Home arrow Authors arrow Chukwudi Nwokoye arrow Abortion Versus Contraception
Abortion Versus Contraception Print E-mail
Written by Chukwudi Nwokoye   
Wednesday, 13 August 2008

Reading the above article titled: “Abortion Is A Sacrifice Satan” written by Okechukwu Peter Nwobu and published in nigeriavillagesquare.com on 9th August, 2008, makes an interesting reading. I agree mostly with what he said, though I do not want to go spiritual as to whose sacrifice abortion was for. However, where I feel that the author, and in fact most people that write about this topic fail to address is the issue of prevention, in this case, contraception.

To be clear I am of the Catholic faith. I was born a catholic and by His grace, I will die a catholic and I make no apologies for professing my faith. Having taking that monkey off my back; I will now go ahead to discuss the issue which my faith forbids, which is contraception. The Catholic Church forbids abortion and personally, I am opposed to killing of any kind. Abortion no matter how anybody views it is murder. Killing of a human being, to me is murder. I do not want to go through the legal rigmarole and the legal personality of a fetus. Some believe that it is not a human being while some believe it is. That is not the essence of this discourse. Whether we believe it or not, you do not have to share my faith or to even be a Christian to feel that there is something wrong here. Even before the advent of Christianity in Africa, our forefathers knew that taking the life of another in whatever form, is an abomination, and calls for ‘ikpu alu’-cleansing of the abomination.

So if most people view abortion as murder or killing of a human being, why then do we shy away from trying to prevent a situation that will lead to a situation where killing of the innocent human beings becomes an option? I love my Christian faith forever, but I still do not understand why the Catholic Church outlaws abortion on one hand and then on the other hand, is against every form of contraceptive or sex education. It made no sense to me when I was young, and it still does not make sense to me now. It is like someone being against killing of mosquitoes, and then turns back and cry about contacting malaria. If you do not eradicate mosquitoes, you must get bouts of malaria.

Whether we fail to understand that the world has changed or not, we are in the computer age. I am not even talking about developed country. Even in the remotest villages, kids are getting more inquisitive and assertive these days. We are in the period of sexual revolution, whether people believe it or not. It may be the sign of the end, I do not know. But this is the situation we found ourselves in. With the age of internet, movies and pop culture, there is no way we can run away from the fact that we need to do something to prevent unwanted pregnancies that lead to abortions. The old adage says that if you are digging and find yourself inside a whole, you stop digging.

Many people argue that it is wrong to teach their kids about sex. Some people think that sex education is coterminous with teaching them how to have sex. It is a wrong assumption. Parents need to do a better job of teaching their kids about what action beget what consequences. In igbo we say “onye nyuo nsi ka o na-aga ahia, o nata ozute ijiji”-if one defecates on his way to the market, on his way back flies will welcome him. If we fail to prepare our teenage kids about what the consequences of pre-marital sex, then we should not blame them for the ignorance. We have to teach them right and wrong. You have to do your own part and leave the rest to God. Do not assume that teaching them about life is exposing them to promiscuity. Whatever you say to them, they would still do what they want to do. It only takes the grace of God.

I am a firm believer of abstinence as my faith taught me. Medically, psychologically and morally speaking, this is the best way to prevent not only unwanted pregnancy but venereal diseases including the most dreaded of them called AIDS (Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome). The mantra is that “If you do not have sex, you do not get pregnant or contact venereal disease”. Some parents drum this into the head of their kids. Back in the days when I was in the final year of my University, I met a girl. Though we remained good friends, we never took our friendship to the next level. It was later in life that she explained her fears then to me. She opened up and told me what I could never have thought was possible. Her mother warned her that if a man ‘touches’ her, she would be pregnant. She grew up with that message in her head and was ruled by it, that even a kiss would make her pregnant. Even though at the time, she was considered a big girl, but she knew next to nothing about sexuality. She concluded that if she didn’t have sex, she would not get pregnant. She did not know anything about ovulation cycle or how it worked. She knew everything about most issues at the time, but was so dumb about man and woman issues. It was too complicated to her since she had a bottom-line: no sex, no pregnancy. It was way after her graduation that she knew what was going on. But hers was an exception. There are other girls that threw overboard whatever was told to her by their mothers about sex.

Many people like her grow up everyday very ignorant of their body and how it works. In this day and age, teens want to experiment. No matter what you tell them, and no matter how strict you are, they will get their information from their peer groups or through the internet or movies and pop music. Whether you want to talk to them about sex or not, somebody else would do the job for you. May be in the manner you will not like, but someone else will do it for you. We have to be close to our kids, be open to them and be ready to tackle the most difficult issue of sex. If they hear the truth from you, it will help to clear all kinds of doubts and suspicions from their mind. What worked in the time of our fathers does not work now. Morality was a virtue during their time. Now things are different. I could remember the first day my big sister visited my uncle at Onitsha in the early eighties wearing a pair of jean trouser bought for her by my elder brother that just came back from the States. My uncle had a fit! You could then imagine how my mother felt when my sister came home to visit my parents in the village. But now even in interior villages, girls wearing trousers is just as normal as if it involves their male counterparts. Time has changed.

I am not saying that we should buy them condoms or contraceptives or teach them the graphics about sex. What I am saying is that we have to not only stress abstinence and the virtue of sex after marriage, but also we should not shy away from teaching them about how to protect themselves. It is good to teach them that their bodies are the temple of God and urge teach them the virtue of morality. However, abstinence sounds good to the ear, but how many people can do without sex? With the youthful blood running in their veins, I doubt it if most young men and women could ‘hold their fire’ until after marriage. Contraception should be at the last resort. It should be the exception and not the rule. Teaching our teens about contraception is not teaching them sexual immorality.

On the contrary, if you do not teach them about contraception, how are you going to tackle the issue of when they become pregnant or get a girl pregnant? If you do not teach them prevention, how are you going to deal with the resultant contraction of HIV/AIDS or other venereal diseases? If you do not let them know about prevention, how is your economic situation going to fare if they bring kids in the world which neither you nor them are prepared for taking into cognizance the economic realities of our time? If they are ignorant of the consequences of unprotected sex, how are they going to progress in life knowing that their own lives is tied up now with the arrival of a baby they are neither physically, psychologically financially prepared to cater for? If you keep them in the dark about sexuality, how will you feel if as young teens, they die during child births? And how are you going to deal with the dilemma of choosing between abortion, adoption and having to keep the baby and go through what it takes to raise a child you are unprepared for? Then you have to live with that guilt for the rest of your life.

I have an uncle who was professor in one of Nigerian Universities in 1989. He and his wife are devout Catholics and contraception was out of the question. They were practicing Billings Method successfully for over 20 years of marriage. However, it failed them once! The wife at the time was approaching 50 years of age. Their last child at the time was already 12 years old and in Secondary School. When she was told by her doctor that she was pregnant, it was like a huge joke. She never believed that it was possible considering her age and the fact that they have practiced natural family planning for years. The doctor advised them that for her health, abortion was the only option! Moreover, chances were that the baby would be abnormal when delivered taking into consideration her age. It was devastating news to them. But being anti-abortion due to their faith, they decided to risk it. It was the toughest decision they have faced in their entire life. Finally, when the baby was delivered, they found out that he had “Down Syndrome”. They named him ‘Chinedu’-God directs me. They had to live with the problem that comes with having to raise a new baby with special needs. Chinedu is now about 20 years old, but they still care for her as a baby. He is a cross which they had carried for almost 20 years now, but if they had used protection, Chinedu would not have been born in the first place and they would have been saved from all these. Moreover they would not have been faced with fighting with their conscience and trying to weigh what the world wants and what their conscience told them was right. 

It is wrong for people to equate sex education to sexual permissiveness. They are not the same thing. We have to face reality and stop pretending. It is the holier-than-thou people that do worse. AIDS is real. Even grown men and women are guilty of this. Many people are not necessarily against contraception because of their religious belief, but they hate using condoms because they are not ‘natural’. They rather enjoy the pleasure of ‘flesh to flesh’ despite the already known consequences. Then who do you blame?

Abortion is a crime in Nigeria . It is criminal under the relevant Criminal Code and Penal Code, but does it stop abortion in Nigeria ? Every chemist in every corner performs abortion in Nigeria even though it is a crime. That is the truth. I have seen people that die out of abortions that were carried out by these chemists. Some develop complications that occasion their wombs being removed by specialist doctors to save their lives. This happens every time. This would have been avoided with a better job of stressing contraception.

We should stress the dangers and the ills of abortion, but we should not stop there. Whether you are pro-life or pro-choice, killing of any kind is wrong. Why do we speak forcefully and so passionately against abortion as killing of human being, but not forcefully against killing of already born kids? Why do we shout ‘blue murder’ against abortion but are not forceful enough against wars that destroy innocent children. Why should we denounce abortion but we are ready to send teenagers to die in senseless wars be it in Liberia , Sierra Leone or Iraq ? Many people of the world speak out forcefully against abortion, but are not speaking out in like manner against hunger and starvation, AIDS and other diseases that have killed millions of children all over the world. It is like saying “if you are killed in your mother’s womb, it is an abomination. But if you are killed outside the womb, it is ok.”

I think that the Catholic Church should as a matter of urgency lift this ban on contraceptives. This hard-line posture by the church and other religious groups never worked and would never work now or in the future. We should preach anti-abortion, but at the same time, we have to push contraception as the way to reduce the scourge of AIDS and other sexually transmitted diseases, unwanted and unprepared for pregnancies and poverty. We should stress abstinence and adoption without forgetting the old saying “prevention is better than cure”.





RobotRobot is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 1

Reading the above article
titled: “Abortion Is A Sacrifice Satan” written by Okechukwu...Read the full article.

Posted by Robot| 13.08.2008 22:16

Reply Quote



Serious_NaijababeSerious_Naijababe is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 2

I enjoyed your point of view on this issue and I am one that subscribes to the same school of thought. Awareness and education can prevent many unwanted pregnancies.

I also cannot understand why the Catholic church is adamantly against contraceptives. I watched a documentary once on NBC, where a woman had to give up so many of her children because of this Catholic church belief. I felt sorry for the families and the unthinkable happened years later, one of the daughters dated her brother. It was a sad case. After doing the do, they know something was weird. It just never felt right. One of the guys was even best friends with his blood sibling but he had no idea- till he decided to go looking for his birth parents.

Their mother had over 15 children but the family could only take care of 3 or 4 children. She gave her children up for adoption, but she ensured they stayed close by. Tell me, is the Catholic church ok with a brother sleeping with his sister all in the name of no contraception? I am 100% sure if the Catholic believed in family planning, these two kids would have grown up in the same household and never have been victims of circumstance.


To be clear, I am not against the Catholic Church but I am not for their no contraceptive doctrine. Now if the Pope will pay to raise the billions of kids born due to this belief, then hey I don't see a problem. Just kidding, one's life could be at risk, I wouldn't advice bearing children in an old age. My mother's friend died in labor at the age of 50. She had been advised that the pregnancy could take her life but because of her anti-abortion beliefs, she proceeded and she's no longer here today. Now that boy has to go on living bearing a terrible name, gosh I hate such names. Everyone has such in their culture.

God help us all.

Posted by Serious_Naijababe| 13.08.2008 22:54

Reply Quote



philipikitaphilipikita is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 3


=Serious_Naijababe;4295083299>... Awareness and education can prevent many unwanted pregnancies...



Precisely the "core" solution. Education does many wonders!

Posted by philipikita| 14.08.2008 00:37

Reply Quote



allaccessallaccess is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 4

Lack of education and backward traditional beliefs are some of the bane of black Africa; people in Africa are having children because of cultural thinking dating back to the time of Alexander the great! IT is still normal for people to have as many children as possible so as to show virility, neighbourhood respect, tradition titles and for simple reasons like “God will provide”.
The resultant palaver from this is that these offspring will be condemned to a miserable life of poverty, and may end up as nothing more than the fly infested faces of Africa on CNN and BBC.
Many African parents have since died and left millions of poverty stricken kids who have no choice but to risk shark infested waters to get to Europe.
Having children for the sake of it should be a Human rights violation and punishable by chemical castration.
It is a humanly right to procreate but it is also a humanly right to be expected to have the basic right of child living bestowed on you before you are able to fend for yourself.

Spread the word and change the face of childbirth in Africa.

Posted by allaccess| 14.08.2008 05:46

Reply Quote



Mikky jagaMikky jaga is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 5

Unfortunately, you are looking at only one side of the issue. On the part of the clergy, how do you teach contraception when your faith regards any form of sex outside marriage as mortal sin. Are you trying to tell the Reverend fathers that contraception reduces the gravity of the sin. This is not according to the bible they are sworn to teach!

The last time I checked, Biology is a general science subjects taught in seconmdary school to both arts and science students. Many, including myself, first learnt of reproductive system during such classes.

Let the clergy preach abstinence and nothing else. Let others tell the children there are other alternatives. As long as there is no adverse effect to abstinence, I do not think the clergy are doing any harm if their followers decide to accept their teaching without question.

On the woman that got pregnant at 50 and delivered a "down syndrome" child, well that is not peculiar, some have given birth to deformed children well below that age. The case of a woman that had complication as a result of treatment received during pregnancy comes in handy here.

Billings method, by the way, is one of the recommended methods of child spacing. All of them do not have equal rate of success. If pregnancy occurs in spite of all your efforts (as married people) allow it to stay. Try all your best to save the lives of baby and mother, but, by all means do not deliberately kill either of the parties. Women and or children die even during "normal" deliveries so, if after you have tried your best, one or the other died, so be it.

Posted by Mikky jaga| 14.08.2008 05:57

Reply Quote



KabikalaKabikala is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 6

God bless you Okechukwu.
I am a Christian too (though not Catholic) but some things continue to confound me about the Catholic faith. This issue of being against all forms of artificial contraception is one that makes no sense at all to me from the perspective you have highlighted. But it is even worse because the doctrine was not in any way drawn from the Bible. It was said to be the opinion of a Pope which has now been binding Catholics for generations. It is especially inhuman in the case of HIV infection as the Catholic Church is against an uninfected partner using condom to prevent getting infected by an infected partner.
I wish we have more realistic and logical Catholics like you.
_________________________
_________________________
Mikky Jaga:
The Catholic Church is against the use of artificial contraception even by married couples. So you know the problem is not inability to preach abstinence with contraception. It is direct rather a serious opposition to effective methods of preventing pregnancy while having sex whether within a sinful or holy inter-gender relationship.

Posted by Kabikala| 14.08.2008 09:35

Reply Quote



Mikky jagaMikky jaga is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 7


=Kabikala;4295083419>Mikky Jaga:
The Catholic Church is against the use of artificial contraception even by married couples. So you know the problem is not inability to preach abstinence with contraception. It is direct rather a serious opposition to effective methods of preventing pregnancy while having sex whether within a sinful or holy inter-gender relationship.



I do not subscribe to contraceptives either, I believe in abstinence and I am not a Catholic either. So, you must have gotten me wrong there. Billing's method, to my knowledge works on the abstnence principle and it is accepted by the church.

Posted by Mikky jaga| 14.08.2008 09:45

Reply Quote



valteenavalteena is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 8


=allaccess;4295083361>Lack of education and backward traditional beliefs are some of the bane of black Africa; people in Africa are having children because of cultural thinking dating back to the time of Alexander the great! IT is still normal for people to have as many children as possible so as to show virility, neighbourhood respect, tradition titles and for simple reasons like “God will provide”.
The resultant palaver from this is that these offspring will be condemned to a miserable life of poverty, and may end up as nothing more than the fly infested faces of Africa on CNN and BBC.
Many African parents have since died and left millions of poverty stricken kids who have no choice but to risk shark infested waters to get to Europe.
Having children for the sake of it should be a Human rights violation and punishable by chemical castration.
It is a humanly right to procreate but it is also a humanly right to be expected to have the basic right of child living bestowed on you before you are able to fend for yourself.

Spread the word and change the face of childbirth in Africa.



What exactly are you ranting on about? The issue here is abortion and not those who decide to have many children for whatever reason which I think has nothing to do with you in any case. Are you feeding any of those children or providing for any of those family?
Those dead parent and fly infested faces of children as you put it on CNN an BBC is not as a result of people having as many children as possible. It is more to do with corruption, mismanagement, wars and sometimes natural disaster which can happen any where.
If you want to tackle child neglect and abuse then do so seperately so we know. And don't just make blanket Judgements about our beliefs and value that are not valid

Posted by valteena| 14.08.2008 09:47

Reply Quote



allaccessallaccess is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 9


=valteena;4295083424>What exactly are you ranting on about? The issue here is abortion and not those who decide to have many children for whatever reason which I think has nothing to do with you in any case. Are you feeding any of those children or providing for any of those family?
Those dead parent and fly infested faces of children as you put it on CNN an BBC is not as a result of people having as many children as possible. It is more to do with corruption, mismanagement, wars and sometimes natural disaster which can happen any where.
If you want to tackle child neglect and abuse then do so seperately so we know. And don't just make blanket Judgements about our beliefs and value that are not valid



Sister (or brother),

Abortion, prevention, reproduction and procreation are seriously tied to the issue of fly infested faces, disease and poverty in Africa, and the sooner you get your pretty head around it the better. There is no famine or war or natural disaster in Nigerian but there are children born to suffer from day one. Are you happy with that? Could couples not have managed childbirth better and ensured they planned their budget around their responsibilities?
It is the sort of silly inept attitude by black Africans that completely makes the issue ignored; people are so iterate they cannot even work out the reason for the child mortality rate in Africa. They don’t understand it and they won’t discuss it. It all gets blamed on war, famine and corruption. What happened to discussing responsibility and sensibility as part of an abortion discussion?
It is the same backward thinking that got Africa where it is today; have as many children as you can and just blame it on corruption if you cannot feed them.

Posted by allaccess| 14.08.2008 12:37

Reply Quote



KabikalaKabikala is offline 
Villager

avatar
 # 10


=Mikky jaga;4295083422>I do not subscribe to contraceptives either, I believe in abstinence and I am not a Catholic either. So, you must have gotten me wrong there. Billing's method, to my knowledge works on the abstnence principle and it is accepted by the church.



I need to understand your point better.
Are you saying married couples should also not use contraception and practice periodic abstinence alone?
What do you mean when you say you are also against contraception? Is it because you also think God does not approve of it (as preached by Catholics), even within marriage?

Posted by Kabikala| 14.08.2008 14:47

Reply Quote


Last Updated ( Thursday, 14 August 2008 )
 
< Prev   Next >