24

Oct

2007

The Nigerian Phonetic and The Ghanaian’s Prejudice PDF Print E-mail
By Dele A. Sonubi

I once encountered a scenario where some fellow Nigerians with another Ghanaian were laughing at Nigerian’s way of speaking. They were busy praising the “Ghanaian English” pronunciation with its nauseating emphasis on words where even English native speakers had never placed emphasis. They were praising Ghanaian pronunciation as superior to the Nigerian English pronunciation and happily noting that the Ghanaians speak the proper Queen’s English while Nigerians do not.

My reaction was instant and uncalculated. It was some worth violent -for which I apologized later. My reaction was like that of a person whose culture had been insulted and abused- more so by his own “tribesmen”. I tried to recollect why I was so violent with my reaction knowing fully well that for the past 35 years I have heard the same praises of the Ghanaian English over and above the Nigerian English and even the English English! Then I tried to justify myself by putting down the reason for my anger.

I grew up in the ‘70s; a time when Nigeria , as the big brother of Africa , allowed its Ghanaian neighbors to come into the country taking over commerce, industry and even academics. The Ghanaians filled up our (Nigerian) schools without any known quota systems for employment. They dominated the industry of electronic sales and commanded factories where casual labors were required. As a result my nursery, primary, secondary and part university education were tutored by Ghanaian teachers. Except at the university level, every subject or 90% of the subjects I ever took were done by Ghanaians. In my days, Ghanaians will tell pupils (us) that; “your pronunciation is horrible”. My teachers never acknowledge anything right with or inside Nigeria yet they lived here at the expense of Nigeria . Our Ghanaian teachers kept running us down as though we were fools speaking in our own style and culturally influenced phonology! The psychological trauma of that is; if someone tells you repeatedly- for so many years- that you are no good, you start to think and believe that indeed you are no good! At a point in my life, I found myself believing it, repeating it, running it and projecting that value; that Ghanaians were phonologically better than Nigerians. (this is my attempt not to delve into their political and social comments about Nigerians- their hosts. That is not the intention of this piece now). I believed them and even tried to speak like them! (My feelings of disgust with myself now, as I write this part, is what late Fela Anikulapo Kuti would have felt when he recollected that at some point in his life he would have gone to church and believed in the priests and their doctrine!)

However, I started my rebellion with “Ghanaianized” phonetics after I made my distinction in English and was one of the three students out of 275 students who passed WAEC’s "oral English" in my class for that year in the school. Then I started telling myself, in retrospect, Mr. Appiajey was wrong; My Koffi was never right; Mr Archipong must have been wrong; Mr. Osei Tutu will ever die in ignorance because my English was not as bad as they said to me and indeed everyone else in our school!

With that, I learnt an important lesson; it is not right to laugh at the other person and as such hardly will one ever be caught saying that someone else’s culture, religion or style of projecting an idiosyncrasy is superior or inferior! Everyone is unique in his or her own peculiarity.

My fellow Nigerians, the psychological trauma of repeatedly telling you your culture is not good enough by your own half brother is really a torture. It is amazing how much these teaching by Ghanaians are still lingering in Nigeria . Only this October 2007, I encountered friends who still repeat the same complex-filled statement about Ghanaian English phonetics being better and superior to Nigerian phonetics. What this means is that ever since the Ghanaians stopped teaching us, every Nigeria generation still believes that every Ghanaian who speaks in English language is automatically and prejudicial accorded the respect of "better native English speaker" it is the same thing as saying every Briton in Nigeria, or every American you find writes or reads or has higher competence in intellectualism than you! But that is not true.... that is not true. Prejudicing on another person's oral phonology is as if one thinks that the American pronunciation of English is better than the Briton or to fail to realize that the New Zealanders speak different sociologically influenced English than the Australians. Who is judging which is better? The Americans use fowl languages and spell English differently but because they have more money than most people...who cares...? Meanwhile American English and pronunciation have become subjects of PhD thesis and linguistic studies.

All in all, the little emotion in this piece is not targeted at anyone or least of all, to commence racial prejudice against the other race. My target is the unconscious structure which places someone else's manner of diction and phonetics over and above mine! I am a Nigerian, a Yoruba man, and an Ijebu breed. I will surely pronounce English as though I taste “Ebiripo or Ikokore” and I will not offer any apologies to anyone least of all the queen!

So dear readers, I hope you can understand if one day someone from your race in the face of other nationals agrees that you are, because of your skin/culture/intelligence or personal styles, inferior! I can see you shouting that... “I beg your pardon- take that back or I smash your face!”

Dele A. Sonubi can be reached at dele4you2@yahoo.com



Your Comments

Please make The Square an enjoyable experience for everyone by refraining from gratuitous ad-hominem contributions, defamatory comments and off-topic posting. Such posts will be removed.

User Avatar
RobotRobot is offline

 # 1 | 23.10.2007 09:35

I once encountered a scenario where some fellow Nigerians with another Ghanaian were laughing at ...Read the full article.

User Avatar
EdnutEdnut is offline

 # 2 | 24.10.2007 21:46

By Dele A. Sonubi
Wednesday, 24 October 2007

I once encountered a scenario where some fellow Nigerians with another Ghanaian were laughing at Nigerian’s way of speaking.



Dele, is there "Nigeria's way of speaking"? Do people from different regions in Nigeria speak the same way? Just asking?

User Avatar
UglyManUglyMan is offline

 # 3 | 24.10.2007 22:44

Hello, Bros Dele, are you a student of the interesting field of phonology?

It is not disputable that the phonetics of the English language varies according to geographical locations and countries. It is also not disputable that even within each English-speaking country, some phonemic issues (such as the distinctions in sounds between the letters A and E or P and B or between Q and K or V and F) are further complicated by the phonetics of our local languages (when a person speaks both the local language and English). For example, Yoruba and Igbo people, when speaking in their local languages, pronounce the letter “E” the way an English man pronounces the letter “A” so that dele is pronounced by a Yoruba as “dail air” while an English man would see dele and pronounce it “dail”.

I cannot fault your story of people rating Ghanaian pronunciation of English words better than Nigerian pronunciation because your article is the first time I am made aware of this misunderstanding between Ghanaians and Nigerians. I have never personally encountered such misunderstanding (for that is exactly what it is, a misunderstanding of the field of phonology).

My point is that I fail to see how one country’s pronunciation of English words can be rated better than that of another country. Different, yes, but better, no. What standard of measurement was used by those you encountered who were engaged in such rating? I am curious.

Is a form of pronunciation of an English word rated better because it is assumed that it is closer to the sounds made by the people of England when pronouncing the same word? Is that the standard? If that is the standard, then I think I have the proper response to the Ghanaians : Nigerians speak Nigerian English and Ghanaians speak Ghanaian English just like Americans speak American English and Canadians and Australians speak their own forms of English.

British people speak and pronounce words in English in ways peculiar to their own region. Even within the geographical region known as Britain, you find local variations in the pronunciations of the same words.

User Avatar
AbraxasAbraxas is offline

 # 4 | 25.10.2007 01:58

Hi, UglyMan!

T'ank yoo very mush, o'jare.

Mucas gracias.

Don Juan-Carlos ABRAXAS
(III)

User Avatar
AuspiciousAuspicious is offline

 # 5 | 25.10.2007 02:22

Said the "Ghenien" in Auspicious:

Eh, Challo. Fire is bening in ye Heuse end ell you er cencened weth is Pheneteks? Ell yer lehders err beyin Mehcehdehs end you err telking ebout hew we Gheniens speak? Eh, Challo, ei em serry feh yu.

Eh, whet is wreng weth yu? Englesh es net mey Lenguege, so ei dent cerr. Emehgene, yu thenk me ei well feight you ovehrr eneder mehn's lenguege? Ef ei do thet, then ei em eneder Celeneized Mugu - e sefferer of Celementelety, eccerding to ya Fela.

Emergine, dey err feightin about who spehks Englesh betehrr - who cehrs?

Kofi Espicies.

User Avatar
CelticologistCelticologist is offline

 # 6 | 25.10.2007 04:33

Hey massa, please step making Gheniens look bed!. They are like bled bradas.

User Avatar
Dele4youDele4you is offline

 # 7 | 25.10.2007 05:57

Dearest UglyMan,
I agree with you on your points that it is absolutely wrong to judge who speaks better. You are indeed a student of phonology and you have the technics to convince me further in this regard.
However, I did point out that this basterdisation started in the mid 70s when teachers of Ghanianian origin flittered the Nigerian Educational systems. The Ghanian economy was undergoing some recessions then and our neighbours came over to seek paid employment. It is just that in my mind and in the soul of many other Nigerians who went through them in those years, they left lasting impression which Nigerians must make conscious efforts to debunk. I like your own arguments more than mine. I will start using your as technical campaign.
I also agree there are other issues in nigeria more perennial than phonology. But...Madam speaker is getting too many media attention and we should begin to look away from her and face other sides of life:biggrin:

User Avatar
CelticologistCelticologist is offline

 # 8 | 25.10.2007 07:00


=UglyMan;2091812865>
My point is that I fail to see how one country’s pronunciation of English words can be rated better than that of another country. Different, yes, but better, no. What standard of measurement was used by those you encountered who were engaged in such rating? I am curious.



Measurement?, well, I love languages, but I realize that the more money you have, the better your accent is likely to be useful or looked nicely upon. You can now watch TV adverts done in totally Hispanic or Asian english On US Tv. I haven't seen the Taco Bell advert in a long time. Anyone remember "yes, drop the chalupa"?. But I remember a number of Asians doing adverts for GE.

Have you ever heard some East Africans talking?. Nice accent no?. I once listened to a Kenyan complaining about the "Nigerian accent" of english and how "bad" it was to understand. *(his own english pronounciation was quite terrible). Then as we progressed to other things, I heard him say:..."Nerison Mandera and chief Butherezi are onry praying poritics".

I looked at him strangely, expecting one of us to laugh...but I don't think he got the joke.

User Avatar
Oru-AmaOru-Ama is offline

 # 9 | 25.10.2007 07:50

They were praising Ghanaian pronunciation as superior to the Nigerian English pronunciation and happily noting that the Ghanaians speak the proper Queen’s English while Nigerians do not.


Huh! that someone could say that Ghanaians speak proper Queen's English is laughable. I once ran into a Ghanaian who wanted to put Nigeria and Nigerians down. Immediately he started, I simply cautioned him to watch his utterances or shut his mouth! I really meant it and was in no mood for the nonsense he was about to vomit out. A colleague of mine was shocked the way I reacted to the guy. It is not because I am a Nigerian but I do not think there is basis for comparing Nigerians and Ghanaians. It was when I got to England that I realized that Ghanaians have this erroneous impression that they are superior to Nigerians.

After reading this thread and was discussing it with my boss, he told me that a Ghanaian guy had once told him that their women make better wives than Nigerian women, and that he told the guy the reason is simply because when you marry a retired prostitute, they turn out to be better housewives because they have seen it all. My boss said the guy took an exception to that statement and that he never apologised for telling him that.

Just like they are proud of their country and ready to flaunt it, I am a Nigerian and proud of my country and I am also ready to flaunt Nigeria.

My advice is whenever and wherever you meet them, do not allow them to put you down. Before they start, put them in their place... that's what I do!

User Avatar
bakoso2000bakoso2000 is offline

 # 10 | 25.10.2007 09:20

Methink that we Nigerians are overly too generous to our neighbors who sometimes take our generousity for stupidity. We are far too accommodating. Now that economic fortune has turned full cycle in favor of Ghana; go there and see how Nigerians are treated!

The quest for cheap labor by private school owners can also be blamed for the uncontrolled inflow of foriegn teachers into our schools. The proprietors will prefer to render Nigerian teachers jobless and ignore the excesses of these Ghanaians as long as their profit is guaranteed.

It is also easy to see the crack in the Nigerian family - Yoruba, Hausa, Igbo. We advertise our differences for the world to see and this brings nothing but disrespect. There are ethnic differences in Ghana too but Ghanaians do not allow the subject to predominate the way we Nigerians do.

Most of our neighbors don't wish us well and they are jealous of our blessings which we've always taken for granted. If we are patriotic and if we learn to celebrate the good qualities which make us Nigerian, it will be very difficult for any immigrant to look down on us or ridicule the way we speak in our country.
 

Services : E-mail news | RSS Feeds | Podcasts
Links:   About the NVS | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies | Advertise With Us
All Rights Reserved. NigeriaVillageSquare.com