the real victims of the type of financial brigandage that brought these governors to Harvard University. The victims may not be in front of you, you may never meet them, your knowledge of them may be limited to figures/statistics, but they are real human beings. They are people’s children, parents, brothers, sisters, uncles, aunts, husbands and wives. Think about them when you deal with these politicians”.

I sent my email to Prof. Rotberg at about 7:00 p.m. and within an hour I received a reply from him. In his reply, not only did Prof. Rotberg deny the existence of any contract with the Nigerian governors, he said “there will never be an agreement with them” without stating why. Prof. Rotberg accused the Nigerian press of jumping the gun. If you believe Prof. Rotberg and I am tempted to, one is then forced to ask why the governors travelled to the United States and how much the trip cost them. Unlike Prof. Rotberg who saw his reputation and that of his 373 year old university at stake and decided to explain their side of the story, our politicians do not give a hoot about the governed. I do not expect the governors to provide any answers to these intrigues because they do not comprehend their responsibilities to the Nigerian people. After all, what can the voters do? The governors do not need to explain anything to anyone because they do not need the people to “vote” them back into office.

All they need is Maurice Iwu.

Majekodunmi Adega

Forwarded by Patrick Nwadike



Your Comments

Please make The Square an enjoyable experience for everyone by refraining from gratuitous ad-hominem contributions, defamatory comments and off-topic posting. Such posts will be removed.

User Avatar
RobotRobot is offline

 # 1 | 14.06.2009 09:24

Harvard University denies agreement with Nigerian governors. Citizen Investigations by Majek Adega It has been reported in some of Nigeria’s newspapers and Internet portals that Harvard University recently entered into an agreement with the Governors' Forum to train Nigeria’s governors’ on capacity building. The Guardian newspaper’s editorial of June 11, 2009 also addressed the issue in very harsh language. I forwarded a copy of Guardian’s editorial to Harvard University. At the end of their jamboree and return to Nigeria, governor Akpabio, the spokesman for the group, held a press conference in Calabar and briefed members of the press about the reasons for the alleged agreement between the Governors Forum and Harvard University. He cited lack of understanding of the Constitution and preparedness for the job they willingly sought as the reasons behind the agreement. This is the same job that some of these governors considered...Read the full article.

User Avatar
Zanubia WolfZanubia Wolf is offline

 # 2 | 14.06.2009 09:59

Thank you for this expose o! This one of the problems with corruption, the perpetrators are every thinking of new avenues to stuff there pockets!! with nija revenue

User Avatar
DapxinDapxin is offline

 # 3 | 14.06.2009 11:15

well done you!

For where the /allegedly some/ editors of our newspapers are content,
with breaking the news (can't we all predict them these days)
and following thru with some interesting b00b-check-and-snooze /see sahara reporters/ :( :)

you most probably have forced these cr00ks to again re-work their plan in loot-o-mania.
by a judicious + timely use of your email client and typing skills...

I congratulate you, and the many tens/hundreds of us, that will learn by your audacious effort here even if on its own, it doesnt put someone in jail...

User Avatar
AgidimolajaAgidimolaja is offline

 # 4 | 14.06.2009 12:29

They are Governors.They are untouchables,thanks to mmunity.They are mini-gods.
After their time is over,may God have mercy on Lady Farida if she attempted to bring them to justice. She may quickly be banished to Kuru or somewhere else more terrible before she is eventually disgraced and exiled. Friends,relatives,cronies,stooges etc of ex-governors would then joined up in the fight,accusing Lady Farida of being selective.Curses and abuses would be dished out at her by the likes of a New York based Tiv "intellectual mugu", for not following "the rule of law".
Before now,we have seen all kinds of show of shame being put on display by friends of treasury looters,apologists, hatchet writers,certificated morons etc.
I will not be surprised if these pathetic folks descended mightily on our man, Majek,for doing so much in exposing these perverse Governors.I will not be surprised if what Majek got for his efforts is negative name callings.
Thanks Majek for job well done.You are a true son and friend of Nigeria.

User Avatar
abdulmuminabdulmumin is offline

 # 5 | 14.06.2009 12:38

Bravo Majek!
Thanks for exposing the charlatans for what they are.

User Avatar
LuchiLuchi is offline

 # 6 | 14.06.2009 13:41

More stories according to Thisday Newspaper.

Document Affirms Govs’ Forum, Harvard Varsity Deal
A Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) between Nigerian Governors’ Forum and John Kennedy School of Government of the Harvard University, United State, has reaffirmed a training deal the Forum sealed with the university during its recent working visit to the United States.
Titled: “Capacity Building Workshops for Nigerian Governors’ Forum”, the MoU focuses on the training of the 36 Governors, Forum staff and local leaders in the areas of leadership, good governance, education policy, economic development, among others.
Jointly signed by the Chairman of Nigerian Governors’ Forum, Dr. Bukola Saraki; Director-General of the Nigerian Governors’ Forum, Mr. A. B Okauru, Harvard University’s Director, Programme on Intrastate Conflict, Prof Robert I. Rotberg and Ms. Katie L. Naeve, programme manager, Programme on Intrastate Conflict, on May 21 and 22, also spelt out the scope of the engagement.
According to the document, “Harvard Kennedy School Programme on Intrastate Conflict will hold three workshops for the Forum and governors, the first of which will take place in October, 2009, and second two before June 2010. Further workshops will occur in 2010 – 2011 and beyond. The programme on Intrastate Conflict will provide experts in the area listed above to teach at each of the three workshops.”
On logistics, the MoU says: “Both the programme on Intrastate Conflict and the secretariat at the Nigeria Governors’ Forum will coordinate the logistics of the workshops including transportation of input from the Nigeria Governors’ Forum Secretariat, will formulate appropriate curricula for each of the workshops.”
The Forum had announced an impending course in capacity building for all the 36 state governors after four of its members returned from a trip to Harvard and some public institutions in the US about two weeks ago.
The members who undertook the trip included its chairman, Saraki of Kwara State, Edo State Governor, Comrade Adams Oshiomhole, Bauchi State Governor, Mallam Isa Yuguda and Akwa Ibom State Governor, Obong Godswill Akpabio.
A media report at the weekend had quoted Head of Kennedy School of Governance, Harvard University, Prof. Robert Rotberg as saying that although the forum contacted him and sought his help for such a programme, the school had not responded before the forum claimed that both parties had signed a memorandum of understanding.
According to the report, what existed between the two parties was a mere draft of the MoU which Rotberg reportedly said was still awaiting the endorsement of the school authorities.

User Avatar
M. AkosaM. Akosa is offline

 # 7 | 14.06.2009 14:07

God bless you Mr Adega, for doing this excellent investigative work and writing this article.

Havard, Oxford or Cambridge should not accomodate any 3rd world country oppressors or charlatans, after they have abused and hurt their citizens, while in office or power of authority.

Why don't these Nigerian governors seek better education like Ngozi Iweala, Oby Ezekwesili, Ndi Onyiuke and the rest did, before looking for positions of authority.

Of course those charlatan governors are so cheap, they settle for internet Phds. Then wreck havoc on their Nigerian victims, then fleece the state funds, then seek their mother's head in the US and England or so called Harvard education and Cambridge.
Of course only Nigerians can abuse power and then head for Warwick, Oxford, Cambridge and Harvard.
Fools!!!

User Avatar
konkomitantkonkomitant is offline

 # 8 | 14.06.2009 14:12

Why did you stop your investigation at Harvard University?

If what you did was an investigation you should have contacted the three parties involved in this story, the Nigerian press, the Governor(s), and of course Harvard.

Now we don't know who's the liar among the other two, namely the press or the Governor(s). All three are capable of giving out misleading information.

Except if you were there when the Governor gave the press release. Then there would be no need to investigate the media.

Please we need the rest of the details in order to ascertain who the liar is.
Thank you.

User Avatar
GbollyGbolly is offline

 # 9 | 14.06.2009 14:49

Well done Majek. We have heard from Harvard people. I am curious to know what the concerned Governors have to say about Harvard denial of their claim. Please can you pass the result of your investigation to Gov. Saraki and others for their comments? Thank you!

User Avatar
changenigeriamovementchangenigeriamovement is offline

 # 10 | 14.06.2009 15:09

Hello Konkomitan:

I agree with you that all parties to a disagreement should be investigated or listend to and their respective perspectives reported. The parties in this case being Harvard University, Governors and Guardian). But I think this case is different. I do not see the need to investigate Guardian or report its perspective. It based its editorial on Governor Akpabio's press conference which the governor is yet to deny. In fact, Thisday's story of June 14, 2009 (http://www.thisdayonline.com/nview.php?id=146038) confirmed the details contained in Guardian's editorial. So you already have the governors' perspective in adition to that of Harvard University. Why investigate facts that have been confirmed by the governors?

Let us even assume that one wishes to contact the governors to obtain their perspective on the matter, how do you do it? Whereas Harvard University has a telephone number and answers its calls, emails and questions, how do you get the governors' side of the story when the governors have no known telephone numbers or email addresses? If you are implying that you know the contact information for the governors, you should do everybody a favor by providing the details. Alternatively, if you do not have their contact information, you can still help the investigation by explaining how you expect the governors's perspctive to be obtained in the absence of contact information.

To me, the real issue is not so much about lies but whether these governors should have taken a job for which they were not qualified or lack the "capacity" to perform; cannot get the same training in a Nigerian university; or should be spending limited resources in this manner. With due respect, these are the real issues in my opinion. If the training sought from Harvard University is actualy an imperative, we can't the governors bring the Harvard University lecturers to Nigeria and conduct the workshop in a Nigerian University, thereby saving scarce resources?

If you cannot trust your health to a "doctor" who is yet to attend medical school and obtain the requisite qualifications, why should Nigerians trust governors with the governance of their respective states when the governors have admitted lacking the capacity to do the job?

What is so complicated in "capacity building" to justify the spending of limited resources on a trip to Harvard University? Any governor who is interested in capcity building need not travel far. I believe governor Fashola of Lagos state will be too happy to accommodate and teach "capacity building and good governance" to these governors for free. What do you think?

I hope you will consider my observations to be in order. Have yourself a great day.
 

Services : E-mail news | RSS Feeds | Podcasts
Links:   About the NVS | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies | Advertise With Us
All Rights Reserved. NigeriaVillageSquare.com