03

Feb

2009

Addax’s Latest Oil Discovery Is Not Good News For Imo State PDF Print E-mail
By Ayo Akinfe
03 February 2009

Addax’s latest oil discovery is not good news for Imo State 

By Ayo Akinfe 

Over the last week, Canadian oil giant Addax Petroleum announced that it had struck new oil deposits in the Njaba Basin in Imo State. Like any other oil company, Addax celebrated the news and began drawing up plans to cash in on its discovery, with obviously no mention of what impact the finding of this Aladdin’s Cave will have on Nigeria. 

In a sane and rational world, one would assume that such a find would be good news for the Nigerian economy as it would boost export earnings, create jobs, act as a spur for the local environment, create associated employment and serve as a catalyst for regeneration across Imo State. However, our experience in Nigeria tells us that this is unlikely to be the case as history has shown us that such finds have done next to nothing for our people. 

Apart from the overwhelming evidence from the Niger Delta to prove that oil discovery means nothing to the lives of the people in whose community it is found, we actually know that in many cases, it actually leads to worsening living standards. Apart from this, we also know that oil has led to the decimation of many local industries that thrived before the black oil curse was cast on our people. 

Across the Niger Delta, we used to have thriving fishing, basket-making, weaving, canoe-building and net-making industries before slicks and gas firing decimated the region. Since 1958, oil has rendered millions of people unemployed across the Niger Delta, with the petroleum industry failing to absorb even one tenth of them. 

Addax Petroleum currently produces approximately 6,000 barrels per day from the Ossu and Izombe fields in OML124 in Imo State and with this latest find that figure is likely to increase significantly. What nobody has told us is how or even whether the lives of the people of Imo State will be improved as a result of the discovery. 

Knowing that cynicism has become a national pastime across Nigeria, I would hate to join the ranks of the naysayers, so I am inclined to give Addax the benefit of the doubt in certain regards. They must have seen what is going on to the south of Imo State, we now have a 13% derivation formula in place and the Niger Delta Development Commission is trying to build critical infrastructure across Nigeria’s nine oil-producing states. 

Having said that, it remains to be seen if Addax and our administrators have learnt from past mistakes. However, for arguments sake, let us give Ufot Ekaette the benefit of the doubt. Oil in itself is not the main problem as far as I am concerned but what makes it a curse is that it has stifled our national development. As of now, 95% of Nigeria’s export earnings come from crude oil sales and there are no plans whatsoever to alter this. 

So long as the taps keep flowing, we as a people are content to sit back, live off the proceeds and delude ourselves into thinking that crude is an infinite resource. We have made no serious attempt to diversify our economy, get manufacturing going, revive agriculture, develop a modern tourist industry, learn how to provide world-class services or explore the plethora of opportunities solid minerals offer. 

Now and again we hear half-hearted proclamations from government ministers but on the evidence so far, this is nothing but political posturing. Apart from maybe Lagos State, no other state in the federation is capable of sustaining itself without the handout known as federal allocation. 

If the finance ministry in Abuja decided that for one month it would not share out revenue, our states would become paralysed. Not only would workers’ salaries not be paid but the actual state structure would freeze. There would be no schools, health centres or even state houses of assembly functioning. 

Unlike most other oil-producing countries, crude oil has created an unprecedented dependency culture in Nigeria that is actually very frightening. What right has a state got to its existence if it cannot meet its running costs out of its own internally generated revenue? 

There is something morally repugnant about a state governor shamelessly going to queue in Abuja every month for federal handouts with no long-term plans to ever make his state financially independent. I would go as far as saying that having the ability to run your own affairs without federal aid should be criteria for the existence of a state. 

Fortunately for us in Nigeria, none of our 36 states are located in barren deserts where nothing grows, there are no resources and economic activity is impossible. Our inability to generate non-oil revenue is down to nothing but a lack of political will on the part of our leaders. 

Seeing how long this has gone on for, it is hard to reach any other conclusion than the view that we are never going to get off our collect behinds and do anything about it until the oil runs out. They say necessity is the mother or invention, so it may just be that without oil, the bony hand of hunger might force us into getting our collective acts together. 

Countries with similar climatic conditions as Nigeria such as Brazil, Indonesia, Malaysia, Pakistan, India and Thailand, make nothing less than $20bn a year from agricultural export earnings. There is simply no reason why Nigeria cannot at least match this. With the amount of arable land we have at our disposal, revenue from our farm produce exports should easily surpass what we currently get from oil. 

If Malaysia can generate $10bn from palm oil export sales alone, nothing is stopping Nigeria with more than 10 times the amount of cultivatable land from raising at least $50bn annually. Given that the Malaysians got their seedlings from Nigeria originally, this alone should shame us into getting our act together. What does it take to produce hybrid seeds, woo commercial farmers, get our smallholders to form co-operatives and introduce semi-processing? 

Leaving agriculture aside, are countries such as Myanmar, Pakistan, Vietnam, Cambodia and Bangladesh where the likes of Nike and Reebok manufacture most of their goods any more technologically advanced than Nigeria? Is there anything stopping our erstwhile commerce and industry minister Achike Udenwa from wooing such companies to outsource production to Nigeria? 

Across the banking and telecommunications world, India has stolen a march on everyone by attracting call centres and customer service outfits. I believe Nigerian English sounds more coherent to the average Westerner than that of our Asian cousins and we should have been in there first. 

Wherever one looks, opportunities are limitless if we care to search. Our problem is simply that with the black gold flowing from the Niger Delta, there is no incentive to develop other areas of our economy. As a result, our export earnings are $60bn when they should be $300bn and our gross domestic product is $200bn when it should be $900bn. 

As long as 140m people are scrambling for these meagre resources, Nigeria will never be at ease with itself and all the ensuing socio-economic problems that come with poverty will continue to afflict us. Until it is made mandatory for states to source their own income, I do not see things changing for the better in the near future. 

Maybe having a constitutional provision that allows the president to declare a state of emergency in any state that cannot fund its own annual budget might just do the trick. Whatever short-term problems this will lead to, I believe it is necessary to end this dependency culture that has got us locked into a vicious cycle of take and spend. 

Ayo Akinfe

aakinfe@aol.com



Your Comments

Please make The Square an enjoyable experience for everyone by refraining from gratuitous ad-hominem contributions, defamatory comments and off-topic posting. Such posts will be removed.

User Avatar
RobotRobot is offline

 # 1 | 03.02.2009 01:05

Addax’s latest oil discovery is not good news for Imo State By Ayo Akinfe Over the last week, Canadian oil giant Addax Petroleum announced that it had struck new oil deposits in the Njaba Basin in Imo State. Like any other oil company, Addax celebrated the news and began drawing up plans to cash in on its discovery, with obviously no mention of what impact the finding of this Aladdin’s Cave will have on Nigeria. In a sane and rational world, one would assume that such a find would be good news for the Nigerian economy as it would boost export earnings, create jobs, act as a spur for the local environment, create associated employment and serve as a catalyst for regeneration across Imo State. However, our experience in Nigeria tells us that this is unlikely to be the case as history has shown us that such finds have done next to nothing for our people. Apart from the overwhelming evidence from the Niger Delta to p...Read the full article.

User Avatar
akuluounoakuluouno is offline

 # 2 | 03.02.2009 04:52


Maybe having a constitutional provision that allows the president to declare a state of emergency in any state that cannot fund its own annual budget might just do the trick. Whatever short-term problems this will lead to, I believe it is necessary to end this dependency culture that has got us locked into a vicious cycle of take and spend.



I do not know why the Imo people decided to reveal a well kept secret in Igboland. Well I trust them when it comes to the devastation of their environment. The Igbos know what to do. Thank God Addax is not Shell for one.:D

User Avatar
NED ONED O is offline

 # 3 | 03.02.2009 14:05

Addax's new oil findings in the Njaba area was received with mixed feelings. This area has for decades produced oil for the national economy but have remained without the most basic necessity of life: running water. An ambitious water scheme planned by the Sam Mbakwe administration for the entire Imo West senatorial zone comprising the area has remained unrealized. Similar Sam Mbakwe-initiated water schemes planned for other places in the old and existing Imo state have since become a reality. There is the belief that those piloting the affairs of Imo state today do not even appreciate the existence or the enormity of this problem. This is another paradox of oil in Nigeria.

User Avatar
Anioma777Anioma777 is offline

 # 4 | 03.02.2009 15:45

Actually call me xenophobic and I make no apologies for it in advance. I read this yesterday in the thisday newspaper on my way to Lagos. The way the story was reported that it was an indigenous company I was over joyed only for my uncle and now reading this article that it is Canadian owned.:sad: With all the noise Nigerians make abour their education you will have thought we should be experienced and encouraging for indigenous oil exploration experts.

I agree with the writer there should be a shift away from dependence on oil. As for the oil palm saga, please don't remind me. My dad in the 80s was chairman of the company and he used to lament then about how corruption and lack of forsight is killing that industry.

I personally think Nigerians in the private sector should look at the these untapped economically opportunities and whilst the environment is not really conducive in terms of goverment support etc. One should try. I will hate to see what happens if oil prices dont increase significantly.

Also with more and more people finding alternative energy sources we need to get our act together.

User Avatar
felixfelix is offline

 # 5 | 03.02.2009 16:36


Knowing that cynicism has become a national pastime across Nigeria, I would hate to join the ranks of the naysayers, so I am inclined to give Addax the benefit of the doubt in certain regards. They must have seen what is going on to the south of Imo State, we now have a 13% derivation formula in place and the Niger Delta Development Commission is trying to build critical infrastructure across Nigeria’s nine oil-producing states.

Having said that, it remains to be seen if Addax and our administrators have learnt from past mistakes. However, for arguments sake, let us give Ufot Ekaette the benefit of the doubt. Oil in itself is not the main problem as far as I am concerned but what makes it a curse is that it has stifled our national development. As of now, 95% of Nigeria’s export earnings come from crude oil sales and there are no plans whatsoever to alter this.



You know what you are doing...The idea of giving a man who has decided to suck you dry another "chance" to suck more doesnt make sense..The people of this area have seen the destruction that comes with oil exploration/expolitation in Nigeria for over 50 years now and if they will have a say ,will prefer to see the process go in a way that the immedaite communities that produces the oil will benefit from it..As it stand now, if there is no strong PUSH , there is a zero chance of the wicked exploitation of the oil communities by the Nigerian state abating! So I dont know what gave you the hope to preach about giving oil companies "a chance"..How many people have you seen come back here after they die??? After giving these criminals "chance" for over half a century, you still see the intelligence in giving them more "chance"???Where is the federal government presence in these areas? Yaradua and co should go and drill in Katsina and Zamfara!chikena! I dont know what is the good news in discovering oil in another community that will be destroyed just to inflate the torsos of the Obasanjos and the Danjumas ...



Now and again we hear half-hearted proclamations from government ministers but on the evidence so far, this is nothing but political posturing. Apart from maybe Lagos State, no other state in the federation is capable of sustaining itself without the handout known as federal allocation.



Again you are wrong! During the days of high oil prices few weeks ago, we all read about how Alaska was doing so well. Our federal constitution follows that of the Americans. So why will Imo state pump billion into Abuja coffers and at the end of the day you say Imo state is not viable? That is a very clever but mischevious argeument! Lagos maybe viable, but the same is the case with Bayelsa, Rivers, Imo, Abia, Delta and co...Those states are being robbed on daily basis by the Nigerian state! Allow them to control their resources and tell me wether some of them will not be more viable than most countries in the West Africa sub-region. Without oil, there may have been no difference between Lagos and Warri..It is oil money invested in the federal capital that drew the large pool of cash and professionals that "developed" Lagos..Agreed; there is a need for diversifaction but the path to this is not to channel the resources from the states that are nothing but malgamating units to a center controled by tribal zealots, who will corner the proceeds, and pour it to "their areas" by creating uncountable local governments and states while destroying whatever that is left in the federal coffers with corruption..


Across the banking and telecommunications world, India has stolen a march on everyone by attracting call centres and customer service outfits. I believe Nigerian English sounds more coherent to the average Westerner than that of our Asian cousins and we should have been in there first.



When it comes to western investments, it seems Africans tend to beleive that all they need to do to bring in such investments is to put up the structures..This may not be totally treu..There are certian areas in India and Vietnam that lack infastructural development more than Okpoko in Onitsha,or Mushin in Lagos yet Oyibo still manages to overlook these things and poor in the dollars..Agreed, Nigeria is messed up but how about Ghana? Codvoire, Senegal, gambia or even kenya, Tanzania etc.. Some of these countries are smaller and though not blessed with the mosts efficient governments , have managed over the years to put up some necessary backbone needed for reasonable investments to flow in but all Oyibo goes to see there are the giraffes , the mating hippos and dancing massas! A cotrolled global market may lead to some sort of controlled investments depending on the mentality of the investors! You cant tell me the Myanmar is better organised than Ghana!

User Avatar
Ayo AkinfeAyo Akinfe is offline

 # 6 | 03.02.2009 16:52

Felix, can we please keep the ethnic baiting out of the discussion please. Life in Katsina and Zamfara States is not any better than it is in Imo State.

User Avatar
felixfelix is offline

 # 7 | 03.02.2009 17:18


=Ayo from CE;321173>Felix, can we please keep the ethnic baiting out of the discussion please. Life in Katsina and Zamfara States is not any better than it is in Imo State.



A Katsina man has no right to dictate, exploit , misuse and allocate to say an Imo man resources/proceeds from Imo state in a vintage federal system...That is the fact my friend and not ethnic baiting! I have not seen proceeds from Groundnut being shared all over the country....You may need to read up your Pol Sc 101 again before you start to pontificate..

User Avatar
Ayo AkinfeAyo Akinfe is offline

 # 8 | 03.02.2009 17:47

Felix, I am a big proponent of resource control and want to see states controlling what is produced locally. In your case, however, I suspect you are being selective here.

I take it you know that during the First Republic, all the proceeds from the Niger Delta were taken to develop places like Enugu, Nsukka, Owerri, Onitsha, Umuahia, Aba, etc in the old Eastern Region, while the oil and fish-producing communities in modern day Rivers, Bayelsa and Akwa Ibom States were deprived. Can you please condemn that too.

This is not a Katsina/Imo thing. We will be here all day talking about it. Hopefully, my book dealing with the subject will be out soon.

User Avatar
felixfelix is offline

 # 9 | 03.02.2009 18:15


=Ayo from CE;321209>Felix, I am a big proponent of resource control and want to see states controlling what is produced locally. In your case, however, I suspect you are being selective here.

I take it you know that during the First Republic, all the proceeds from the Niger Delta were taken to develop places like Enugu, Nsukka, Owerri, Onitsha, Umuahia, Aba, etc in the old Eastern Region, while the oil and fish-producing communities in modern day Rivers, Bayelsa and Akwa Ibom States were deprived. Can you please condemn that too.

This is not a Katsina/Imo thing. We will be here all day talking about it. Hopefully, my book dealing with the subject will be out soon.



With all respects, I dont know what you are rambling about up there! Proceeds from Niger Delta oil? used to biuld where in the first republic? When?Have you heard of palm oil and Coal in the first republlic eastern Nigeria? When did Nigeria start making money seriously from oil exploration and from which oil wells? So define your Niger Delta here..This is what you are going to write in your book? This is the way you guys spread misinformation.Have you heard of the ongoing clamour for the creation of the so called Njaba state for the past 10 years or thereabout? What was the response from Abuja? The region from which this Njaba comes from has the least number of states in Nigeria while others that contributes nothing have more...I am pointing this out to you and you say it is ethnic baiting..All you want is peace so your almighty Addax will have the "chance" to plunder.

Njaba state is not viable but Njaba is viable enough to be exploited of her mineral deposits?.. Baylesa has 8 or so local government and Kano almost 50! The number of Local governments in Katsina is almost double that of Njabas Imo state! What is the criteria?? Have you been to the oil producing areas in Imo state? Have you seen the gas flares that have been there for decads? Have you seen the erosion menace in the Njaba area??? What is Abuja doing about this? When the people from this area accept your sermon and give your Addax "a chance" to explore non stop without their influence, who is going to handle the alarming enviromental degradation that comes with such activities? Ekaete???My piont is that other parts of the country should get off their "lazy behind" and do some work! The actual ethnic baiting is when you skillfully deposit an article here that suppourts a process that will ensure the evacuation of oil deposits from Njaba to biuld Abuja while people in those areas are still living in caves.....

User Avatar
Ayo AkinfeAyo Akinfe is offline

 # 10 | 03.02.2009 18:58

Felix, Nigeria discovered oil in 1958. Between then and 1966, we had resource control with the Eastern Region government getting the proceeds and just paying tax to Lagos.

Please tell me how much of the money made from Oloibiri Michael Okpara put back into the local community. I can say the same about the fishing, net-making, basket-weaving, canoe-construction, etc industries. My point is that this taking money away from local communities and spending it in the centre is nothing new.

I take it you have been to Hotel Presidential Enugu, UNN Nsukka, Onitsha market, etc that were all build by the government of the old Eastern Region. Were any such facilities built in Brass, Bonny, Okpobo, Degema, Buguma, Yenagoa, etc?

It is not only the Eastern Region that is guilty of this. In the Western Region, it was the modern day Ondo and Ekiti States that produced most of the cocoa wealth that went to build Lagos, Ibadan and Abeokuta.

Hopefully, we will redress some of the problems you have highlighted with resource control but do not think it will solve all our woes. If the Imo State government had all the wealth from Njaba, I put it to you that Owerri would see more of it than the producing communities.

Just look at the 13% currently got by the oil-producing states. How much of it goes to the producing regions? Did you see the State House Odili built in Port Harcourt?
 

Services : E-mail news | RSS Feeds | Podcasts
Links:   About the NVS | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies | Advertise With Us
All Rights Reserved. NigeriaVillageSquare.com