14

Jan

2009

Israel’s Unjust War In Gaza PDF Print E-mail
By Disu Kamor

During the past half-year there has been ‘a ceasefire’ in Gaza where Israel has falsely called it’s elected government a terrorist organization, cut off all outside aid into the strip, imposed a crippling economic embargo, imprisoned 1.5 million Gazans in isolation on a Bantustan measuring only 10km by 40km (thus making the strip of land the densest human population in the world!), inflicted devastating human suffering, and stepped up oppression in an all too familiar pattern- repeated incursions, killings, targeted assassinations, mass arrests, incarcerations, torture, and all the rest. In the words of John Ging, the head of operations of the United Nations agency for Palestine refugees (UNRWA) who captured the situation that existed very well, Gaza was at this time of the ceasefire  a place where its people ‘did not benefit; they did not have any restoration of a dignified existence. We in fact at the UN, our supplies were also restricted during the period of the ceasefire, to the point where we were left in a very vulnerable and precarious position and with a few days of closure we ran out of food’. But just last month the Israelis carried out a further violation of the ceasefire by firing missiles into Gaza that eventually killed 29 Palestinians on the pretext of pre-emptively striking and destroying tunnels that the resistant groups allegedly were using to smuggle weapons into Gaza.

In response to Israel's attack, Hamas’ military wing- the Qassam Brigades- fired primitive rockets into southern Israel a few of which caused injuries to some settlers there. This ‘retaliation,’ and Hamas’ refusal to renew the ceasefire- on the ground that the initial ceasefire ‘did not benefit the Gazans’ (interestingly the same as in Ging’s words above)- played into the hands of Israel just as intended; Israel had spent the ‘6 months of quiet’ to planned a large-scale offensive (Israel's Defense Minister admits to this when he stated that they had been planning and preparing for months for the military offensive), with Israel as usual portraying itself as the only victim. Israel’s war on Gaza has so far killed more than 950 Palestinians (compared to 13 killed on Israel’s side) - most of who were children and women, and seriously wounding thousands more. Israel claims most of the dead were Hamas ‘terrorists,’ but in fact, the first targets of its campaign were police stations in dense residential areas, and the dead included many police officers and other civilians. Under international law, police officers are civilians, and targeting them is no less a war crime than aiming at ordinary civilians on the street. These first sets of air assaults also came at a time when Palestinian children were leaving the morning school session and the afternoon students were arriving. In occupied Palestine, schools are normally built close to police stations so the police could offer safety and protection to the children to and from school. Israel knew this fact well and yet indiscriminately fired on police stations thereby killing many policemen and school children. Israeli latter shelled three UN run schools where many families were wiped out- head of UN operations in Gaza said after the cowardly attacks that they had supplied the co-ordinates of all UN run schools in Gaza to the Israeli military prior to this campaign and there were neither militants in the schools nor any militant operation around the areas when the schools were targeted. So, these were cold-blooded mass murder and Israel knew exactly what it was doing. After a recent savage Israeli bombardment of a civilian area in Gaza, Palestinian and international medical service providers were forbidden from recovering the dead and injured. When the Red Cross eventually was allowed 4 days later, they found two babies with their mouths suckled to the toes of their dead mothers- they had both starved to death. Because of Israel’s indiscriminate attacks on civilians that had seen whole families wiped out, Palestinian families are now splitting up in a desperate bid to survive Israeli bombardment. Heartbroken parents are scattering their children so as the families are not entirely wiped out by the air strikes. Yet, nowhere is safe! A few days ago, more than 30 civilians were killed when a house where Israeli soldiers themselves had evacuated 110 people was repeatedly shelled 24 hours later. Survivors had to stagger more than a mile down the road in search of help. It was Israeli soldiers that put these people into the house and gave them strict instruction only 24hours earlier not to leave the building under any circumstances- or else they die. The timing during these dying days of the Bush administration may indicate an Israeli effort to take advantage of a moment when there might be more political cover from the lame duck American president.

Israel and the supporters of its policies have always falsely referred to Hamas as a terrorist organization to justify its war crimes. Yet Hamas, a registered Palestinian political organization, won a free and fair Palestinian elections in 2006 in the freest election in the whole Arab countries - a clear victory for the whole Palestinian people who used the ballot to reject the grossly corrupt Fattah government, yet Israel, the United States and European Union have insisted that its right to govern cannot be treated as legitimate. More proof, as if any is needed, of the transparent hypocrisy of nations that went to an illegal war partly ‘in order to bring democracy to Iraq’. Israel then immediately rounded up most of the elected parliamentarians who are still languishing in its jails. After mid-June 2007, the western-backed ‘moderate Palestinian’ government of president Mahmoud Abbas, collaboratively and at the behest of Washington and Israel, declared a false "state of emergency"; deposed Prime Minister Ismail Haniya; appointed an "emergency" cabinet; split Palestinian authority between Gaza and the West Bank; incited internal conflict to divide and conquer; and acceded to Israel blockading Gaza. Under the proud eyes of United States military advisors, president Abbas assembled ‘security forces’ to fight the resistance to this killing siege on Israel's behalf. However, none of the humiliating concessions has spared a single Palestinian in the West Bank from Israel's relentless colonization and the brutality of its settlers. Indeed, one of the underlining objectives of the current Israeli merciless military campaign in Gaza might be to reinstate the corrupt government of Mahmoud Abbas in Gaza.

But let us be clear what Zionist Israel means by moderate Palestinians and terrorists. The Hamas leadership in recent years has signaled that it is willing to negotiate a two-state settlement according to the June 1967 border and also as long as there will be the resolution of the right of refugees to return. That means that Hamas has signaled to do what the international community has wanted Israel to do over the past 30 years.

Israel rejects such a two-state settlement because it wants to continue and advance its dream of the Greater Israel project- a project predicated on the racist and evil ideology of Zionism. So for Israel a moderate Palestinian means a Palestinian who is willing to do whatever Israel wants: is a Palestinian who is willing to follow Israeli orders: a Palestinian organization that will be subservient to Israel in the premeditated land "purification" goals and methods. When the Palestinian Authority refused to do this under Arafat, it branded Chairman Arafat a terrorist and repeatedly complained it had ‘no partner for peace’ to work with, when Hamas refuses to be subservient, it brands it a "terrorist organization".

However, an interesting feature of Israel’s aggressions in the Middle East is that whenever it goes to war, so do the dominant media- in the lead are FOX, CNN, Sky, BBC and New York Times- and other ‘Israel must defend itself. And Hamas must bear responsibility for ending a six-month ceasefire this month with a barrage of rocket attacks into Israeli territory’ media cult whose Middle East affairs desks have been partially converted to Israel’s war propaganda offices to twist facts into a fabric of misinformation and agitprop, to viciously vilify Hamas, Hezbollah, Syria and Iran. So, when next you see dapper, Western-accented apologists for mass-murder appearing on any of those channels acting as spokespersons for Israel, remember that a well-oiled propaganda machine is at work! As we have seen in other Israeli aggressions against its neighbours in the recent past, a veteran cheering squad always suits up to support the home team as soon as the first Israeli missile strikes. This section of the media never report Palestinian violence to be the effect— only the cause. Following in the trend set by the immoral and one-sided Middle East foreign policy of White House itself which always sees President George Bush and his war-on-terror pimp, Condoleezza Rice, blame Hamas for every violence, insisting that (only) Israel has a right to exist and defend itself. The so-called mainstream media report nothing about Hamas’ democratic election, the unlawful arrest and continued illegal detention of elected parliamentarians, its seeking peace and rapprochement, its unilateral ceasefires, its support by the great majority of Gazans, and the efforts it makes to ease living under the overwhelming challenges of Israeli relentless siege. They are quick to justify Israel's every violent attacks in a manner that de-contextualizes Palestinian militancy, thereby depriving the latter of any semblance of legitimacy. The inhuman practices adopted by Israel in treating the Palestinians are in clear violation of virtually every article of the Fourth Geneva Convention, and are considered, by international law, as war crimes. Yet you do not find the media and State Department mentioning this at all.

It is amazing that while these media organizations are busy helping to sell Israel’s war to the world public, more and more people from the mainstream of Israeli politics are voicing alarm. In the Israeli newspaper Ha’aretz, former Knesset Speaker Avraham Burg compared the situation in Israel today to Germany on the eve of the Nazis’ rise to power. And writing for The Huffington Post, former Israeli peace negotiator Daniel Levy likened Israel to a drunk and the U.S. to a "friend" who gives the already-drunk a bottle of vodka and keys to the car.

Israel is a lawless country and it is no doubt emboldened to continue promoting Zionism and colonization at gunpoint by the complicity of its principal backer and financier- the US government, the European Union and the Arab leaders’ pathetic silence. Of course the Israeli government could never have pursued its oppressive and violent policies in the occupied territories without the money, weapons, and diplomatic cover provided by the United States, especially the Congress which has been hopelessly corrupted by the Israeli lobbies in Washington. They are, almost all of them, fully complicit in Israeli government crimes, including its war crimes. The gradual process of ethnic cleansing in the occupied Palestinian territories is being accelerated through the current campaign in Gaza, and with it so is the moral culpability of Israel’s political backers. Israel knows and is emboldened by this fact. Despite popular outrage, pro-forma criticism and anger on Arab streets, corrupt and oppressive Arab kings and presidents in the region's capitals offered little or no supports for Gazans for fear of antagonizing their protecting friends in Washington and their powerful Israeli neighbour- whom they fear given its military might of nuclear arsenal and close ties to America. The silence and tacit support of these Arab regimes are also factors in the collective abandonment of Gaza by the international community while Israel continues to commit war crimes carried out with brutal impunity against the occupied people, most of whom are refugees in their homeland. The 41-year-old war of attrition on the Palestinians is an unjust and immoral war that is paid for in American dollars and American political capital. The Amnesty International, the Red Cross and many other humanitarian and human rights organizations, now have rightly condemned the way and manner the Gazans are being attacked. During the 6-month period of the so-called ‘ceasefire’, more Gazans surely died of hunger, torture and targeted killings than this current Israeli aggression which to many Gazans is same death by other means. Palestinians and their supporters worldwide will never be silenced or defeated, and the Palestinian martyrs, even as the number grows unbearably by the day, are dying honorable deaths that highlight their cause and signpost a very dark chapter in human history. Their cause is to resist oppression, colonization, and to pursue and win freedom even unto the very bitter end.

 

Disu Kamor

Director of Media & Communications

Muslim Public Affairs Centre, MPAC, Nigeria

e-mail: kamor.disu@mpac-ng.org

website: www.mpac-ng.org



Your Comments

Please make The Square an enjoyable experience for everyone by refraining from gratuitous ad-hominem contributions, defamatory comments and off-topic posting. Such posts will be removed.

User Avatar
RobotRobot is offline

 # 1 | 14.01.2009 08:09

During the past half-year there has been ‘a ceasefire’ in Gaza where Israel has falsely called it’s elected government a terrorist organization, cut off all outside aid into the strip, imposed a crippling economic embargo, imprisoned 1.5 million Gazans in isolation on a Bantustan measuring only 10km by 40km (thus making the strip of land the densest human population in the world!), inflicted devastating human suffering, and stepped up oppression in an all too familiar pattern- repeated incursions, killings, targeted assassinations, mass arrests, incarcerations, torture, and all the rest. In the words of John Ging, the head of operations of the United Nations agency for Palestine refugees (UNRWA) who captured the situation that existed very well, Gaza was at this time of the ceasefire a place where its people ‘did not benefit; they did not have any restoration of a dignified existence. We in fact at the UN, our supplies were als...Read the full article.

User Avatar
DeebeeDeebee is offline

 # 2 | 14.01.2009 14:13

This article reeks of either bias, ignorance or both. However, I will not attempt to begin a controversy. I'll just say war is an ugly evil that humans, unfortunately, must often resort to because "gentlemen" are not gentlemen.

I don't think it's fair to expect Israel to allow an enemy that has vowed its extinction to continue taking advantage of ceasefire agreements to sneak weapons through tunnels. You need to "dig" a little (pun intended) to find article that truthfully report that the violations of ceasefires between Israel and her enemies have almost always been committed first by those enemies - Hamas, PLO, Lebanon, Syria, Egypt, whoever. Also, Iran - always seeking to cause trouble in order to be the power broker in the Middle East - is spending millions of dollars to arm Israel's enemies, instead of building necessary infrastructure and providing basic necessities for the Palestinian people. Same occurs in Sudan, with Arabs rather spending millions of dollars to massacre black Sudanese, rather than building their nation. Arabs will rather spend billions on spreading their hate than helping their citizens.

Israel is not perfect, but it has shown considerable restraint. Whenever its patience finally wears out, people start talking about "disproportionate force" as if that were a principle of war. Meanwhile, Hamas never ceases to hide weapons in schools and residences. It's ridiculous!

The history of the Arab-Israeli conflict is complex, and we should refrain from taking sides. It doesn't help either the Jews or their enemies. Most of all, it does us no good.

User Avatar
ade123ade123 is offline

 # 3 | 14.01.2009 14:44

Deebee,
Indeed the article has made a good reading. As it has been stated by a Jewish scholar, 'The record is fairly clear. You can find it on the Israeli website, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs website. Israel broke the ceasefire by going into the Gaza and killing six or seven Palestinian militants. At that point—and now I’m quoting the official Israeli website—Hamas retaliated or, in retaliation for the Israeli attack, then launched the missiles.

Now, as to the reason why Israel broke the ceasefire, the record is fairly clear as well. According to Ha’aretz, Defense Minister Barak began plans for this invasion before the ceasefire even began. In fact, according to yesterday’s Ha’aretz, the plans for the invasion began in March. And the main reasons for the invasion, I think, are twofold. Number one; to enhance what Israel calls its deterrence capacity, which in layman’s language basically means Israel’s capacity to terrorize the region into submission. After their defeat in July 2006 in Lebanon, they felt it important to transmit the message that Israel is still a fighting force, still capable of terrorizing those who dare defy its word.'

And the second main reason for the attack is because Hamas was signaling that it wanted a diplomatic settlement of the conflict along the June 1967 border.

Your statement that: 'Israel is not perfect, but it has shown considerable restraint. Whenever its patience finally wears out, people start talking about "disproportionate force" as if that were a principle of war' exposes your views as very controversial. How you could say this of a nation that has caged Gaza – a land saturated with rubble and body parts – carpet-bombed by air, invaded by ground, attacked by sea beats me. Have you seen weapons hidden in schools and residences or just parroting the Israeli narrative that dominate the media these days? Where did the ANC hid its weapeons when it was fighting the racist aparthied regime in South Africa? For your information- and education (because this is wat really cures ignorance) the Palestinians, or even Hamas, are not fighting or opposing Jews but ZIONISTS and colonialists. There are thousands of prominent Jews that have joined Palestinians in this fight for FREEDOM because they are conscientious objectors to what the Zionists are doing in their name. This is not a fight between Arabs and Jews, nor a fight between Muslims and Christians as there are thousands of Palestinians Christians that involved in the resistance activities.

This is indeed a complex issue but history matters in understanding and discussing it. Palestinians have consistently resisted Israeli dominance over their lives. Gazan resistance has been especially problematic for Israel. In the 1970s, before Hamas, Ariel Sharon was charged with “pacifying” Gaza. Sharon imposed a brutal policy of repression, blowing up houses, bulldozing large tracts of refugee camps, imposing severe collective punishment and imprisoning hundreds of young Palestinians.

As for your ridiculous 'Israel is not perfect, but it has shown considerable restraint' read - himself an Israeli Jew-Uri Avnery's How Many Divisions? at http://www.avnery-news.co.il/english/index.html

User Avatar
K_StationK_Station is offline

 # 4 | 14.01.2009 16:23

I thank the author for including his affiliation (MPAC); it helps to understand his bias to his Moslem brothers in Gaza. Unfortunately this has been one protracted conflict in which there are very few unbiased commentators, and of course how you see the conflict depends on whose side you are on. By the way, I’m with Israel on this one.

The authors comments that “In response to Israel's attack, Hamas’ military wing- the Qassam Brigades- fired primitive rockets into southern Israel a few of which caused injuries to some settlers there” tries to downplay the effect of rockets being lobbed daily into Israel, like Israeli women and children’s lives don’t matter too. Hamas’s primitive rockets & the fact that they haven’t killed many Israelis are not by design! Hamas (& their collaborators) wishes daily that their rockets are killing thousands of Israeli people! If that happens, then the war will be ‘just’?

The author also said, “Israel’s war on Gaza has so far killed more than 950 Palestinians compared to 13 killed on Israel’s side”, like this is a video game or that the war will suddenly become ‘just’ if there are equal number of casualties on both sides! The terrible casualties obviously have not stopped Hamas from firing rockets every single day since the beginning of this war. If the death of hundreds of Palestinians has not been bad enough to make Hamas stop firing rockets and seek the path of peace, what will it take? Complete annihilation?

Time and events have overtaken a lot of the historical reasons for the Arab-Israeli conflict. They all need to get real and find a way to live together in peace for the sake of their children. War is a terrible thing and the death of civilians especially women and children on both sides is very unfortunate. As for Hamas, they need to stop using the blood of the average Palestinians to advance their own Jihadist agenda, but until then, Israeli’s actions in Gaza will remain as ‘unjust’ as Hamas’ lobbing rockets blindly into southern Israel every day.

User Avatar
ade123ade123 is offline

 # 5 | 14.01.2009 18:01

I hope we- most Nigerians- can get out of this vicious cycle of interpreting things and issues only in the light of 'our affliations'. Obviously this is a better condition to be in. It is astonishing to read that the author's religion, rather than the topic and issues he raised, is being mentioned as a point of interest. K_Station, will it be fair for be to allege that you make the statement of the author's religious affliation just because you dont share that affliation? Or do you mean anyone not from his religious background cannot share his point of view? In both case you will be wrong because as I quoted in my first reply, this issue transcends race and religion (it is neither a racial or religious issue) and the opinion expressed by the author is widely shared by many people across the racial and religious divide. Obviously we still need to do a lot of work in our own country to see issues only based on the merit of the facts presented. There are many Palestinian christians caught up in this crises as well, and I suppose the author will feel proud, on the account of your comment, that he speaks in their defense.

User Avatar
K_StationK_Station is offline

 # 6 | 14.01.2009 20:04


=ade123;313139>I hope we- Nigerians- can get out of this vicious cycle of interpreting things and issues only in the light of 'our affliations'. Obviously this is a better condition to be in. It is astonishing to read that the author's religion, rather than the topic and issues he raised, is being mentioned as a point of interest. K_Station, will it be fair for be to allege that you make the statement of the author's religious affliation just because you dont share that affliation? Or do you mean anyone not from his religious background cannot share his point of view? In both case you will be wrong because as I quoted in my first reply, this issue transcends race and religion (it is neither a racial or religious issue) and the opinion expressed by the author is widely shared by many people across the racial and religious divide. Obviously we still need to do a lot of work in our own country to see issues only based on the merit of the facts presented. There are many Palestinian christians caught up in this crises as well, and I suppose the author will feel proud, on the account of your comment, that he speaks in their defense.



Ade,
Did you seriously think the author would have written the same article if he were a Jew? How can this issue transcend religion when the fundamental issues at stake here are tied to religion? I wish I can look you straight in the eye as you answer these two questions.

I do not rejoice at the death and destruction in Gaza (like they did on 9/11!) but like Obama said , "if you fire rockets at my kids every day and swore to destroy my family, I will come at you with everything I have", and guess what, it will be just and fair.

User Avatar
ade123ade123 is offline

 # 7 | 14.01.2009 20:50

Again you are mixing things up: Palestinians DID NOT rejoice at Sept 11th. Any shred of evidence you can dig up to support that allegation would not stand to scrutiny. My God! Arafat even donated his blood for the surviving victims of Sept 11th and the then Palestinian leadership- while under siege- sent condolences to the whole American people. So, the whole people of Palestine did not rejoice. This is the fact. Go to Israel today and see the number of people that are rejoing at the ethnic cleansing going on in Gaza. Even if certain numbers of Palestinians did rejoice at the Sept 11th attack, that would have been because they saw America as part of the architect of their collective tragedy. Wrong/unjustifiable? Yes, but tell that to the Nigerians who rejoiced on the street on the day Abacha died.

Yes, Obama will say that, and he did say that- while on an all expenses paid visit to Israel sponsored by the corrupting Israeli lobby AIPAC. But you have to understand that he was a politician seeking election into an office and he had to say whatever he believe would please the power that be. Rightly or wrongly.

Dont forget that the same Obama only a year before he made the statement you have quoted said the following: “Nobody is suffering more than the Palestinian people.” http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/17631015/ . This is just to let you know how the Washington politicians have conditioned to the wrath of the lobbies.

It is only a marginal few like you who continue to believe that the conflict between the Israelis and the Palestinians have got anything to do with religion. How could that be when you have Jews, Christians and Muslims in both camp (even people with other religions on none). Even the zionists that are in power in Israel are not religious, PA is a secular party in Palestine, and Hamas has never claimed that it is resisting occupation because the Quran tells them that Palestine has been given to them by God. You have so far failed to addresse that point, haven't you? The fact is either incorrect or you dont consider those people on the Palestinian side as authentic Jews/Christians. The creation of Israel was a political decision. Simply. The zionists (including the Christian zionists) will like people like you to continue to believe the myth that it is partly a religious conflict so that they can continue to perpetrate their crimes against the Palestinians- Christians and Muslims amongst them alike. Imagine if the Nazists and the then apartheid regime in South Africa had justified their racist policies on religion.

Finaly, in the US, it is a duty of everyone aspiring to be elected to demonstrate allegiance to Israel and express his/her hatred for the Palestinians (or renounce their association with Palestinians) and the candidates did not do this better than during the last presidential election- http://www.indianexpress.com/news/release-obama-video-praising-palestinian-leader-say-mccain-palin/379439/ and http://electronicintifada.net/v2/article6619.shtml. They must also be able to sing the American national anthem at an AIPAC convention: 'Jerusalem will remain the capital of Israel, and it must remain undivided. Now you reflect on all these facts, then make up your own mind'. You see, when you are a politician in Washington, it is a crime to befriend the Palestinians.

User Avatar
AgidimolajaAgidimolaja is offline

 # 8 | 14.01.2009 23:50

ade123,

You lied!

Palestinians rejoiced over the unfotunate incident of 911. They were shown all around the universe as they took to the streets dancing,honking and celebrating the primitive destructions of World Trade Centre. All the world saw them rejoicing except you.

Disu,

If Hamas is not a terrorist group,pls tell us what Hamas is.

User Avatar
ade123ade123 is offline

 # 9 | 15.01.2009 00:18

agidimolaja, your antics will put a 10 year old to shame. On this and other threads, you have only shown two abilities: ability to read and ability to write. You badly need the third and most important: ability to reason. The ANC, the IRA and even the black freedom movements in America during the civil rights movement were all at different times castigated as terrorists, yet held up now as heroes. Mandela himself was just a few months back just removed from the list of registered terrorists in America. Given this precedents, Hamas and its leaders are in good company!

The term terrorists has become a politician tool which he employs as he likes to brand people. America now leads other nations as the greatest purveyor of violence in the world. Bush & Blair qualifiy just by the sheer number of graves they will be remembered by to be the greatest terrorists of our time. The issue of Palestine is not Hamas or Fatha or any other Palestinian political organisation. It is simply an issue of colonization and freedom. Simple.

User Avatar
AgidimolajaAgidimolaja is offline

 # 10 | 15.01.2009 00:39

ade123,

Thanks for awarding me the passed mark.I scored,two out of three,that is good enough.
But you who can reason better,why did you lie?
You just lied to your readers that Palestinians did not rejoice on Sept.11 when your Islamic barabaric terrorists brought down the World Trade Centre.
All eyes around the world saw Palestinians took to the streets,honking,dancing,rejoicing etc. Facts cannot be denied!
Is telling your readers blatant lies what you called "ability to reason"?
Whatever personal interpretations you decided to give to terrorists is your cup of tea. The issue at hand now is not ANC etc.The issue here today is Hamas and they are the ones I'm talking about.
That they are not terrorists is another aspect of your blatant lie.
 

Services : E-mail news | RSS Feeds | Podcasts
Links:   About the NVS | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies | Advertise With Us
All Rights Reserved. NigeriaVillageSquare.com