16

Nov

2006

Reasoning on Pat Utomi Presidential Campaign PDF Print E-mail
By Anthony A. Kila

Reasoning on Pat Utomi Presidential Campaign

This article is almost a reaction to Sabella Abidde’s Pat Utomi’s Presidential Campaign, I will therefore advise readers to also read that article.

Sabella Abidde knows more than he is saying thus I will not try to inform nor convince him. Other Nigerians should however know that Pat Utomi is yes trotting the globe, he is however not only seeing Nigerians abroad he is also visiting Nigerians in all those fascinating places Sabella Abidde listed in his article.

The real sad, strange and shocking concern is that Pat Utomi’s visits abroad are more documented and easier to access than his visits in Nigeria. This says something about the level and kind of communication Nigerians in Nigeria are getting.

For those us, campaigning for a issued centred, truly democratic and transparent campaign, it is encouraging to see one man (i.e. Pat Utomi) actually going out to talk to and to listen to people not only to powers.

As long as one is alive, there is always room for improvements and I am sure a lot more can be done to improve Pat Utomi’s presidential campaign; but it is important for us to all bear in mind that this is the only candidate trying to run a truly human and democratic campaign. He is not trying to buy people with money nor is he threatening them with his might. He is simply talking and listening to people that care about Nigeria and that will be affected by the future of Nigeria: the legitimate stakeholders of Nigeria.

The questions we ought to be asking are:

-where are the other contenders?

-who are they and what do they represent?

-What have stood for or against in the past?

-What are their programmes and ideas?

-Who are their supporters and sponsors?

-why are they contesting?

It might also be useful for Nigerians (based home and abroad) to ask themselves: what am I doing to make my country better?

Pat Utomi is making himself available, he is standing up to be counted, he is openly and clearly giving answers to these kind and all other kinds of questions. People should look closer and then draw their conclusions. Nigerians are very good at the latter a bit of practice in the former will be useful. It will also be useful to compare the candidates and their attitudes.

It will be too shameful and maybe unpardonable if this generation of Nigerians chanced to witness the genesis of a possible positive metamorphosis in Nigerian politics will only sit in their armchairs to aimlessly slate and abuse the courtesy shown by the only candidate that amongst many has shown his commitment to treating Nigerians with dignity.

I am of course partisan, and my support is openly and strongly for Pat Utomi’s bid. My choice is however a reasoned one and I am sure I have made the right choice, a choice many of us are convinced will take us towards the much needed transformation of Nigeria.

Sabella Abidde, as said above, however knows more than he is saying and I am sure he, like any other Nigerian that can write or read his kind of article cannot but support Pat Utomi’s Bid. Criticisms such as the one in Sabella Abidde’s article cannot but be aimed at improving things for Pat Utomi’s bid and for Nigeria and for Nigerians.

Our concern is that some people for ignoble reasons might try to twist Sabella Abidde’s words and mislead some gullible souls.

Anthony A Kila



Your Comments

Please make The Square an enjoyable experience for everyone by refraining from gratuitous ad-hominem contributions, defamatory comments and off-topic posting. Such posts will be removed.

User Avatar
RobotRobot is offline

 # 1 | 16.11.2006 19:08


Reasoning on Pat Utomi Presidential Campaign


This articl...Read the full article.

User Avatar
InDiasporaInDiaspora is offline

 # 2 | 16.11.2006 20:23


Sabella Abidde knows more than he is saying thus I will not try to inform nor convince him. Other Nigerians should however know that Pat Utomi is yes trotting the globe, he is however not only seeing Nigerians abroad he is also visiting Nigerians in all those fascinating places Sabella Abidde listed in his article.



How true! In fact I don't know if fellow villagers have noticed how the Utomis, Okoties and other credible candidates receive very low media coverage in Nigeria? The reason, simply because they won't "play ball" or "sort" them.

THISDAY easily comes to mind. THISDAY is the number 1 cash and carry newspaper in Nigeria. Look that their front pages on any given day who do you see? The same usual suspects - Babangida, Atiku, Odili and and those willing and able to pay. They are mischievious in their reportage, skewed in their analyses and fair from being fair and balanced

You will never find them give the same media treatment to Okotie or Utomi, neither will you hear them report of their campaign efforts. The state of our media is sickening. Their payday is just around the corner. They will pay for their action or inactions. It's just a matter of time.

User Avatar
FjordFjord is offline

 # 3 | 17.11.2006 02:12

Dr. Kila,

the main issue in Abidde's article deserves good consideration. You've touched on it. Yes, it is important to ask and seek answers to the questions raised in your article, and those who most need to consider those questions are Nigerians at home. The Utomi Campaign has been doing a good work abroad; Abidde raises the most potent weakness in that approach: an apparent neglect of the peoples at home. Not that one underestimates the ability of Nigerians abroad to affect some change at home (and I'll disagree with Abidde's statistics in his article, including the charge that Nigerians abroad don't move things forward at home. Credible data has shown that remittances from abroad represent a big chunk of the Nigerian economy; the cash can be converted to political power, and that's a strong argument for foreign campaigns), but that must not be overestimated, and certainly not the the neglect of a campaign at home.

One fundamental assumption in Utomi's bid must be that the people's votes will count; let's suppose that that will be true. Surely then, our potential president should be able to effect publicity at home without compromising his principles; perhaps a small group in the Utomi for president organisation should focus on that; it may be the first step in navigating the difficult Nigerian waters.

Post Script: this is a tiny matter, but one deserving some attention. Er, Dr. Utomi was quoted to have made a statement during a visit to the US; words to the effect that only an Igbo could achieve some good for Nigeria were ascribed to him. I don't suppose there was any statement to correct the impression of that. Was the strategy that of letting the dissent die a natural death? There were discussions on this board. It's a tiny matter, but a gesture to assure those who've formed an opinion of the man different from that the statement says may not be a bad idea. Just a tiny note.

.

User Avatar
denkerdenker is offline

 # 4 | 17.11.2006 02:48

Nigerians need leaders, not rulers – Utomi
By Michael Faloseyi and Olalekan Adetayo
Published: Thursday, 16 Nov 2006

You have made it in business and academics, why are you in politics?


Pat Utomi

Politics is far too important to be left to politicians. It is about my life, your life, his or her life and how society gets together to order choices. It is about how society runs and unfortunately for us, the nature of the way that we have made choices, the quality of the choices we have made have left Nigeria in a state far from where it should be. I was in the US last week for a meeting with top government officials and Nigerians. In the morning of my arrival, there was a statement credited to Senator Barak Obama that Nigeria is a country in the throes of collapse. Nigerians don’t enjoy hearing critical things said about them by non-Nigerians particularly. But the truth of the matter is that we could seriously remove ourselves from that sense of who are these people talking about us and look about Nigeria’s condition. What we would find probably is that our country is far from where it should be.

The same week, while I was travelling, there was an economic report that 65m Nigerians were below poverty line, another economic report said that 71m Nigerians were living below poverty line. The truth you and I know is that the quality of life in Nigeria is worse today than it was in 1963. Every society in the world with technology advancement is making progress but one society that I know has been progressively moving the other way is Nigeria. About the same time the quality of life in Nigeria was higher than it is today, the government of Nigeria set up a commission to review higher education, and a professor from Oxford called Eric Ashby chaired the commission. That commission said that tertiary education in Nigeria was as good as the very best in the world. That time, the existing universities were the University of Ibadan, and the University of Nigeria. The University of Lagos was about taking off.

You and I know that the quality of education in Nigeria has dropped so dramatically that many universities in the world have to put Nigerian graduates through the third degree to give them admission for postgraduate studies. You and I know that in terms of health care, the average Nigerian in the 1960s lived to be nearly 60 years old, today an average Nigerian who lives to be 45 years old is lucky because we know that life expectancy in Nigeria has been dropping since the last decade and a half or so such that today, it is about 45 years. But in the United Kingdom every year, for the last 100 years, life expectancy has been increasing continuously. Something is wrong with the way we organise our society; something is wrong with our politics.

Last year, the US intelligence community predicted that Nigeria was on its way to being a failed state. The international comment on Nigeria is that the country is on the way to becoming a failed state and the Nigerian elite did not react except one or two comments that they were not serious. All of us went as if nothing significant had happened, whereas before that, there were series of events pointing to the same thing. There have been such other projections. The truth of the matter, according to Barak Obama, is that the world has completely written Nigeria off. So I asked myself, if my children grow up and Nigeria actually becomes what this people are predicting, what would they think of me? So, for a very selfish reason of at least being able to tell my children with conviction that I did my best to prevent this, I have chosen to get into the so-called murky waters.

What are your goals in politics?

I hope to make a phenomenal difference. First and foremost, I expect that we are going to make Nigerian politics move away from ‘it is my turn’ or ‘I can spend more money than you’ to the politics of ideas. Last year, the Anyam Osigwe Annual Lecture featured Henrique Frenando Cardasso, former President of Brazil. If you remember, what he repeated most during that lecture was ‘ideas’. I shared many things in common with Cardoso, as we are both academics. He was a professor who got fed up with the way things were going in Brazil and went into exile in Chile. While in exile he worked with Economic Relations in Latin America, a part of the thinking group that redefined global structural economics. He is, of course, the father of what many of us who read political science and economics have come across, Tendency Theory or in the US dependistas.

If there is anything that our systems have been hostile to, it has been ideas. Forget that from time to time they put together experts, either by the name Vision 2010, economic team and so on. Ask yourself how strongly those teams of experts believe in their reports? The biggest problem of Nigeria in my opinion is the absence of freedom of expression. This is an irony. If you dare suggest an idea that somebody who has power feels it’s not wholesome, you immediately become an enemy of the state. The moment you take a contrary opinion that their own is not the greatest thing, you become their enemy. I have never been able to understand that. I like people to tear my points of view apart because that is how knowledge grows. You don’t have to attack anybody’s person if you disagree with him. If you just come up with an idea, you immediately become their enemy and I have never understand that.

The only way to do it is by example. As president, you need to subject yourself to scrutiny by ordinary Nigerians through a fortnight town hall meeting with ordinary Nigerians and journalists. It is not the type you meet with selected journalists and shout them down when they say what you don’t want to hear. I want to come to Dugbe market and stand and be asked questions by Nigerians. We have rulers not leaders. I am not different from that ordinary man on the street. I want to be a leader not a ruler, I want to be just that man on the street who has a clear way of how our problems should be solved. I want to inspire that man with my ideas of how to solve our problems. I don’t want to rule, Nigerians don’t need a ruler. We have had enough rulers.

What are your economic programmes?

If I get the ticket of the Action Congress, I will run a true progressive movement and show Nigerians a true example of how to govern. How to govern has been the biggest single problem in Nigeria and it is linked to other problems like unemployment. I have mapped out my vision and agenda. My number-one programme is job creation.

What is your position on the management of our oil revenue and resources?

I have said that the problem with the Nigerian economy is the management of the oil revenue. I have suggested three tranches of use of oil revenue. The first tranche, as I said many years ago, should be $18 benchmark. The Nigerian budget should depend on oil revenue for no more than $18 per barrel. Whenever oil revenue exceeds that border, only $18 can government do their budget on. Everything from $18 to $25 per barrel should go into what we have often talked about; an account that enables you, when there is this gyration, to make up in lean time. You have that second tranche of money to use as stabilisation account. When oil prices fall below $18, projects just collapse as we often experience creating the Dutch disease that we often talk about. Everything between $18 and $25 per barrel should be put in the stabilisation account. That ensures that you have your constant $18 per barrel for your budget from the stabilisation account. When it goes beyond $25, everything goes into the future fund because such benefits belong to all generations of Nigerians. And 40 years from now, the oil might not be there any longer to provide revenue. Besides the fact that it is good economics, it helps you build your absorptive capacity. It helps in building institutional absorptive capacity. The fund could be invested abroad. My position is that we need budget benchmark, stabilisation band and future fund. The fund future can also be used to put infrastructure in place. The future fund ensures that we do not debit the future generation for what they did not consume.

If you are elected president, what would be your approach to tackling corruption? Would you retain the EFCC and the ICPC? What would be your own approach?

There are two major kinds of institutions required in fighting corruption. One is the institution of horizontal accountability and the other is the institution of vertical accountability. Institutions of horizontal accountability like the EFCC and the ICPC are very important institutions. As a president, if Nuhu Ribadu wants to stay on the job, I will retain him.

The biggest missing link is that the Nigerian people do not matter to the leadership. Politicians go there and at the end of four years, the people’s votes don’t count. The biggest corruption is electoral corruption; nothing gets worse than stealing the people’s votes. The whole system is corrupt when we hold elections after elections that have been remarkably fraudulent. It is from that level of corruption that you go to the other levels of corruption. One of the most powerful tools, besides the horizontal and vertical accountability which is related to vertical accountability, is the power of personal example.

User Avatar
FjordFjord is offline

 # 5 | 17.11.2006 03:04


What is your position on the management of our oil revenue and resources?

I have said that the problem with the Nigerian economy is the management of the oil revenue. I have suggested three tranches of use of oil revenue. The first tranche, as I said many years ago, should be $18 benchmark.....



One'll suppose this interview was conducted quite a while ago; $25/barrel oil has been history for quite a long while...

.

User Avatar
salstepsalstep is offline

 # 6 | 17.11.2006 08:02

Like i said on a previous post, when my Granma in the village start telling me she is voting for Utomi then i will start to believe in Him.

User Avatar
ExxcuzmeExxcuzme is offline

 # 7 | 17.11.2006 16:17

If Mr. Utomi can persuade INEC to make available voting registration or find a way to maket registration of voters accessible and transparent, I will take him and his fellow progressive serious.
 

Services : E-mail news | RSS Feeds | Podcasts
Links:   About the NVS | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies | Advertise With Us
All Rights Reserved. NigeriaVillageSquare.com